Wine Country — After downtown's Super Lounge arcade won approval in a single cycle, four wineries filed to reopen as arcades with cabernet. Their 1984 use permits capped visitors at two a week, and arcades have no cap.
Napa County's use permits, first issued in 1984, do not define what a winery visitor is, what a tasting is, or what a visitor is permitted to do with a glass of cabernet once they have been seated. Planning staff said the question had been raised in a meeting of the Planning Commission, which entered its third hour without a ruling and adjourned to a Tuesday. Applicants told the commission that their proposed cave tours should be classified as a side-scrolling level. The applications describe the cave as "a single continuous corridor with one checkpoint," and the pouring station as a "save point." One applicant filed a tasting as "continue, 1 credit."
The applicants declined to explain the credit system. A representative for one of the four wineries said the arcade classification "gives us room to breathe," then asked that the remainder of the call be treated as off the record.
Quote
“Arcades do not need a definition of public play. Everyone already knows what it means.”
Marguerite Ostendorf-Vale, a retired up-valley resident, submitted a handwritten letter opposing all four applications. The letter ran eleven pages and included exhibits labeled A through G. Exhibit C is the 1984 Summit Lake permit, which estimated two visitors a week. Exhibit F is a photocopy of a sign that reads "seated, by appointment." She asked the commission to explain why an arcade, which has no cap, required no hearing, while a tasting room with a cap required three.
The county has told federal court it has no written definition of "public tasting." The hearing in Hoopes v. County of Napa is scheduled for November 20, 2026. The county attorney has asked to borrow the arcade reasoning for the argument.
The county has told federal court it has no written definition of "public tasting." It has no definition of "private tasting" either. It has filed the arcade classification with the state. ■