OpinionNov 16, 20262 min read
SatireAsk the Sommelier: My Wine Club Ended, Am I Still Loved
Wine Country — A Windsor reader asks why her Sonoma-Cutrer membership became a SKU. The sommelier advises seeing other labels.
The sommelier, who has written this column for eleven years from a converted barn outside Windsor, began her reply by thanking the reader for her membership, which she described as "a real and generous commitment to the idea of Sonoma-Cutrer." She then addressed the central question directly. "You are not being replaced," she wrote. "You are being reclassified." Under the new ownership, she explained, the club has been moved from the Heritage tier to the Portfolio tier, a category that does not include a tasting room, a pickup date, or a named host. Her letter-writer's bottles, she noted, will now ship from a fulfillment center in Sacramento, where a team of three people has been trained to say the word "Sonoma" without looking up.
Quote
“It's not you. It's the three-tier system.”
Why this lands
The three-tier system is the state's law separating producers, distributors and retailers. Here it is offered as a breakup line.
The column's second half walked the reader through the logic of a wine club no longer owned by the people who founded it. Duckhorn Portfolio, now part of Butterfly Equity, paid just under $2 billion for the company in 2024. Since then, its Sonoma-Cutrer tasting room in Windsor has closed, and the club's pickup schedule has been folded into a regional allocation that the sommelier described as "thoughtfully optimized." When asked by a reader whether the club would survive, she answered that the company's chief executive, Hanson, had recently called tasting rooms "loss generating," and that the reader should not take this personally. "He isn't talking about you," she wrote. "He's talking about the room."
The sommelier closed with three recommendations, each more specific than the last. The reader should, she said, "explore labels outside your current ownership structure," should consider a Santa Rosa bottle shop where the staff can name the grower, and should accept that the club's final shipment would arrive on a Tuesday, unannounced, in a box that says "Valued Portfolio Member." She said the reader would know it was over when a mailer arrived inviting her to "concentrate on where growth will come from." The reader, a retired schoolteacher, wrote back the next morning to ask where growth would come from. The sommelier did not reply. She was, a note at the bottom of the column explained, "at a Duckhorn-adjacent tasting, by appointment only." ■