Healdsburg Offers to Move Street Two Minutes Closer
AI illustration
Wine Country — With SMART deciding the station site in December, the city proposed relocating the street itself to end a fight over a five-versus-seven-minute walk. Cloverdale, promised a train in 2008, asked to be moved closer to Healdsburg.
A preliminary feasibility memo filed with the city clerk on Tuesday proposes relocating a 0.3-mile segment of Hudson Street roughly 180 feet east, a distance the memo's authors described as "about the length of a Saturday line outside the Plaza tasting rooms." The city's public works department estimates the move would take 14 months and cost less than the city has spent since 2008 on consultants to explain why the station can't be placed on Hudson Street. Mayor Chris Herrod, who has placed the walk from the depot to the Plaza at five minutes and the walk from Vine Street at seven, said the proposal "reflects a creative commitment to the rail corridor." Asked whether the street could be moved without moving the buildings along it, the city said the question was "under review."
Vine Street residents responded within 48 hours with a counter-proposal to relocate the depot building itself, a structure the neighborhood association described as "already very close to Vine Street in spirit." The association's filing included a sketch of the depot on rollers and a request that the train be asked to stop at the new location, which it cannot, because the train has not yet arrived. Councilmember Ariel Kelley, the lone council voice for Vine, said she had "no objection to moving things" but wanted it noted that the depot has been standing for over a century and the tracks have been standing for about 18 minutes shorter than the plan. Ryan Alsop, Napa County's chief executive, reached for comment about the regional precedent, declined, and forwarded a link to a 2019 transit study.
Crews test the Hudson Street relocation rig on Tuesday, the first stage of the two-minute shift.
The town of Windsor, which already has a SMART station and a platform that has rarely been crowded, submitted a letter offering to lend its station to Healdsburg on weekends. The letter, signed by a Windsor transit liaison whose title was given as Interim Coordinator for Regional Rail Adjacency, proposed that Healdsburg riders "simply treat Windsor as a sister station" and walk the remaining distance on a shared path. The letter did not say how long the path would take. The Healdsburg Plaza, where the train was promised in the 2008 ballot language, is 30 miles north of Windsor's current platform. The Mill District, which has a planned mixed-use parcel near the depot, was not mentioned.
Cloverdale, the northernmost stop on the corridor and the only town promised a station in the original 2008 measure, filed a letter asking that its planned terminal be relocated closer to Healdsburg. The letter, which cited the 2008 vote in which 69.5 percent of county voters approved the tax, asked the transportation authority to "consider the spirit of the corridor" and reduce the distance between the two towns to something a person could walk before lunch. Voters approved the tax on Nov. 4, 2008. The corridor's nine-mile extension broke ground in March 2026 at a cost of $269 million, with service targeted for 2028. Cloverdale remains planned. It is not yet funded. Its counter, the clock on its town website, has been running since the vote. It now reads 18 years. ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.