Pied-à-Terre Owners Sue to Prove Apartment Is Their Home, Not Their Home
Manhattan — Wilbur Ross and Steve Wynn's suit against the city's pied-à-terre surcharge argues the tax targets people who live elsewhere, a position their own apartments have held since move-in. Pemberton Asch of the Fifty-Seventh Street Residents' Association filed a supporting statement on behalf of 220 Central Park South's 14th floor, which he said has been 'tenanted continuously by the idea of a tenant.'
The statement, filed Thursday in Staten Island Supreme Court, asks the court to find that the 14th floor at 220 Central Park South is a residence because its owner has, in the association's words, 'maintained a durable and sincere relationship to its kitchen.' The kitchen was not photographed. Asch told a reporter by phone that the association did not believe an inspection would add anything the statement did not already establish. Pied-à-terre surcharge exemptions turn on whether an owner's primary residence is elsewhere, and the plaintiffs' own argument rests on that question: their brief says the tax penalizes owners who live outside the city, which requires showing they live outside the city. Asch's statement is the first document in the case to describe a Manhattan apartment as a place someone is from. Three other owners' filings in the same case cite a residence in Connecticut, Florida or London. None of them lists a New York City address for service of process.
The city's response, filed by the Law Department, observed that the suit's central claim is that the surcharge 'targets owners who live outside the city.' The response said that is the definition of the tax. Justice Wayne Ozzi found the city's notices arbitrary and capricious on Sept. 29, a ruling the appeals court has since put on hold. About 17,000 owners received notices, roughly 9,300 filed for exemption, and more than 5,200 were approved. The plaintiffs' lawyers have asked the court to treat the 220 Central Park South penthouse, which closed at $238 million in 2019, as a place to stay when its owner is in town. Asked whether the owner would attend the hearing, a spokesperson for the plaintiffs said the owner would participate 'remotely from the residence he is most closely associated with,' and declined to name it. The Law Department's filing requests that the court ask the same question of everyone who signs an affidavit. Pemberton Asch's association has asked to be heard on the question.
Justice Ozzi, in a scheduling order issued Friday, asked counsel to identify which of the named plaintiffs would appear in person at the next hearing and where each would be physically located during it. Counsel for Wilbur Ross and Steve Wynn said the plaintiffs' interests were being represented by the association. Asch confirmed the association would appear 'in spirit and by statement.' The order gave the parties until Oct. 13 to provide a service address within the city. None was provided. The plaintiffs' exemption deadline was extended to the same date, and the city says its bills, due Jan. 1, will be issued to owners based on the same residency records now under review. Comptroller Brad Lander's office projects the surcharge will raise between $340 million and $380 million, against the city's $500 million estimate. The gap, a city spokesperson said, is 'the distance between where people say they live and where they receive their mail.'
Asch, the association's Vice President for Lobby Experience, said in a written statement that the 14th-floor apartment 'has been tenanted continuously by the idea of a tenant,' and that the association's members consider the unit a home in every sense the tax code does not recognize. He said he had not personally been inside the building since 2019, when the association's annual meeting was held in a conference room on the ground floor, and that he did not expect to be asked to return. Asked to describe the apartment's furniture, Asch said the association would prefer to describe its value. The filing lists the apartment's occupant as 'a person of substance,' and its primary residence as 'a feeling of permanence in a place that stays lit from the street.' The city's Department of Finance has asked the association to clarify whether the unit's light is on a timer.
The court has set a hearing for Jan. 4, the first business day after bills are due. The Law Department has asked that all affidavits in the case include a sworn statement of where the signer sleeps. Two plaintiffs' affidavits say they sleep in Manhattan, one says it depends on the season, and Asch's affidavit describes his residence as 'the building,' without an address or a unit number. Asked whether the association would send a representative to the hearing, Asch said the association was 'considering its footprint.' The Staten Island courtroom is 45 minutes from the nearest Manhattan subway stop. The association's own bylaws, which it provided to the court, require members to attend meetings in person within the city limits. The bylaws were filed as an exhibit to the statement about the apartment's residence, and the court has not yet ruled on whether they count as a primary document.
A spokesperson for the Fifty-Seventh Street Residents' Association said the tax 'does not reflect how people in Midtown actually live,' and that residents of the district were being penalized for having 'a sense of place that the city cannot audit.' The association has asked the court to consider a second exhibit, a letter from its Community Board 13 committee opposing the surcharge on the grounds that the tax 'does not account for the building as it was originally envisioned.' The committee has opposed every structure above six stories since 1961, including the ones already standing. It has not yet been asked to comment on whether any of its members live in those buildings. Asch's apartment, the association's filing says, will be 'reviewed for residency upon the next reasonable opportunity,' which the association defined as any day that is not a Tuesday.
The owners suing over the surcharge must prove, to win, that they live somewhere else, which is the exact fact the tax exists to measure. The suit's plaintiffs have not disputed that the penthouse at 220 Central Park South is occupied only when its owner is in town. They have only disputed the bill that follows from that fact. On Jan. 1 the city will mail the invoices, and on Jan. 4 the court will ask who is coming to the hearing. The apartment on the 14th floor will be taxed, it has been reported, at the rate for a home its owner keeps elsewhere. Asch's association has been asked whether its members will be present for either date. It has replied that it has not yet determined where it is. ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.
Who actually pays the pied-à-terre surcharge, and how does the city decide which home is primary?Get the straight answer →

