Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Lease Watch

Manhattan's 1.55 Percent Vacancy Rate Excludes Ground Floors, Brokers Clarify

A long stretch of Broadway on Manhattan's Upper West Side where every ground-floor storefront is papered over and dark while every apartment window above glows with lamps and moving boxes, a broker locking yet another empty shop door.AI illustration

— Manhattan's record-low vacancy rate counts only above the lobby, excluding ground floors. The Broadway storefronts vacancy rate on the street level tells a different story.

Brokers working the Upper West Side and Midtown said Thursday that the figure is accurate, but that it measures only residential units above the ground floor, and that the street-level storefronts along Broadway between 59th and 110th Streets belong to a separate category. Asked what the separate category was called, Dana Prill, Vice President of Commercial Classification at the Manhattan Residential and Commercial Brokers Council, said the term was "pre-leased to an idea."

The Council said it had issued the clarification after reporters asked why a block could report near-zero vacancy and also have a dark storefront every few doors. Prill said the two facts were "not in conflict, only in different spreadsheets." The West Side Rag's annual count of the strip found 59th through 110th Street lined with closed or interim-use frontage, the paper reported, with managing editor Gus Saltonstall describing the walk as "a long afternoon."

The Council's guidance, circulated to member firms Wednesday, lists seven classifications for ground-floor space. Under "interim vision," it counts smoke shops, which it describes as "active curatorial occupancies." Under "flex two," a term the Council did not define, it counts storefronts with a temporary wall and a permanent rent. A spokesperson for a Broadway landlord said the approach "reflects how the street is actually being used," and declined to specify which uses.

The guidance does not address upstairs. There, the median asking rent in Manhattan reached a record $5,099 in April, according to the listings tracker, which counted 4,766 available units citywide. The Council said upstairs and downstairs were "measured on different days."

Comparison

Broadway Street Level, 59th to 110th, as Classified

CountNote
VacantNot countedRecategorized as pre-leased to an idea
Flex twoCountedPermanent rent, temporary wall
Interim visionCountedSmoke shop; "active curatorial occupancy"
Open to the publicRecorded in errorCorrected
Quote

We are not in the business of telling people what their storefront is for. We are in the business of telling them what their apartment costs.”

Dana Prill
Asked whether a dark storefront counts toward the borough's vacancy rate, at a press briefing at the Council's offices on West 57th Street.

Fox 5 sent a camera crew to the strip Thursday to film the count, which it did from the only open storefront between 96th and 97th Streets, a smoke shop. The shop's manager said the crew had been there for two hours and had bought nothing, and that the shop was "technically the vacancy rate's most reliable tenant."The West Side Rag's count is expected next week. Saltonstall said the paper would count all frontage it could see from the sidewalk and would list each one under its own name, "which is more than the brokers have done for us." The Council said it would issue a further clarification once the count is published. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

why are there so many empty storefronts on the upper west side?Get the straight answer →

More from Manhattan

Manhattan front page
Manhattan
Centre Street
Seven Barn Owls Safe, Manhattan Housing Still Not

All seven Upper West Side water tower barn owls were accounted for after a roof removal and a new DEC nest box. They will be offered a market-rate lease.

Related: The $5,099 median: rent in a borough with a 1.55% vacancy rate
Manhattan
The Park and the Row
Pied-à-Terre Owners Sue to Prove Apartment Is Their Home, Not Their Home

Wilbur Ross and Steve Wynn's suit against the city's pied-à-terre surcharge argues the tax targets people who live elsewhere, a position their own apartments have held since move-in. Pemberton Asch of the Fifty-Seventh Street Residents' Association filed a supporting statement on behalf of 220 Central Park South's 14th floor, which he said has been 'tenanted continuously by the idea of a tenant.'

Related: The $5,099 median: rent in a borough with a 1.55% vacancy rate
Manhattan
The Park and the Row
Upper West Side Mobilizes for Displaced Family After Confirming They Are Owls

Seven barn owls lost their nest atop 15 West 75th Street on Oct. 29, and the Manhattan Borough President called it "illegal." A block association that has fought every shelter since 2020 offered the owlets its guest rooms.

Related: East Side, West Side: sixty years of arguing which side of the park is the liberal one, settled by precinct
Manhattan
The Street
Socialists Pray for Wall Street Bonuses

The average 2025 Wall Street bonus was $246,900, and the securities industry produced 19.4 percent of New York State tax collections. Members prayed at the Charging Bull for a 10 percent pool and asked that nobody tell the chapter.

Nearby in Manhattan
Manhattan
The Great White Way
Broadway Killed Times Square Casino Over Fear Tourists Might Win

The Broadway League helped sink the $5.4 billion Caesars Times Square bid, then grossed a record $1.91 billion on fewer seats. A producer said the difference is that at a casino, nobody makes you stand and applaud after you lose.

Nearby in Manhattan
Manhattan
Below 60th
Justice Department Calls $9 Toll a Situationship

In its Second Circuit brief, the Justice Department says federal highway officials may revoke the toll's approval at any time. The MTA, which netted $468 million in ten months, said it was not ready to define the relationship.

Nearby in Manhattan
ManhattanNew York City

A $5,099 median rent, a $246,900 median bonus, a borough president with a letterhead.

Manhattan front page
Satire

The Manhattan paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting and filed from a flex two-bedroom below 96th Street. Everyone quoted is made up, the real officials' included, and the rent really is $5,099.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.