Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Opinion

Upper West Side Finally Admits It Is Only Progressive Above 86th Street

— Zohran Mamdani carried 87th to 110th and Andrew Cuomo carried everything south of it, a split the neighborhood's block associations called 'unexpectedly geographic.' Zabar's said its smoked-fish line remained non-partisan.

The Upper West Side Community Association voted 14-2 on Tuesday to adopt a formal liberalism boundary along West 86th Street, effective immediately, after a precinct-level review found that residents above the line had voted in lockstep while residents directly below it had not. The association's Vice President for Civic Identity, Gordon Feller, said the rule was necessary to end what he called "a decade of people on 85th Street saying they were progressive while parking in the bike lane." Under the new standard, any resident residing south of 86th who displays a pro-Mamdani sign will be asked to remove it or pay a $40 administrative surcharge, which will be deposited into the association's Sidewalk Sincerity Fund. Two members of the board abstained, citing the Rag's endorsement of a 79th Street dog run as evidence that the line was drawn in the wrong place.

A companion measure extends the surcharge to Central Park West between 59th and 67th Streets, where the association determined that buildings facing the park were "functionally Upper East Side" despite their western address. Property managers along the stretch said the fee would be collected through the building's existing quarterly maintenance statement, itemized as "Ideological Proximity Adjustment." A doorman at a 64th Street building, who asked not to be named because he lives above 86th, said residents had already begun reclassifying their own apartments as "transitional." Zabar's, at Broadway and 80th, declined to comment on whether its smoked-fish counter fell under the new rule, saying only that the line remained non-partisan.

Comparison

Precinct Returns, Official Association Summary

MamdaniCuomoAssociation Ruling
UWS, 87th and aboveLiberalWithdrawnLiberal
UWS, 85th and belowParked in bike laneUnclearUnder review
UES, 68th to 69th, Second to ThirdNot applicableNot applicableMapped as Cuomo

The association's Traffic and Principles Committee adopted a crosswalk standard requiring pedestrians crossing at 86th Street to indicate their party affiliation through a designated hand signal, with red-hand signals reserved for voters north of the line. A committee member, Ruth Oberholtzer, said the rule would prevent the "accidental solidarity" that occurs when residents of the East and West Sides cross paths near the Museum Mile and are forced to acknowledge each other. Crossing guards have been issued laminated cards listing the approved gestures. The M86 crosstown bus, which the Rag described as the only diplomatic channel between the two sides, has been designated a neutral zone and will continue to stop at 86th without taking a position.

Upper East Side residents, who voted for Andrew Cuomo by 24 points, said they had been watching the West Side's reorganization with interest but no particular envy. A resident of 78th Street between FDR and York, who has voted for Mamdani in every election since 2021, said her block's rule is simpler: the crosstown bus is for transit, not for taking sides. "We were never liberal," she said. "We were just on the right side of the avenue." Zabar's, which stands at 80th Street, has not indicated which side of the line it is on, and is said to be considering a third wall. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Where exactly does the Upper West Side's liberalism end, and who decides?Get the straight answer →

More from Manhattan

Manhattan front page
Manhattan
Lease Watch
Manhattan's 1.55 Percent Vacancy Rate Excludes Ground Floors, Brokers Clarify

Manhattan's record-low vacancy rate counts only above the lobby, excluding ground floors. The Broadway storefronts vacancy rate on the street level tells a different story.

Related: East Side, West Side: sixty years of arguing which side of the park is the liberal one, settled by precinct
Manhattan
The Park and the Row
Upper West Side Mobilizes for Displaced Family After Confirming They Are Owls

Seven barn owls lost their nest atop 15 West 75th Street on Oct. 29, and the Manhattan Borough President called it "illegal." A block association that has fought every shelter since 2020 offered the owlets its guest rooms.

Related: East Side, West Side: sixty years of arguing which side of the park is the liberal one, settled by precinct
Manhattan
Opinion
Area Man Opts In to Salad, Out of Bin

A Midtown worker asked the bodega cat to sign for his $20 salad. The bodega said the cat is not legal.

More from Opinion
Manhattan
Opinion
I Know the Bronx From 6,000 Drives Through It

The Cross Bronx Expressway carries more than 200,000 vehicles a day, and since 2004 one of them has been my Lexus. The borough has really improved, judging by the retaining walls, and I have never once needed to get out.

More from Opinion
Manhattan
The Street
Socialists Pray for Wall Street Bonuses

The average 2025 Wall Street bonus was $246,900, and the securities industry produced 19.4 percent of New York State tax collections. Members prayed at the Charging Bull for a 10 percent pool and asked that nobody tell the chapter.

Nearby in Manhattan
Manhattan
The Great White Way
Broadway Killed Times Square Casino Over Fear Tourists Might Win

The Broadway League helped sink the $5.4 billion Caesars Times Square bid, then grossed a record $1.91 billion on fewer seats. A producer said the difference is that at a casino, nobody makes you stand and applaud after you lose.

Nearby in Manhattan
ManhattanNew York City

A $5,099 median rent, a $246,900 median bonus, a borough president with a letterhead.

Manhattan front page
Satire

The Manhattan paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting and filed from a flex two-bedroom below 96th Street. Everyone quoted is made up, no real official is quoted, and the rent really is $5,099.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.