Manhattan — In its Second Circuit brief, the Justice Department says federal highway officials may revoke the toll's approval at any time. The MTA, which netted $468 million in ten months, said it was not ready to define the relationship.
A Justice Department attorney read the government's appellate brief aloud Tuesday on the steps of the Thurgood Marshall federal courthouse, pausing only to let a reporter from the New York Post copy the sentence that begins "The government must be empowered." The attorney, who asked not to be named because the brief was not yet public, said the document had been drafted over four months by a team that reviewed 214 prior filings to determine how the department should describe its relationship with the congestion toll. The team concluded it should describe the toll as a relationship. "We considered 'partnership' and 'collaboration,'" the attorney said. "Those implied a shared calendar. This is not that."
Definition
An approval granted in 2024, withdrawn by letter in 2025, restored by a district judge in March 2026, and appealed in June because the government 'must be empowered to adjust to changing circumstances or to changed priorities.'
Interview Transcript
JUDGE:
[long pause] Counsel for the government, did the approval mean anything?
GOVERNMENT COUNSEL:
[adjusts papers] It meant something at the time, Your Honor.
JUDGE:
Something specific?
GOVERNMENT COUNSEL:
It meant yes, until the agency determined otherwise.
MTA COUNSEL:
[slides binder across the table] Your Honor, the record reflects $468 million in net revenue over ten months and an 11 percent reduction in vehicle entries below 60th Street. We would describe the relationship as functional.
GOVERNMENT COUNSEL:
We never said it was exclusive.
JUDGE:
Counsel, the approval was in writing.
GOVERNMENT COUNSEL:
[long pause] Writing is a starting point, Your Honor. We are not in a position to define the terms going forward.
The Second Circuit has not scheduled a ruling. The government's brief argues the case belongs in the Court of Federal Claims, a forum that handles money disputes, which the department described as 'the cleaner of the two options.' Judge Lewis Liman, who ruled in March that the federal bid to end the toll was arbitrary and capricious and vacated the rescission letters, is not on the panel. Sean Duffy's letters remain in the record, along with the approval they tried to undo. Nobody at the Transportation Department has been reached to say which of the two was the mood.
How the Relationship Has Progressed
🚗Jan 5, 2025
$9 at peak hours, every vehicle below 60th Street, no exceptions for anyone with a plan.
✉️Feb 2025
The federal government declares it dead
Rescission letters arrive. The approval is over. The toll collects another $9 the following morning.
⚖️Mar 2026
Judge rules the rescission arbitrary and capricious
The letters are vacated. The relationship is, legally speaking, back on.
📎Jun 2026
The administration appeals the restoration. The toll keeps collecting.
📄Nov 11, 2026
Brief argues the case belongs in the Court of Federal Claims
The government asks that the question of whether it meant it be reassigned to a court with the word 'claims' in its name.
Asked whether the MTA would continue collecting the toll while the appeal is pending, spokesperson Teodora Vance said the agency was 'not ready to define the relationship' and would keep collecting $9 at the gantry until it was. Asked what that meant for the 60th Street commuter who has paid the toll 300 times and has never once been told where things stand, Vance said the agency 'values that commuter's patience.' Twelve lawsuits have targeted the program. None has stopped the toll. The approval remains on the books, which is the only thing either side has agreed to. ■