Manhattan — The borough president's advisory opinion on the Penn Station plan arrived at the master developer's office three weeks after the lease was signed. Dana Prill, the borough president's Deputy Director of Message Discipline, said the letter had been 'reviewed by everyone with a vote and no one with a hammer.'
The borough president's office said Thursday that the letter will remain in the project file indefinitely, where it will be described as advisory. Asked whether the developer had been required to wait for the recommendation before beginning demolition, Prill said the office 'does not comment on sequencing.' Neither the federal government nor the master developer has scheduled a public hearing. The office has asked that the letter be read at the next meeting of Manhattan Community Board 13, which has not yet met to discuss anything built above six stories since 2019, including several that now have windows.Hoylman-Sigal's office first objected publicly on June 7, when he stood outside Madison Square Garden on Eighth Avenue and called the plan a land grab. The objection was then joined by a letter from Representative Jerry Nadler and state Senator Erik Bottcher, which said the master developer had been selected without a request for proposals, cost estimates or hearings. The letter was filed with the federal project team in the ordinary way. It arrived after the permit. ■
Quote
“We've reviewed it with everyone who has a vote and no one who has a hammer.”
The Advisory Process, As Filed
📣June 7
Press conference outside the Garden
The borough president calls the plan a land grab. Nadler and Bottcher's joint objection follows the next day.
📎Post-letter
Letter filed with the federal project team
Recommendation logged as advisory. No hearing date set.
🏗️Post-permit
Letter arrives after the demolition permit
The office says it will remain in the project file, forever advisory.
🗓️Next winter
Community Board 13 receives an extended application deadline
The board has not yet reviewed the plan. The deadline is the one thing it has reviewed.