Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Centre Street

Hoylman-Sigal Issues Strongly Worded Recommendation to Federal Government Already Finished Building Penn Station

— The borough president's advisory opinion on the Penn Station plan arrived at the master developer's office three weeks after the lease was signed. Dana Prill, the borough president's Deputy Director of Message Discipline, said the letter had been 'reviewed by everyone with a vote and no one with a hammer.'

The borough president's office said Thursday that the letter will remain in the project file indefinitely, where it will be described as advisory. Asked whether the developer had been required to wait for the recommendation before beginning demolition, Prill said the office 'does not comment on sequencing.' Neither the federal government nor the master developer has scheduled a public hearing. The office has asked that the letter be read at the next meeting of Manhattan Community Board 13, which has not yet met to discuss anything built above six stories since 2019, including several that now have windows.Hoylman-Sigal's office first objected publicly on June 7, when he stood outside Madison Square Garden on Eighth Avenue and called the plan a land grab. The objection was then joined by a letter from Representative Jerry Nadler and state Senator Erik Bottcher, which said the master developer had been selected without a request for proposals, cost estimates or hearings. The letter was filed with the federal project team in the ordinary way. It arrived after the permit. 

Quote

We've reviewed it with everyone who has a vote and no one who has a hammer.”

Dana Prill, Deputy Director of Message Discipline, Manhattan Borough President's Office
Statement to reporters outside One Centre Street, Thursday

The Advisory Process, As Filed

📣June 7
Press conference outside the Garden
The borough president calls the plan a land grab. Nadler and Bottcher's joint objection follows the next day.
📎Post-letter
Letter filed with the federal project team
Recommendation logged as advisory. No hearing date set.
🏗️Post-permit
Letter arrives after the demolition permit
The office says it will remain in the project file, forever advisory.
🗓️Next winter
Community Board 13 receives an extended application deadline
The board has not yet reviewed the plan. The deadline is the one thing it has reviewed.

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

What does a borough president's advisory recommendation actually do?Get the straight answer →

More from Manhattan

Manhattan front page
Manhattan
The Street
Socialists Pray for Wall Street Bonuses

The average 2025 Wall Street bonus was $246,900, and the securities industry produced 19.4 percent of New York State tax collections. Members prayed at the Charging Bull for a 10 percent pool and asked that nobody tell the chapter.

Nearby in Manhattan
Manhattan
The Great White Way
Broadway Killed Times Square Casino Over Fear Tourists Might Win

The Broadway League helped sink the $5.4 billion Caesars Times Square bid, then grossed a record $1.91 billion on fewer seats. A producer said the difference is that at a casino, nobody makes you stand and applaud after you lose.

Nearby in Manhattan
Manhattan
Below 60th
Justice Department Calls $9 Toll a Situationship

In its Second Circuit brief, the Justice Department says federal highway officials may revoke the toll's approval at any time. The MTA, which netted $468 million in ten months, said it was not ready to define the relationship.

Nearby in Manhattan
Manhattan
The Dinosaurs
Paleontologists Declare 45 Park Place Tribeca's Most Complete Dinosaur Skeleton

The Nov. 10 Dinosaurs of Tribeca list again ranks 45 Park Place worst, a "rotting hulk" with its crane still up. The dig team recovered a crane, an inspection sticker and what commenters call a bankruptcy still in progress.

Nearby in Tribeca
Manhattan
Canal Street
Counterfeit Crackdown Seizes Fake Tribeca Apartments South of Chambers Street

Realtors have pushed Tribeca south to Vesey or Murray Street, and Google Maps showed Vesey as its border in January 2025. Officers working Canal Street seized 40 listings stitched with the Tribeca name and left the handbags alone.

Nearby in Tribeca
Manhattan
The Fortress
Bogardus Plaza Kiosk Asks Fourth Tenant to Submit Obituary With Application

The Bogardus Plaza kiosk has lost three tenants since 2023, and its owners are drafting a request for proposals for a fourth. Applicants must state their cause of death in advance, with "about a year" preferred.

Nearby in Tribeca
ManhattanNew York City

A $5,099 median rent, a $246,900 median bonus, a borough president with a letterhead.

Manhattan front page
Satire

The Manhattan paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting and filed from a flex two-bedroom below 96th Street. Everyone quoted is made up, no real official is quoted, and the rent really is $5,099.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.