Poisonal
Poisonal
Opinion

Man Who Loves Animals Clarifies He Means Four of Them

At a backyard cookout in suburban Texas, a smiling man in an apron cradles a small dog in one arm while turning a whole roasting pig on a spit with the other, neighbours holding out paper plates.AI illustration

— Asked at a backyard cookout to clarify, the self-described animal lover named dogs, cats, horses and dolphins, and flipped another burger. A pig has appealed the decision and been told the list closes at dinner.

Doug Mercer, a regional sales manager in Newark, Ohio, told guests that dolphins made the list after a 2019 cruise out of Port Canaveral, during which one of them looked right at him. Horses qualified on the strength of two encounters, both at a fence.

Asked by neighbor Paula Reyes about pigs, Mercer said pigs were more of a food. He then asked that the list be put in writing, to avoid confusion at future gatherings. His wife took it down on the back of a paper plate as he dictated from the grill.

The Mercer List
as dictated at the grill, recorded on a paper plate
Dog
loved
lives here, has a stocking
Cat
loved
sister has two
Horse
loved
seen at a fence, twice
Dolphin
loved
the cruise
Cow
medium
on the grill now
Chicken
Sunday
in the cooler, marinating
Pig
closes at dinner
appeal on file
Turkey
November
seasonal

Reyes pointed out that a 2015 review in the International Journal of Comparative Psychology found pigs comparable to dogs on several cognitive measures. Mercer thanked her and had the plate turned over. Under a new heading, Things He Does Not Mean, his wife wrote clever. A guest's follow-up about feelings added a second entry.

Mercer then plated a cheeseburger for Biscuit, his nine-year-old Labrador, who has a chair.

"I only asked what he meant," Reyes said. "Ground beef is $6.79 a pound and he gave one to the dog."

The list is in line with national practice. Americans spent a record $158 billion on pets in 2025, according to the American Pet Products Association, and the USDA projects a record 59.5 pounds of beef per person in 2026.

"Those are the same households," said Carol Benton, deputy director of pet sentiment analysis at the association. "People have never loved animals more, and the ones they love have never eaten better. We were not asked to count the others."

Before the plates were cleared, Mercer passed his phone around the table so guests could sign a petition to save a red panda at a zoo he has not visited. The list closed at dinner. Octopuses were considered and eaten. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Are pigs really as smart as dogs, and why do Americans treat some animals as family and others as food?Get the straight answer →

More from United States

United States front page
United States
The Acting Cabinet
Dick Cheney's Ghost Says Iran War Is the One He Meant

Dick Cheney's ghost said the Iran war was the plan all along and Iraq was a one-letter typo. Oil sits about 30% above its prewar price, and JD Vance says the war is why Republicans lost.

Related: Affordability: the word of the year, every year
United States
The Statute Shuffle
Federal Reserve Holds Draft Lottery for Unemployment

Federal Reserve governors drew birthdays from a glass drum to choose which Americans lose their jobs to bring 3.7% inflation down. Deferments were granted to anyone who owns stocks, which rallied on the news.

Related: Affordability: the word of the year, every year
United States
Opinion
Couple Calling Baby the Best Thing That Ever Happened to Them Blinks Twice

At their daughter's first birthday, a couple told relatives parenthood was the best thing that ever happened to them, blinking twice. A childless cousin who blinked back was handed the baby and has not been seen at a brunch since.

More from Opinion
United States
Opinion
I'm a Baby Monkey, and Even I Got Over My IKEA Orangutan

Punch, a baby macaque at Japan's Ichikawa City Zoo, needed his IKEA plush orangutan less as he settled in. He writes that your friend, three years into texting a man whose job is founder, could do the same.

More from Opinion
United States
Continuing Resolution
ICE Agrees to Body Cameras if the Cameras Can Also Wear Masks

ICE accepted the body-camera demand from the 76-day Department of Homeland Security shutdown, provided each camera is issued a neck gaiter. The footage will be released once the cameras feel safe being identified.

Nearby in United States
United States
The Bill Comes Due
Anthropic Unable to Warn Public of AI Takeover During IPO Quiet Period

Anthropic, filing to raise up to $64.4 billion, said SEC quiet-period rules bar it from warning anyone about an AI takeover. Its lawyers cleared one statement: the next six to twelve months involve risks and uncertainties.

Nearby in United States
United States

Three tariff laws, two shutdowns, one $40 trillion tab, and the gas was supposed to be $2.99.

United States front page
Satire

The United States paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on the public record. Every quote is made up, the real ones included, the swing voter is invented, and the debt is the only number we couldn't make bigger.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.