Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Opinion

Op-Ed: My Family Needs an Entire Commercial Building

A single child's tricycle parked alone in the middle of a cavernous empty former warehouse floor in Tribeca, columns stretching into the distance.AI illustration

— An unnamed future resident of 11 Hubert Street explains why one household requires a pool, a penthouse and a former workplace. The children, he notes, are growing.

The op-ed arrived through a representative. It runs four paragraphs and uses the word modest eleven times. Plans for the address call for converting the commercial building into a single private residence with a pool and a rooftop penthouse.

"The family did look at apartments," said Paul Renner, the household's Director of Residential Communications. "What they found is that apartments tend to come with other people's apartments attached to them."

Renner said the author would remain anonymous because he is a private person, and will shortly be a private block.

Opinion

My Family Needs an Entire Commercial Building

By A Future Resident of 11 Hubert Street
Head of Household

People hear entire commercial building and assume excess. I would ask them to count my family. There are five of us. There is one building. I do not see where the surplus is.

The pool is not a luxury. It is one lap lane, a second lap lane for passing, and a shallow area for a child who has not yet been assigned a lane. The penthouse is a modest rooftop room where a father can go to be above the rest of his house.

Nobody mourns the jobs this building once held more than I do. I toured those offices. I saw the desks. One of them will be kept, in the mudroom, as a tribute to work.

I ask only that neighbors respect the privacy of Hubert Street, which we think of as the front hall. Laight Street is lovely and runs in the same direction.

The household has since written to Community Board 1 asking that the Hubert Street sidewalk be reclassified as a foyer. It has offered to pay for the signage and for a bench on Laight Street where pedestrians may wait to be somewhere else.

Median rent in Tribeca is about $8,300 a month. Denise Kaplan, who rents a one-bedroom two blocks away, said she had read the op-ed twice.

"I pay close to that and I share a wall with a man learning the trumpet," Kaplan said. "This guy gets a floor for each kid's mood."

Renner said the family had heard the concerns and was adding a floor for them.

The design goes before the Landmarks Preservation Commission for review. The family has asked that the commission review it from Laight Street. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Can an entire commercial building in Tribeca really be converted into a single-family home, and who has to approve it?Get the straight answer →

More from Tribeca

Tribeca front page
Tribeca
Frozen Towers
Landmarks Asks Hubert Street Pool to Look More 1890s

Reviewing SPAN Architecture's plan to turn 11 Hubert Street into a single-family home with a swimming pool, commissioners requested the water appear 'historically consistent.' The architect returned with brick-colored water.

Nearby in Tribeca
Tribeca
Opinion
Neighbor Takes Village East's Survival as Personal Win

A Second Avenue resident claims watching Cinema 123 films weekly is his civic duty. He has not enjoyed either.

More from Opinion
Tribeca
Opinion
Restaurant Week Lists 32 UES Establishments, Most of Which Have Decided Full Price Is Enough

Restaurant Week 2026 includes 32 Upper East Side restaurants offering prix fixe menus. A spokesperson said the others "are still deciding."

More from Opinion
Tribeca
Empty Storefronts
Tribeca Brand Licensed to More Shops Than Tribeca Has

Tribeca Pediatrics' growth to 48 locations puts the brand on more doors outside the neighborhood than open shops inside it. Residents now visit Tribeca mainly in New Jersey.

Nearby in Tribeca
Tribeca
Canal Street
Counterfeit Crackdown Seizes Fake Tribeca Apartments South of Chambers Street

Realtors have pushed Tribeca south to Vesey or Murray Street, and Google Maps showed Vesey as its border in January 2025. Officers working Canal Street seized 40 listings stitched with the Tribeca name and left the handbags alone.

Nearby in Tribeca
Tribeca
The Fortress
Bogardus Plaza Kiosk Asks Fourth Tenant to Submit Obituary With Application

The Bogardus Plaza kiosk has lost three tenants since 2023, and its owners are drafting a request for proposals for a fourth. Applicants must state their cause of death in advance, with "about a year" preferred.

Nearby in Tribeca
TribecaManhattan

Ground Zero is four blocks away and the storefronts are still for lease.

Tribeca front page
Satire

The Tribeca paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Every quote is made up, especially the ones from real officials.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.