Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Opinion

Neighbor Takes Village East's Survival as Personal Win

— A Second Avenue resident claims watching Cinema 123 films weekly is his civic duty. He has not enjoyed either.

Gerald Pruitt, 58, a resident of the Second Avenue building across from the theater, said he has attended every Cinema 123 screening since its owners announced the closure, and that he intends to keep attending through the last week of its lease. "Somebody has to," Pruitt said Tuesday, standing outside the box office at Village East by Angelika. "You don't move a movie house out of a neighborhood by letting it sit empty. That's how the paperwork gets done." Pruitt has seen 41 films at the theater since Oct. 30, according to his own tally, which he keeps in a spiral notebook he refers to as the ledger. He said the films were mostly the ones he would have skipped. "I'm not here for the movies. I'm here so the seats are warm when the inspector comes."

Cinema 123 opened in 1962 as the nation's first twin-screen cinema, and its closure has drawn attention from neighbors who had never bought a ticket there. Pruitt said he has sat through a 2:40 p.m. double feature of a film he cannot name, an experience he described as "like being asked to witness a will." Asked whether his attendance has changed the outcome, he said he had not yet been informed. Keith Powers, the Assemblymember for District 74, said his office has received no formal request for preservation funding. Pruitt said he took that as a sign the work was going well.

Pruitt's notebook now runs to four volumes. In each, he has rated the films, the popcorn and the spirit of the lobby, and has written a short assessment of the ceiling. He said the theater's neighbor, Village East by Angelika, remains open and that he has not yet decided whether to extend his loyalty there. "I've checked," he said. "That one's still going. I don't think it needs me. I think it's just doing fine." He added that he would reassess once someone from the building issued a statement. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Does attending a closing movie theater actually help keep it open?Get the straight answer →

More from East Village

East Village front page
East Village
St. Marks Is Dead
St. Marks Place Mourners Accuse Newcomers of Declaring It Dead Wrong

Every generation since the 1950s has declared St. Marks Place dead, and its 1994 mourners say newcomers are doing it wrong. They have asked the city to issue death certificates by year of arrival, with seniority.

Related: The nostalgia economy: CBGB is a clothing store, Gem Spa is a T-shirt, and the festival is in Brooklyn
East Village
Opinion
Op-Ed: My Family Needs an Entire Commercial Building

An unnamed future resident of 11 Hubert Street explains why one household requires a pool, a penthouse and a former workplace. The children, he notes, are growing.

More from Opinion
East Village
Opinion
Restaurant Week Lists 32 UES Establishments, Most of Which Have Decided Full Price Is Enough

Restaurant Week 2026 includes 32 Upper East Side restaurants offering prix fixe menus. A spokesperson said the others "are still deciding."

More from Opinion
East Village
St. Marks Is Dead
St. Marks Place Heritage Authority Certifies Bubble Tea Shop as Formerly Punk

The St. Marks Place Heritage Licensing Authority certified a bubble-tea storefront at 27 St. Mark's Place as 'formerly punk' this week, an honor that comes with an annual fee and has never been granted to a storefront that still is. The certificate is framed beside the Gong Cha sign, which opened in February 2021 across from a Kung Fu Tea.

Related: The nostalgia economy: CBGB is a clothing store, Gem Spa is a T-shirt, and the festival is in Brooklyn
East Village
Sheds & Platforms
Dining Shed Listed as Junior One-Bedroom

Under Local Law 135, a roadway shed may now stay up all winter for a $630 license. The listing asks $3,400 a month, calls the heat lamp "in-unit heat" and the bathroom "the restaurant."

Nearby in East Village
East Village
Under the Berm
Track Lights Letter Gets Its Own 2028 Reopening Date

The Oct. 27 letter from five elected officials asking for lights on the East River Park track has entered the ESCR schedule as a change request. Its delivery date slipped one year on arrival.

Nearby in East Village
East VillageManhattan

The park is buried, the wall is behind glass, and the egg cream is a T-shirt.

East Village front page
Satire

The East Village paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting and filed from a fifth-floor walk-up that used to be punk. Everyone quoted is made up, the real officials' included, and the numbers are the only thing on St. Marks nobody has sold.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.