St. Marks Place Mourners Accuse Newcomers of Declaring It Dead Wrong
AI illustrationEast Village — Every generation since the 1950s has declared St. Marks Place dead, and its 1994 mourners say newcomers are doing it wrong. They have asked the city to issue death certificates by year of arrival, with seniority.
In Memoriam
St. Marks Place, a street between Third Avenue and Avenue A, died this decade, according to a newcomer who arrived this year. It has been declared dead before.
Beatniks said it died in the 1950s. Punks said the 1970s. A man in Westchester says 1996, when the Gap opened on Astor Place.
Trash and Vaudeville left for East 7th Street in 2015, and the street died again. The Sock Man moved to 99 1/2 St. Mark's in 2016, and it died one more time. Ada Calhoun's 2015 history argues every generation since the 1950s has declared it dead.
- ·Says the street died the year after he arrived
- ·Pronounces "St. Marks" as though it were a late friend
- ·Carries a keychain from a venue that no longer exists
- ·Corrects younger mourners on the date of death
- ·Has left for Westchester, returns only to be disappointed
27 St. Mark's Place: A Tenancy Record
| Tenant | Years | Departure | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Sock Man | The Sock Man | Until January 2016 | After a reported rent hike |
| Lab -320° | Lab -320° (ice cream) | Six months, 2016 | Closed |
| Vacant | Vacant | 2016-2021 | Storefront sat empty |
| Gong Cha | Gong Cha (bubble tea) | From February 2021 | Open |
Spot the Eulogy
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.
Has St. Marks Place really been declared dead every decade since the 1950s?Get the straight answer →


