Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Opinion

Brooklyn Bridge Park Board Member Says Bypass Would Harm the Park He Once Helped Pay For

AI illustration

— At a Sep 17 board meeting, former DOT commissioner Hank Gutman said the BQE bypass would damage the experience of Brooklyn Bridge Park. Gutman, a board member, had purchased a Pierhouse condo in 2014 along with another board member. The park pays for itself with private development on its edges.

The Brooklyn Bridge Park Corporation's board of directors convened Thursday in a second-floor conference room to consider a proposal to route a section of the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway over the park's southern edge, a plan the city's Department of Transportation says would take 11 years and cost $4 billion. Board member Hank Gutman, who served as commissioner of the department for six years, spent the first 20 minutes of the meeting reviewing the concerns of residents who, he said, will lose the view of the harbor they were promised. The plan would place the eastbound lanes roughly 40 feet above the Pierhouse rooftop bulkhead, a structure whose residents, according to the building's own marketing, paid between $1.1 million and $11.1 million for an unobstructed look at the water. Gutman did not dispute the marketing. He asked the board to consider what the expressway would do to the experience of the park.

The park is financed in part through private development on its edges, a model the state approved in a General Project Plan in 2006 that let the project skip city land-use review entirely. Pierhouse, a condo-hotel with 108 units, was among the first buildings to rise on that land, and its sales records, reported by The Real Deal on Sep. 24, 2015, showed units priced from $1.1 million to $11.1 million. Gutman purchased a unit in 2014, along with fellow board member Ruth Okonkwo-Lindgren, according to the same records. The park's board has since approved the development's rooftop bulkhead, which sits in the sightline the expressway would now occupy. Asked whether a board member with a unit in the building could fairly weigh the bypass's impact on that building, a spokesperson said the board's conflict-of-interest policy was followed in full. The spokesperson did not say which policy, or what it required. Gutman, reached by phone, said the condo owners attend the meetings. He said it as though it were a point in their favor.

The city has scheduled a public comment period on the bypass for later this year. Residents of the Brooklyn Heights Promenade, who have lived beneath the stacked expressway for decades, were invited to submit comments online. The Promenade's own advocates note the Department of Transportation's proposal would route traffic over a structure built for 50 years and now booked through 2080. Mike Flynn, the city's transportation commissioner, defended the plan in a Streetsblog op-ed, writing that the bypass offers the fastest route to restoring the park's connectivity. Gutman said he supports the plan's goals and simply wants the board to hear from those who will look at the highway from their windows. Those windows, several of them in Pierhouse, belong to the people who funded the park's last expansion.

The Harry Chapin Playground, which the bypass would remove for the duration of construction, will be restored when the highway is complete, the Department of Transportation said. The temporary highway is expected to operate from 2029 to 2040. Gutman said the board would take up the matter at its next meeting, and that he looked forward to hearing from the public. The park pays for itself, which means the condo owners attend the meetings. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why does the Brooklyn Bridge Park board include people who bought condos in the building the park's highway plans would affect?Get the straight answer →

More from Brooklyn

Brooklyn front page
Brooklyn
The Cantilever
DOT Says Kids Can Have Their Playground Back Once They Can Drive Over It

The BQE bypass would arch over Harry Chapin Playground from 2029 to 2040, and DOT says it will be restored. Kindergartners at the closing ceremony will be handed learner permits dated 2040.

Related: Brooklyn Bridge Park: the public park paid for by the condos inside it
Brooklyn
The Cantilever
DOT Unveils $4 Billion BQE Plan That Locks In the Highway Until 2080

The Department of Transportation presented $4 billion in plans on Aug 24 to keep the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway running for four more decades without widening it. A 2029-to-2040 temporary highway over the Brooklyn Bridge approach would take Harry Chapin Playground and the Promenade's neighboring parks. The structure was designed for 50 years and 50,000 vehicles a day; it has stood about 70 years and carries 130,000.

Related: Brooklyn Bridge Park: the public park paid for by the condos inside it
Brooklyn
Opinion
Brooklyn Boot Company Keeps Building Things in Pennsylvania as Borough Brand Goes Global

The Brooklyn Boot Company's factory is in Martinsburg, Pennsylvania. Parisians use 'très Brooklyn' as praise for food. The Nets, after moving from New Jersey, sold more merch than they won games, going 20-62 last season.

More from Opinion
Brooklyn
Opinion
Upper West Side Finally Admits It Is Only Progressive Above 86th Street

Zohran Mamdani carried 87th to 110th and Andrew Cuomo carried everything south of it, a split the neighborhood's block associations called 'unexpectedly geographic.' Zabar's said its smoked-fish line remained non-partisan.

More from Opinion
Brooklyn
Surf Avenue
Mermaid Parade Asks Its Own Borough President to Pay for the Street

The 44th Mermaid Parade ran on June 20 after organizers warned of a shortfall. Borough funding and a GoFundMe covered the costs of closing Surf Avenue for sea creatures.

Nearby in Brooklyn
Brooklyn
Kings County v. New York County
Brooklyn Rent Hits $4,350, Manhattan Lowers Its Price Only by Matching It

Brooklyn's median rent reached a record $4,350 in June, up 8 percent from last year. Manhattan's median is $5,295, also up 8 percent. The ratio stayed at 82 cents on the Manhattan dollar. The Interborough Express, a 14-mile freight route linking Brooklyn and Queens without Manhattan, is $5.5 billion and only half funded.

Nearby in Brooklyn
BrooklynNew York City

America's fourth-largest city until 277 votes said otherwise; arena delivered, housing pending.

Brooklyn front page
Satire

The Brooklyn paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real reporting and filed from a borough that was a city until 1898. Everyone quoted is made up, no real official is quoted, and nothing here went through a General Project Plan.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.