Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Opinion

As a Progressive, I Demand Housing Be Built Somewhere I Can't See It

On a leafy Brooklyn Heights brownstone block, a man in a fleece vest stands on his stoop holding a megaphone at a rally of neighbors carrying protest signs, all of them facing and shouting at a single new glass apartment tower across the street.AI illustration

— My window sign says housing is a human right, and our suit against the tower next door lists it as Exhibit A. Our block stopped six highway lanes on the Brooklyn Heights Promenade, and the trucks can go somewhere poorer.

I moved to Brooklyn Heights in 2019 from Columbus, Ohio, because I wanted to live in a place that believed in things. I still do. The housing is a human right, the science is real, transit is justice, and kindness is everything, which is why my window sign says so. It hangs in the front parlor, facing the street, where anyone walking the Promenade can read it. I have never once thought of it as a sign for the people on the other side of the block wall.

I support 7,700 apartments at the Brooklyn Marine Terminal. I want that clearly on the record. Red Hook is a different watershed, and the port has been underused since the Carter administration, and the state has a General Project Plan for it that I understand skips the city's land-use review, which I admit is a bit of a shortcut, but a shortcut toward the Bronx is still a shortcut toward a just future. I also support the Cross Bronx. I support it strongly.The building next door is the problem, and I want to be specific about the problem. Save the View Now sued Toll Brothers and the park in April 2015 over Pierhouse's height and the views from the Promenade. Our block joined the suit. Our lawyers filed my window sign as Exhibit A, because it proves that this block cares deeply about the community, and caring deeply, our counsel explained, is the thing a judge looks for. 

Which of these seven beliefs is the one the block actually adopted?

TAP THE LINE
TAP THE LINE YOU THINK IS WRONG
Map · Location

Location

Location

40.678200°, -73.944200°

Loading...
3 Locations
Open in Google Maps→
GlossaryA–Z

neighborhood character

The view. Specifically, the view from our front parlor of a building that does not yet exist, which our suit defends as the character of the block.

Category: Words I Use

community input

A lawsuit filed by nine civic groups against 1,300 proposed condo units after a $150 million Brooklyn Bridge Park plan was approved in February 2006.

Category: Words I Use

somewhere else

The Bronx. Also Red Hook. Also anywhere within walking distance of a train I do not take.

Category: Words I Use

temporary

Six BQE lanes on the Brooklyn Heights Promenade, proposed by de Blasio in 2018 and dropped after the Brooklyn Heights Association opposed them. Temporary, in this context, was a word for a highway on someone else's park.

Category: Words I Use

browse terms →
Opinion

I Will Be Marching for Housing on Saturday

By Thomas Hollenbeck
Homeowner, Brooklyn Heights, and member of the block association's housing subcommittee

I will be marching for housing on Saturday, and I want everyone to know the route. The association approved it because it does not pass the block. We walk down Court Street, turn toward Borough Hall, and end at a plaza the marchers will leave by 4 p.m. We have asked the organizers to keep the chants on the good side of the Promenade.

I am proud of this. Housing is a human right, and I have the sign to prove I believe it. I hope that the 7,700 units at Red Hook get built, and that the next bypass goes somewhere that already has a bypass. Nobody on this block wants to see a highway in a park. We have already done that work, and the park is still there, and the view is still ours.

Please join us Saturday. Bring a sign if you have one. Keep it in your front window where it can be read, and where the building next door can see it too.

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why did a Brooklyn Heights association sue to block housing next door while publicly supporting housing elsewhere?Get the straight answer →

More from Brooklyn

Brooklyn front page
Brooklyn
The Cantilever
DOT Says Kids Can Have Their Playground Back Once They Can Drive Over It

The BQE bypass would arch over Harry Chapin Playground from 2029 to 2040, and DOT says it will be restored. Kindergartners at the closing ceremony will be handed learner permits dated 2040.

Related: Brooklyn Bridge Park: the public park paid for by the condos inside it
Brooklyn
The Yard
Atlantic Yards Housing Plan Arrives Right on Time for the Next Project

The developers presented a plan with 5,600 more units and 30 percent affordable, down from 35. The $700 million in public money for the rail-yard platform is still pending.

Related: The General Project Plan: how the state builds on Brooklyn's waterfront without asking the city
Brooklyn
The Cantilever
DOT Unveils $4 Billion BQE Plan That Locks In the Highway Until 2080

The Department of Transportation presented $4 billion in plans on Aug 24 to keep the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway running for four more decades without widening it. A 2029-to-2040 temporary highway over the Brooklyn Bridge approach would take Harry Chapin Playground and the Promenade's neighboring parks. The structure was designed for 50 years and 50,000 vehicles a day; it has stood about 70 years and carries 130,000.

Related: Brooklyn Bridge Park: the public park paid for by the condos inside it
Brooklyn
The Canal
Gowanus Tower Breaks Ground on the Canal, Promises Four Months Free

A Bjarke Ingels Group tower could somehow clean the notoriously polluted Gowanus Canal through sheer architectural will. Leasing agents promise first tenants four months free on a 13-month lease.

Related: The General Project Plan: how the state builds on Brooklyn's waterfront without asking the city
Brooklyn
Opinion
Brooklyn Boot Company Keeps Building Things in Pennsylvania as Borough Brand Goes Global

The Brooklyn Boot Company's factory is in Martinsburg, Pennsylvania. Parisians use 'très Brooklyn' as praise for food. The Nets, after moving from New Jersey, sold more merch than they won games, going 20-62 last season.

More from Opinion
Brooklyn
Opinion
Upper West Side Finally Admits It Is Only Progressive Above 86th Street

Zohran Mamdani carried 87th to 110th and Andrew Cuomo carried everything south of it, a split the neighborhood's block associations called 'unexpectedly geographic.' Zabar's said its smoked-fish line remained non-partisan.

More from Opinion
BrooklynNew York City

America's fourth-largest city until 277 votes said otherwise; arena delivered, housing pending.

Brooklyn front page
Satire

The Brooklyn paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real reporting and filed from a borough that was a city until 1898. Everyone quoted is made up, the real officials' included, and nothing here went through a General Project Plan.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.