Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Reimagined Public Safety

Tear-Gas Ban Survives Hostage Scenario It Never Anticipated

AI illustration

— Council voted 5-4 in late September to keep the ban on police tear gas, rejecting a proposal for barricades, hostages and high-risk warrants. Mayor Ishii and Councilmember Lunaparra opposed the exception.

The scenario at the center of the vote, a hostage taker barricaded in a Southside duplex, does not exist. It has been held on the council agenda since January, continued eleven times, and assigned a staff liaison.

Councilmember Rashi Kesarwani proposed the exception for hostages. Councilmember Brent Blackaby then amended it to add barricades and high-risk warrants cur-tear-gas-vote, which city staff interpreted as instructions to give the hypothetical hostage taker a barricade and an outstanding warrant. By June, the imaginary standoff had more documented risk factors than the North Berkeley BART housing project.

Interview Transcript
Public Comment, Item 31 (Continued)
Berkeley City Council Regular Meeting, September 2026
CLERK:
Item 31, the hostage, continued from August. Staff report is updated.
STAFF:
The hostage is stable. We have moved him to a second-floor unit to reflect the Blackaby amendment.
CLERK:
Has the captor made any demands?
STAFF:
He has asked that the item be heard after the November election. We have accommodated that in spirit.
PUBLIC COMMENTER:
I've waited four hours to talk about the speed bump on my block, and this man has been holding someone since January.
CLERK:
Your time has expired.

Staff said the scenario was never meant to resolve before the council found a politically suitable week. That week arrived in late September, when one councilmember framed keeping the ban as resistance to the Trump administration cur-tear-gas-vote, giving the imaginary hostage a federal dimension.

"We have kept him fed, hydrated and on the agenda, which is more than the county can say for most people," said Dolores Fenn, the city's Deputy Clerk for Continued Items. "Nobody wanted to rush a hostage."

The exception failed 5-4, with Mayor Adena Ishii and Councilmember Cecilia Lunaparra among those opposed cur-tear-gas-vote. The ban on police tear gas stands for every hostage situation in Berkeley, including the one the city built.

The captor remains barricaded. Staff have referred him to the Public Safety Policy Committee for a check-in in 2027.

The hostage has been asked to submit his remarks in writing. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why did Berkeley vote to keep its police tear gas ban instead of allowing it for hostage situations?Get the straight answer →

More from Berkeley

Berkeley front page
Berkeley
Zoning Wars
Elmwood Seeks Landmark Status for Its Parking and Convenience

A resident asked the City Council to designate the sidewalk mood at 4 p.m. as historic. The council votes Nov. 12 on making 28 Elmwood buildings a Historic District.

Related: Berzerkeley: the stereotype locals half-agree with
Berkeley
Gourmet Ghetto
Berkeley Atheist Eats Whatever Pizza the Collective Reveals Today

The Cheese Board Collective on Shattuck bakes one pizza a day, and a local atheist has never once questioned it. He calls the line a community, not a congregation, and tithes in the tip jar.

Related: Berzerkeley: the stereotype locals half-agree with
Berkeley
Reimagined Public Safety
Mobile Crisis Team Disbands 113 Days Ago; Police Chief Confirms the Team Was Dispatched to Fewer Than 5% of Mental-Health Calls Anyway

Berkeley's Mobile Crisis Team was disbanded July 17 as part of a budget that also cut the winter shelter. A 2023 city report found the team reached fewer than one in twenty mental-health incidents over six quarters. The Specialized Care Unit now belongs to the county, and the department remains at 137 officers.

Related: Reimagining public safety, unimagined
Berkeley
Bears in the ACC
Tightwad Hill Sells Out at Price of Nothing

Tightwad Hill, above Memorial Stadium, remains the most Berkeley seat in college football. Attendance is unaffected by the ACC.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
Town v. Gown
Heumann House to Open Fall 2027 With 1,113 Beds, Two-Thirds Open Space, Supportive Apartments Awaiting Funding

UC's 57-year project on the block it bought in 1967 is nearly complete, with the student tower on schedule. The roughly 100 promised supportive and affordable apartments remain about half-funded and will not begin construction until the dorm opens. Demonstrators have moved on to the containers, which are now the park's most visited feature.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
Forwarding Address
Florida Man Spends $100 Million Fighting California Tax He Moved to Avoid

Sergey Brin, reported to have moved to Miami before the residency cutoff, gave more than $100 million to defeat Proposition 40. A Florida Man roundup filed it between an alligator in a pool and a man who married his boat.

Nearby in Bay Area
BerkeleyCalifornia

Invented single-family zoning in 1916. Still workshopping the apology.

Berkeley front page
Satire

The Berkeley paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire on real local reporting. The commenters are invented; the parcel taxes are not, and no real official is quoted.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.