Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Gourmet Ghetto

Berkeley Atheist Eats Whatever Pizza the Collective Reveals Today

On Shattuck Avenue in Berkeley, a long line of people in fleece and sandals kneel on the sidewalk facing a pizzeria's open window with heads bowed, as a worker inside raises a single pizza aloft like a sacrament.AI illustration

— The Cheese Board Collective on Shattuck bakes one pizza a day, and a local atheist has never once questioned it. He calls the line a community, not a congregation, and tithes in the tip jar.

Asked why he left organized religion at 19, North Berkeley resident Dylan Hartwig, 52, said he did not like being told what to accept. He then said he has joined the Cheese Board Collective line on Shattuck at 11:30 every day since the 1990s, and has never once asked what the pizza is before joining. "You don't ask the altar what's on it," Hartwig said. Asked whether that was a contradiction, he said it was a community, not a congregation, and paid the tip jar on the way out.

Cheese Board Collective · 1512 Shattuck Ave
Today's pie. One item. Served until gone.
Pizza of the Day
$6 slice
potatoes, rosemary, whatever the collective decided at 6 a.m.
Substitutions
n/a
none accepted
Questions
n/a
no

Hartwig's partner, who asked not to be named, said the line has its own rites: the Pilgrim who drove from Walnut Creek, the Regular who knows the bread schedule, the Skeptic who stays anyway, and the Tourist who asks about pepperoni and is gently redirected. Live jazz plays from the corner. Strangers share the median tables on Shattuck, which the partner described as "the nave." When asked if the couple had considered trying another pizzeria, Hartwig called the idea "transactional" and ordered two slices of corn.

Diary Entry
Week of Nov. 9
Dear Diary,
Mood: Quietly Devout

Monday: corn.

Tuesday: corn again. It was meant.

Wednesday: asked a regular what the pizza was. He said 'the pizza.' Felt seen.

Thursday: partner suggested Chez Panisse. Told him the deposit is $25 a person and the booking is a month out. Did not go.

Friday: I do not believe in anything.

✱
✱
✱
Reflection
The line is long and the faith is short, and I am in it either way.
✱
✱
✱
— Me

Hartwig, when asked whether he believes in anything at all, said he does not believe in anything. He added that the pizza is what was meant, and that he has no further comment on the matter until tomorrow's corn. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

How does the Cheese Board Collective decide what pizza to make each day?Get the straight answer →

More from Berkeley

Berkeley front page
Berkeley
Reimagined Public Safety
Berkeley Hostage Asked to Wait Out Trump

The Berkeley City Council voted 5-4 to keep its tear-gas ban, rejecting an exception for barricades, hostages and high-risk warrants. The city's revised protocol offers each hostage a land acknowledgment and an estimated wait of 26 months.

Related: Berzerkeley: the stereotype locals half-agree with
Berkeley
Zoning Wars
Elmwood Seeks Landmark Status for Its Parking and Convenience

A resident asked the City Council to designate the sidewalk mood at 4 p.m. as historic. The council votes Nov. 12 on making 28 Elmwood buildings a Historic District.

Related: Berzerkeley: the stereotype locals half-agree with
Berkeley
Opinion
Salt & Straw Picks Rockridge, Berkeley Takes It Personally

Salt & Straw opens Nov. 13 in Rockridge, its second East Bay store. Berkeley's Gourmet Ghetto noted the opening is across the Oakland line.

Related: Chez Panisse, the Cheese Board line and Berkeley Bowl: food as religion
Berkeley
Bears in the ACC
Tightwad Hill Sells Out at Price of Nothing

Tightwad Hill, above Memorial Stadium, remains the most Berkeley seat in college football. Attendance is unaffected by the ACC.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
Town v. Gown
Heumann House to Open Fall 2027 With 1,113 Beds, Two-Thirds Open Space, Supportive Apartments Awaiting Funding

UC's 57-year project on the block it bought in 1967 is nearly complete, with the student tower on schedule. The roughly 100 promised supportive and affordable apartments remain about half-funded and will not begin construction until the dorm opens. Demonstrators have moved on to the containers, which are now the park's most visited feature.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
Forwarding Address
Florida Man Spends $100 Million Fighting California Tax He Moved to Avoid

Sergey Brin, reported to have moved to Miami before the residency cutoff, gave more than $100 million to defeat Proposition 40. A Florida Man roundup filed it between an alligator in a pool and a man who married his boat.

Nearby in Bay Area
BerkeleyCalifornia

Invented single-family zoning in 1916. Still workshopping the apology.

Berkeley front page
Satire

The Berkeley paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire on real local reporting. The commenters are invented; the parcel taxes are not, and no real official is quoted.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.