Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Zoning Wars

Berkeley's Apology for Single-Family Zoning Exempts the Hills

On a flatland Berkeley street of crowded fourplexes, a city official in a suit kneels on the sidewalk with his head bowed in apology, while up on the green hillside above, a man on the deck of a large view home watches through binoculars, holding a glass of wine.AI illustration

— Berkeley's formal apology for inventing single-family zoning in 1916 will be read aloud citywide, except in the Berkeley Hills. Hills residents say they support the apology in principle but cannot evacuate that many words.

The apology, which runs 1,140 words, was circulated to the press Thursday after a closed-door session at the Permit Services Center on Milvia Street. It opens by acknowledging that the city "gave the nation a template for keeping neighbors out of neighborhoods in 1916, and has spent the century since polishing it." The text then asks forgiveness of anyone "priced out, carded out, or lawn-signed out," and commits the city to "a continuing conversation about character." Staff said the document will be read aloud at the next regular meeting, a process expected to take four hours and fourteen minutes, not counting the Elmwood. Mayor Adena Ishii said the city "owes its residents the full weight of its regret," then added that the regret would be applied "proportionally, consistent with our 2025 middle housing work."

Map · Location

Location

Location

37.871600°, -122.272700°

Loading...
3 Locations
Open in Google Maps→
6/26
public comment, 6/26
  • oppose 8 sentences in elmwood (character)
    the first district, 1916, my street, built under it
  • ask staff re: traffic on alcatraz
  • housing supported in principle, all hearings
  • apology too long for 3 min slot
  • shade on my solar panels
    the apology's shade, not the trees'
  • my house was built under it
    crossed out, then rewritten in the margin
  • request env. review of apology's impacts
  • who is wendell in this paragraph
  • ask for one-line hills version
  • bring copies of 1916 ordinance
  • hold seat for Ruth (after lunch)
  • sign off on the map by 11:55
    before midnight
neighborhood character
invasionEnglish (1916 council record)

the arrival of lower-cost housing, described as a threat to property values

neighborhood characterEnglish (2025 public comment)

the reason four units cannot go on a 5,000 square foot lot

neighborhood character (apologized for)English (2026 resolution)

a thing the city regrets, except where it is hiding

The phrase kept its meaning for a century; only the apology changed the grammar, from threat to heritage to something to be sorry for, always in the same direction.
Quiz
1/4

Zone 0 requires 5 feet of ember-resistant clearance; apologies are not yet rated. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why does Berkeley's zoning apology exclude the hills?Get the straight answer →

More from Berkeley

Berkeley front page
Berkeley
Town v. Gown
Homeowner Backs Housing, Just on Another Street

Wendell Ostrow-Pike, 44-year Elmwood resident, told the Zoning Adjustments Board he supports housing in principle and opposes the one proposed at 1130 Oxford. He then asked for the sign-in sheet to be saved for the next one.

Related: The city that invented single-family zoning, and its 109-year apology
Berkeley
Reimagined Public Safety
Police Audit Finds Surveillance Clean, Community Not Yet Consulted on Cameras

A department audit of Flock license-plate cameras found no breaches, but privacy advocates say third-party access was not examined. The Council votes Nov. 17 on whether the cameras should keep reading plates while who else reads them waits.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
The Alphabet Ballot
Berkeley Saves Its $57 Million Cushion for an Emergency Worse Than Winter

Berkeley closed its 25-bed winter shelter to save $358,750 and is holding its $57 million cushion for a proper emergency. Finance staff said qualifying events include an earthquake, a lawsuit and a cold snap at a council member's house.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
Opinion
Salt & Straw Picks Rockridge, Berkeley Takes It Personally

Salt & Straw opens Nov. 13 in Rockridge, its second East Bay store. Berkeley's Gourmet Ghetto noted the opening is across the Oakland line.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
Bears in the ACC
Tightwad Hill Sells Out at Price of Nothing

Tightwad Hill, above Memorial Stadium, remains the most Berkeley seat in college football. Attendance is unaffected by the ACC.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
Town v. Gown
Heumann House to Open Fall 2027 With 1,113 Beds, Two-Thirds Open Space, Supportive Apartments Awaiting Funding

UC's 57-year project on the block it bought in 1967 is nearly complete, with the student tower on schedule. The roughly 100 promised supportive and affordable apartments remain about half-funded and will not begin construction until the dorm opens. Demonstrators have moved on to the containers, which are now the park's most visited feature.

Nearby in Berkeley
BerkeleyCalifornia

Invented single-family zoning in 1916. Still workshopping the apology.

Berkeley front page
Satire

The Berkeley paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire on real local reporting. The commenters are invented; the parcel taxes are not, and no real official is quoted.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.