Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Zoning Wars

Berkeley Council Unanimously Passes Eight-Unit Ordinance, Then Exempts Hills Pending Evacuation Study Expected to Conclude Around 2141

A council chamber photo of a lawn sign reading 'In This House We Believe' held up at the public comment podium, next to a 1916 city map labeled 'One Family' on a projector behind it.AI illustration

— The city that invented single-family zoning in 1916 passed citywide middle housing after a four-year resolution process, excluding the hills. The exemption will remain in place while the city studies evacuation routes, a process council staff estimate at 117 years. Lawn signs in the Elmwood now read 'In This House We Believe.'

The hills carve-out took effect at 11:42 p.m., eleven minutes after the ordinance itself, and was drafted as a separate item so that council members could vote for the housing and the exemption on the same night without having to be in the same room as either. The exemption covers every parcel in the city's Fire Hazard Severity Zones, roughly the entire district of Councilmember Brent Blackaby, who voted yes on both. Staff scoped the evacuation study the following morning and listed its completion date as "pending, with a working estimate of 2141." The study is being conducted by the same department that would have to approve the evacuation routes it recommends.

"The study is comprehensive, and comprehensive things take time," said Dolores Hathaway, the city's Senior Planner for Pending Determinations, at a briefing Thursday in the council annex. "Grizzly Peak has two ways out. Residents would like us to confirm there are fewer than two ways in. If we get that wrong in the other direction, we would have to study that too." Hathaway said the 117-year timeline has "built-in flexibility" and could slip to 2150 if the Hayward Fault produces any new data.

A council chamber with a giant binder labeled Evacuation Study Volume 1 of 4,000, and an elderly man asleep beside a stack of identical binders.

Volume 1 of the evacuation study, shown to the public Thursday.

On Elmwood's Ashby Avenue, where the single-family zoning experiment began in 1916, residents greeted the ordinance by retiring the old signs. The new ones read In This House We Believe and went up on the same lawns, in some cases the same stakes. "We believe in all of it," said Wendell Ostrow-Pike, 71, a retired actuary who has lived on the block for 44 years and supports housing "in principle." "I just think the process has been rushed. It's only been a hundred and nine years."

Berkeley's Office of Neighborhood Character Preservation confirmed Friday that it has opened a file on the ordinance's definition of "neighborhood," which the ordinance does not contain. The office expects to close the file in time for the study. Eight units are now permitted on a 5,000-square-foot lot, provided the lot is not in the hills. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

What does Berkeley's middle housing ordinance actually allow, and why are the hills exempt?Get the straight answer →

More from Berkeley

Berkeley front page
Berkeley
Town v. Gown
Homeowner Backs Housing, Just on Another Street

Wendell Ostrow-Pike, 44-year Elmwood resident, told the Zoning Adjustments Board he supports housing in principle and opposes the one proposed at 1130 Oxford. He then asked for the sign-in sheet to be saved for the next one.

Related: The city that invented single-family zoning, and its 109-year apology
Berkeley
Reimagined Public Safety
Police Audit Finds Surveillance Clean, Community Not Yet Consulted on Cameras

A department audit of Flock license-plate cameras found no breaches, but privacy advocates say third-party access was not examined. The Council votes Nov. 17 on whether the cameras should keep reading plates while who else reads them waits.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
The Alphabet Ballot
Berkeley Saves Its $57 Million Cushion for an Emergency Worse Than Winter

Berkeley closed its 25-bed winter shelter to save $358,750 and is holding its $57 million cushion for a proper emergency. Finance staff said qualifying events include an earthquake, a lawsuit and a cold snap at a council member's house.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
Opinion
Salt & Straw Picks Rockridge, Berkeley Takes It Personally

Salt & Straw opens Nov. 13 in Rockridge, its second East Bay store. Berkeley's Gourmet Ghetto noted the opening is across the Oakland line.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
Bears in the ACC
Tightwad Hill Sells Out at Price of Nothing

Tightwad Hill, above Memorial Stadium, remains the most Berkeley seat in college football. Attendance is unaffected by the ACC.

Nearby in Berkeley
Berkeley
Town v. Gown
Heumann House to Open Fall 2027 With 1,113 Beds, Two-Thirds Open Space, Supportive Apartments Awaiting Funding

UC's 57-year project on the block it bought in 1967 is nearly complete, with the student tower on schedule. The roughly 100 promised supportive and affordable apartments remain about half-funded and will not begin construction until the dorm opens. Demonstrators have moved on to the containers, which are now the park's most visited feature.

Nearby in Berkeley
BerkeleyCalifornia

Invented single-family zoning in 1916. Still workshopping the apology.

Berkeley front page
Satire

The Berkeley paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire on real local reporting. The commenters are invented; the parcel taxes are not, and no real official is quoted.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.