Phillies' Nationwide Manager Search Ends at General Manager's Kitchen Table
Philadelphia — The Phillies kept Don Mattingly, 65, on a two-year deal after another October exit. His son Preston is the general manager, and Mattingly said, 'I'm comfortable with whatever they want to do.'
Pat Lindqvist, managing partner of Lindqvist Baseball Search in Hartford, said the firm reviewed candidates in all 50 states over a nine-week period that began in early October. "We looked everywhere," Lindqvist said. "We spoke to coaches in Phoenix, former bench players in Tampa, a retired infielder who now sells boats in Maine. Every road was explored." The firm's invoice to the Phillies lists travel expenses for 212 flights, 48 rental cars and one dinner at a house on the 1400 block of Marconi Road in Havertown, which Lindqvist described as "the final stop of an exhaustive, deliberate process." The search concluded at the kitchen table on Thanksgiving Day, when Preston Mattingly, the team's general manager, reported that his father, Don Mattingly, 65, had been "available and enthusiastic." Don Mattingly was retained on a two-year deal, a decision that followed a 6-2 loss at Atlanta in Game 3 of the Wild Card round on October 1 and a 79-55 record in the 2026 interim stretch that began April 28, when the team stood 9-19.
NOW HIRING, REGIONALLY
Seeking Manager. Must Know the GM's Schedule.
Subheadline
Competitive salary. Thanksgiving availability required. Candidates must be comfortable with 'whatever they want to do.' Apply at the kitchen table.
Disclaimer
*Position reports to the general manager. Position is also the general manager's father. Nationwide search conducted at no cost to the Phillies, which has been advised the costs were covered by the search firm, the search firm, and the search firm.
Cycle
The Nationwide Search, as Conducted
01
📋
Post Opening Nationally
The position is listed on every major job board, in every state, and at the Sunday morning table at the Reading Terminal Market. Every applicant is received and filed under 'Dad.'
02
🎙️
Screen Thirty Candidates
Thirty qualified applicants are interviewed by video from 50 states over nine weeks. Each interview concludes with a question about Thanksgiving, which is answered by the GM's mother.
03
📝
Compile a Shortlist
The shortlist contains four names. One is the GM's uncle, who interviewed well but lives in Evansville. The other three are contingent on his availability.
04
🍗
Review Finalists Over Dinner
The finalists are reviewed at a kitchen table in Havertown. The GM's mother also reviews the finalists. Her decision is recorded as unanimous.
05
🔁
Return to the Kitchen Table
The process restarts with the same kitchen table, which the search firm has listed on its website as a 'national talent hub.'
The Phillies have defined a 'nationwide search' as a process that begins in every state and ends in one house. Under the team's guidelines, a candidate's credentials are evaluated according to how well they fit the general manager's Thanksgiving calendar. The team's internal glossary, reviewed by this newspaper, describes the phrase as 'a commitment to rigor that concludes where rigor is most comfortable.' Team owner John Middleton, reached through a spokesperson, said the team 'values the perspective of families who have stood with the club through every October.' Asked whether that perspective included a family seat at the table, Middleton's office declined to comment.
Multiple-Choice Quiz
01/01
Question 01
To whom does the Phillies' general manager report?
A
The owner
B
The fans
C
His father
D
Dave Dombrowski
To whom does the Phillies' general manager report?
Your Answer
Correct Answer
Dave Dombrowski
✗Incorrect
Explanation
Dombrowski is the only check in the building. The team describes his oversight as 'thorough and entirely unrelated to dinner.'
Score0/ 1
Mattingly said he was "comfortable with whatever they want to do," a sentence the search firm later called the strongest answer of the cycle. The recruiter, Lindqvist, has billed the team for travel to all 50 states and is expected to submit a second invoice reflecting the drive from Havertown to Citizens Bank Park, which the firm listed as 'a regional exercise.' The Phillies have not announced the name of the runner-up, who was the general manager's uncle and remains available in Evansville. ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.