Philadelphia — Philadelphia Municipal Court ruled that 'Go Birds,' already the city's hello and goodbye, is also a complete plea. Prosecutors may answer only with 'Go Birds,' at which point both sides rest.
The rule, issued by Court Administrator Frank Dolan, runs one page. A defendant enters the plea in two words, standing, and may not amend it. Elaboration is treated as a second plea and struck. "We found nobody was saying anything after the two words anyway," Dolan said. "We were transcribing a lot of nodding. This saves the stenographers' hands for the other side of the room, which also only says two words." The first hearing under the rule concerned a Honda parked on the South Broad Street median.
Interview Transcript
THE COURT:
How do you plead?
THE COURT:
[gavel] Go Birds.
CLERK:
[stamps file closed] Go Birds.
Judge Carol Nolan, who presided, said the ruling clears a docket of parking and noise matters in under an hour. Her clerk keeps a laminated card of what the plea has been held to mean, taped to the bench beside the water pitcher.
Definition
A two-word plea that the court files as guilty, not guilty, "I was at the game," or "what time is it," depending on how loud it was said.
The thing most people miss
The defendant who says it quietest is presumed to be a Dallas Cowboys fan.
The defense bar has raised one objection. Clients in Cowboys gear may not use the plea and must plead in full sentences, with subordinate clauses. "My guy got a noise ticket outside the Linc and had to testify for forty minutes," said Mike Brennan, a public defender. "Youse don't get two words if you're wearing a star. That's not in the Constitution. I checked." Asked whether the plea survives an Eagles team that is 2-7 and last in the NFC East, Dolan said the court does not comment on pending seasons.
Pittsburgh visits on Nov. 22. The court has posted a notice that afternoon dockets will adjourn at 12:40 for the 1 p.m. kickoff, with defendants instructed to wear green to preserve their plea.Court resumes after the game, unless they lose, in which case nobody is pleading anything. ■