Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Phase 2

Second Avenue Subway Phase 2 Breaks Ground on Commemorative Dirt Pile

Three men in high-vis vests and hard hats stand ceremoniously around a single heap of grey gravel in the middle of Second Avenue, each holding a golden plastic garden trowel with intense concentration.AI illustration

— MTA engineers unveiled a heirloom dirt pile at 106th Street marking a major milestone in the Second Avenue Subway century-long excavation. Chairperson Janno Lieber confirmed construction will proceed uninterrupted until September 2032. The dirt has been certified historic fill.

The pile, roughly four feet tall and fenced on all sides, sits on a closed lane of Second Avenue beneath a vinyl banner reading PROGRESS. Engineers spent eleven months determining its final shape, which officials described as conical, with room to grow.

The pile will be watered twice weekly and guarded overnight by a two-person detail from MTA Construction & Development. It is not permitted to be moved, added to or dug into until the agency completes environmental review of the pile itself.

Riders at the Q at 96th Street, where the line has ended since 2017, could see the pile from the station stairs. "I've been getting off at 96th for nine years and walking the rest," said Ruth Feldman, a home health aide from East Harlem. "Now I walk past the dirt."

Agency officials said the pile represents the first visible output of Phase 2, which will add stations at 106th, 116th and 125th Streets. "Every great subway begins with a hole, and every hole begins with deciding where the dirt goes," said Greg Malone, the MTA's Senior Manager of Groundbreaking Continuity. "We decided." Malone added that the hole itself remained in procurement.

Phase 2: Revised Milestone Schedule

1929
Second Avenue Subway proposed
Plan announced alongside the Independent Subway System expansion.
2017
Phase 1 opens to 96th Street
Three stations. Q extended.
Now
Commemorative dirt pile completed
Certified historic fill.
2027
Pile achieves settlement
Engineers expect it to lose about an inch.
2029
Bronze plaque installed at pile
Plaque to commemorate the pile, not the subway.
September 2032
Revenue service to 125th Street
Assumes the pile is not landmarked.

Janno Lieber has said publicly that Phase 2 remains on budget and on schedule for 2032. The plaque, a 14-by-20-inch bronze tablet engraved with the date the dirt was poured, has already been minted and is being held in a climate-controlled room in Lower Manhattan until the pile is ready to receive it.

The Second Avenue Subway Phase 3 Community Advisory Committee, which has never met, issued a statement requesting a pile of its own.The dirt was borrowed from Queens. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

When will the Second Avenue Subway Phase 2 actually open, and why does it take so long to build?Get the straight answer →

More from New York City

New York City front page
New York City
Moving to Jersey
Billionaires Threaten to Move Into Their Manhattan Apartments

Billionaires threatened to sleep in their 57th Street apartments after an appeals court let the pied-a-terre tax proceed Nov. 4. Doormen are learning their names.

Related: Albany holds the leash: the city that needs permission
New York City
Albany Permission Slip
Hochul Wins Second Full Term, Indefinitely Pauses It Out of Habit

Gov. Kathy Hochul, re-elected Nov. 3, put her second full term on indefinite pause, as she did congestion pricing in June 2024. The term is expected to resume shortly after the next election.

Related: Albany holds the leash: the city that needs permission
New York City
The Garden & the Parking Lot
Mets Fans Told Casino Next Door Will Offer Better Odds

The Mets finished 74-88, last in the NL East, as Steve Cohen's Metropolitan Park casino heads for the Citi Field lot. Cohen said in August the roster carried 'too much risk,' a problem the slot machines will not have.

Nearby in New York City
New York City
City Hall Station
Cuomo Enters Democratic Primary for Transportation Secretary

Andrew Cuomo entered the Democratic primary for transportation secretary after Gov. Kathy Hochul demanded Sean Duffy resign following the FAA ground stop. He trails.

Nearby in New York City
New York City
Opinion
Area Man Opts In to Salad, Out of Bin

A Midtown worker asked the bodega cat to sign for his $20 salad. The bodega said the cat is not legal.

Nearby in New York City
New York City
Empire Bins
Brooklyn Heights Co-op Wants Bin Key Card for Cat

A co-op board asked if Empire Bins' key card works on cat flaps. DSNY confirmed containerization works.

Nearby in New York City
New York CityNew York

Eight million people, a $3 fare set in Albany, a subway line due in 2032.

New York City front page
Satire

The New York City paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Everyone quoted is made up, no real official is quoted, and the fare really is $3.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.