Brooklyn Heights Co-op Wants Bin Key Card for Cat
New York City — A co-op board asked if Empire Bins' key card works on cat flaps. DSNY confirmed containerization works.
The request, a one-page letter signed by the five-member board of the building's co-op and delivered to the Department of Sanitation on a Thursday, asks whether the key card issued for the Empire Bin can also be programmed to open the cat flap in the lobby door of 118 Pierrepont Street, a 62-unit prewar building in Brooklyn Heights. The board noted that the bin's card reader and the flap's latch "appear to be roughly the same size." Sanitation spokesperson Dolores Tran, reached at the department's Metrotech office, said the request was received and read in full. The agency confirmed that containerization works.
The Empire Bin, a locked on-street container for buildings over 30 units, opens by key card and is emptied by a side-loading truck. Of the roughly 450 buildings in Community Board 2 contacted about opting in, about 50 have signed up, according to Brownstoner. The board of 118 Pierrepont said it had been "inspired by the clarity" of the program, in which every resident gets one card, every card opens one thing, and nobody argues about whose turn it is. Its own house rules currently govern the cat flap through a four-page addendum that tenants describe as "not read." Under the proposed arrangement, Biscuit, a 9-year-old tabby in apartment 4C, would be issued a card for the bin and a second, separate card for the flap, pending the board's decision on whether a cat counts as a tenant for purposes of the sign-up fee.
The department's reply, dated the following Tuesday, was two paragraphs long and addressed to "Dear Board." It stated that key cards are issued to buildings, not to residents, pets or doors, and that the city has "no process for enrolling a flap." It also noted that the cards open the bin and "nothing else, including other bins." Tran said the department receives unusual correspondence daily and that this one was answered the same as the rest. "We just want the trash in the container," she said. "What happens at the lobby door is between the building and the cat."
The board met Wednesday night in the lobby to vote on whether to continue the effort. Treasurer Gary Pruitt said the vote was less about the cat than about the building's reputation among neighbors who had already enrolled. "Everyone on Remsen Street is in," Pruitt said. "We cannot be the building that wrote to the city and then did nothing." Tenant Aileen Marsh, 71, who has lived in 2B since 1989, said she had no strong feelings on the card but wanted it noted that she still did not have a working intercom. The motion passed 4 to 1, with the lone dissent from the cat's owner, who said Biscuit had not been consulted.The $55-a-tenant fee tied to the bin program, which the city is holding in reserve, is "not being collected." ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.
How does NYC's Empire Bin key card system work for apartment buildings, and what does it cost residents?Get the straight answer →

