Developer of Stalled 45 Park Place Files Countersuit Against the Crane
AI illustration
Tribeca — The developer of 45 Park Place filed a countersuit Tuesday alleging the crane has failed to vacate the site since 2019 and is responsible for the project's delays. A court filing states the crane is 'no longer cooperating with the schedule,' and the developer is asking that it be removed from the property at once.
The countersuit, filed in New York County Supreme Court, names as defendant "one (1) tower crane, make and model unknown to the Plaintiff, last seen cooperating in 2019." Dale Ostrander, the developer's Senior Vice President for Site Accountability, said the company had exhausted every alternative before turning to litigation. "We have asked the crane to come down, in writing, on four occasions," Ostrander said. "It has not responded. It has not even moved. At some point you have to ask what kind of partner doesn't move for seven years."
The filing describes the crane as having "remained on the premises in a posture of non-participation" and cites its failure to attend a single scheduling meeting. It also notes the crane "has been unavailable for comment since approximately the Trump administration's first term."
Reached by phone, the crane's attorney did not return a call, a failure Ostrander said "speaks for itself, and has since 2019." The developer's filing asks the court to treat that silence as an admission. The crane has also missed two deadlines to file a response, and a third is expected to pass this week, as it has every week.
The filing is the first of its kind in Tribeca, though not the first to suggest that the tallest object at the site is the only one with no explanation for its position. Residents who walk past it daily said they had assumed the crane was part of the building.
Quote
“I've lived on Park Place since 1984. The crane has been up longer than some of my neighbors' leases. If anyone is going to be served, it should be the one who's been on the site the whole time.”
Evelyn Hartwig, Park Place resident
The developer has requested that the court order the crane removed "forthwith and at its own expense," and has reserved the right to name additional parties, including the tower, the lot, and "such other fixtures as may be discovered during discovery." Ostrander declined to say what the company would do if the crane were found in contempt, noting only that the site "is now officially a party to litigation and will be treated as one."A hearing is scheduled for next month. The crane has not been located for comment. ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.