East Village — NYU opened its newest East Village residence hall this week, a 26-story tower built behind the restored 1847 facade of St. Ann's Church, whose tower and iron gates now frame the front door. The building houses about 4,400 students across the neighborhood's eight halls, and about 17% of NYU undergraduates are New York City residents.
Founders Hall's lobby is the nave. Students swipe in beneath the 1847 tower, past the iron gates, through a church facade that now opens onto a mailroom, and the building's welcome packet has already stopped using the word "entrance." The packet says "the façade experience." Move-in staff were instructed to say "welcome to St. Ann's" to arriving freshmen and to stop there, because the follow-up question, "who's St. Ann?", reached the front desk by 9 a.m. Tuesday and has not been answered in writing.
The tower is the only part of the church that still does anything. It rises 26 stories short of the 26 stories behind it, and NYU has lit it at night since Monday. "The steeple is fully operational," said Rob Teller, a facilities manager for the university's Division of Real Estate, standing in the gate. "It is not a steeple of anything. It's a steeple. We looked into whether it should be doing something and the answer was that it's historic." Teller said the structure would stay exactly as restored: a bell with no one to ring it, a door with nothing to be a door to. He called this "the preservation outcome."
Move-in day at Founders Hall, East 12th Street. The doors are original.
The hall is the ninth in the neighborhood. It joins eight others, and together they hold about 4,400 students, a headcount the East Village has absorbed on the theory that a neighborhood can only be taken one building at a time. A church that once held a congregation now holds Founders Hall and the sense that someone, somewhere, decided the facade was the part worth keeping. The congregation did not get a facade. The congregation got a plaque.
Residents have taken the arrangement in stride, which the university describes as a sign of community buy-in. "I used to walk past this church to get to my corner," said Denise Okafor, 61, who has lived on East 11th Street since 1989. "Now I walk past it to get to somebody else's. Nobody told me when it stopped being the thing it was. It just got a lobby." Okafor said she had stopped checking the sign out front, since the sign now lists floors.
Only about 17% of NYU undergraduates are New York City residents, a figure the university cited at the opening as evidence of its reach. Everyone else arrives with luggage. The residence life office confirmed that move-in weekend will again bring Third Avenue to a standstill, as it does each fall, with cars double-parked under the tower and IKEA bags stacked at the gates like pews. The church has a tower, gates, and nothing behind it but freshmen. ■