Poisonal
World
Poisonal
City Hall Station

Mamdani Confirms Jessica Tisch Will Remain Police Commissioner Unless Someone Asks Nicer

— Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced that Jessica Tisch will retain her post at 1 Police Plaza following a comprehensive review of departmental tone.

The review, which began after a week of protests outside City Hall, examined whether Commissioner Tisch could be made to leave if asked in a sufficiently warm tone. Investigators concluded that no request to date had been warm enough, and that the bar for warm enough would be set by a second review. "We tested every phrasing that came in, from the chants to the letters," said Marcy Odom, the mayor's Deputy Director of Continuity. "Several were very close. One said 'please.' But a commissioner cannot be removed by a request that also contains the word 'demand.'"

Copies of the findings were printed on recycled paper from 2019 and distributed to protesters, who were asked to resubmit their concerns in a friendlier voice by the next committee hearing. "I asked her to leave the way my mother taught me," said Luis Ferreira, a retired bus driver from Sunset Park. "Apparently my mother didn't know enough." The NYPD budget will stay where it was while the city waits for someone to ask nicer. The review of whether the request was nice enough is scheduled to take 24 hours, and the Strategic Response Group will be on hand to receive it. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why did Mayor Mamdani keep Jessica Tisch as NYPD commissioner?Get the straight answer →

More from New York City

New York City front page
New York City
Albany Permission Slip
Mamdani Extends Street Fair Ban Through 2027 to Prevent NYPD From Accidentally Enjoying Zeppoles

Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed an executive order extending the citywide street fair moratorium through 2027, citing the risk that NYPD overtime calculations might accidentally include a vendor selling fried dough. The city hall administration stressed that officers deployed to watch three people eat skewered cheese on Lexington Avenue must remain entirely unrefreshed.

Related: NYPD overtime: the department that bills the summer
New York City
City Hall Station
Taxi Union, Uber and Hedge Fund That Owns 3,000 Medallions Agree Drivers Need Healthcare

The Taxi Workers Alliance, Uber and MarbleGate Capital, which owns thousands of taxi medallions, are pressing lawmakers to redirect the 50-cent yellow cab surcharge—currently funding the MTA at about $24 million a year—into a driver health fund. The coalition cited four driver deaths this summer. The MTA, which has received the surcharge since 2009, was not part of the announcement.

Related: The Mamdani era: socialist mayor, same police commissioner
New York City
City Hall Station
Councilman Proposes Dedicated NYPD Units to Combat Car Meetups; Department Confirms It Already Has Them

A Queens councilman introduced a bill requiring the NYPD to maintain dedicated street-takeover units and quarterly reporting on tickets, tows and arrests. The department said it already deploys these teams.

Related: NYPD overtime: the department that bills the summer
New York City
The Garden & the Parking Lot
Mets Fans Told Casino Next Door Will Offer Better Odds

The Mets finished 74-88, last in the NL East, as Steve Cohen's Metropolitan Park casino heads for the Citi Field lot. Cohen said in August the roster carried 'too much risk,' a problem the slot machines will not have.

Nearby in New York City
New York City
Opinion
Area Man Opts In to Salad, Out of Bin

A Midtown worker asked the bodega cat to sign for his $20 salad. The bodega said the cat is not legal.

Nearby in New York City
New York City
Empire Bins
Brooklyn Heights Co-op Wants Bin Key Card for Cat

A co-op board asked if Empire Bins' key card works on cat flaps. DSNY confirmed containerization works.

Nearby in New York City
New York CityNew York

Eight million people, a $3 fare set in Albany, a subway line due in 2032.

New York City front page
Satire

The New York City paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Everyone quoted is made up, no real official is quoted, and the fare really is $3.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.