Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Empire Bins

Downtown Brooklyn Receives 1,700 Empire Bins While Bronx Rats Form Legal Cooperative

A group of five exceptionally large rats in tiny neckties standing outside a Brooklyn brownstone holding a clipboard and a petition against municipal containerization.AI illustration

— As Brooklyn CB2 began deploying Empire Bins for containerized garbage, local rodents responded by retaining counsel and establishing a neighborhood association. The rats noted that sidewalk dining culture is a protected municipal right.

Downtown Brooklyn received its first Empire Bins installation Tuesday, when a side-loading truck deposited a row of locked steel containers along the south curb of Montague Street at 7:40 a.m. The bins are opened by key card and emptied on a fixed schedule, and the Brooklyn Community Board 2 district office confirmed that 1,700 units are scheduled for installation across its catchment by the end of the fiscal year. The department's public notice described the program as a consolidation of refuse presentation. Residents on Clark Street reported that the previous arrangement, in which bags were set out on the sidewalk the night before collection, had been informally managed by a population of rats that residents describe as organized. That population has not, to date, submitted a comment to the board. Its representatives did so in writing on Wednesday, through a firm.

Frequently Asked

Official Questions Regarding Refuse Presentation

The department is not aware of any rodent population on Montague Street in the sense the question implies. The Empire Bin is a containerized refuse system designed for buildings over 30 units. It is locked, sealed and emptied on schedule. Any residual activity in the vicinity of the former curb set-outs is outside the scope of the program, and the department has referred the matter to the rat czar office, which has no current director.
Responsibility is shared between the department, the building owner and the Community Board. The board has requested clarification on the $55 annual tenant fee attached to the key card, which the department describes as a participation charge and the board describes as a toll. A spokesperson said the fee would be reviewed at the next scheduled meeting, which is in September 2027.
Residents may leave bags on the sidewalk until the bin is installed on their block. After installation, the department notes that sidewalk presentation is no longer the recognized method of refuse presentation. The rats' counsel has since filed a letter asking the department to define recognized. The department's reply is pending.

On Thursday, the rodent population of the Clark Street corridor filed articles of incorporation with the New York Department of State under the name the Montague Tenants' Cooperative for Open-Air Refuse Access. The filing lists a registered agent, a board of seven, and an address at a utility closet beneath the stairs of a Brooklyn Heights brownstone. The board's first resolution, passed unanimously, declares sidewalk dining a protected municipal right and states that containerization constitutes a reduction in access without notice. A cooperative spokesrodent, reached through counsel, said the group had consulted a neighborhood association and found the bins aesthetically hostile. The counsel is a real estate attorney who asked that his name not be used, citing the lease the cooperative is seeking to hold.

Pros Cons

Testimony Submitted to Community Board 2 by Montague Street Rodent Representatives

Advantages

  • +Sidewalk refuse access has been maintained without interruption since at least 1974, according to the cooperative's historical filing.
  • +The bags were always set out the night before, as the department intended.
  • +The cooperative has invested in its own sanitation operation, which it describes as non-invasive and fully self-directed.
  • +Containerization was not discussed with the cooperative prior to installation.
  • +Residents have been notified; rodents have not, a distinction the cooperative views as material.

Disadvantages

  • −The cooperative has not identified a single bag by owner.
  • −The board's inquiry into the cooperative's rent was adjourned when a representative stated that the building is a sublet situation.
  • −Testimony was delivered in a sealed plastic tub, from which the reading was inaudible.

List · Bulleted

Schedule of Installations, Downtown Brooklyn (Preliminary)

5 items
  • Montague Street — south curb, between Clinton and Court, installed Tuesday.
  • Clark Street — pending a utility survey that began in 2024 and remains open.
  • Willoughby Street — scheduled for installation, subject to the cooperative's right to be heard.
  • Schermerhorn Street — the cooperative has requested a public hearing on the bin's color.
  • Remsen Street — the bin is in place. The cooperative has not yet been informed of its location; the cooperative says it has seen the bin.

The Montague Tenants' Cooperative filed suit in Kings County Supreme Court on Monday, seeking an injunction against the department and the Brooklyn Community Board 2 to restore open-air refuse access on Montague Street. The complaint cites the Equal Protection Clause, a provision of the New York City Administrative Code concerning customary presentation, and a 1974 letter from a former district manager that describes the curb as a refuse commons. The department has not responded to the complaint. A spokesperson said it would not comment on pending litigation involving an individual or a corporation of unknown composition. The cooperative's counsel said the case would be decided on its merits, and that the rats are prepared to wait. The cooperative's proposed settlement asks the city to return the sidewalk to its prior condition, and to establish a tenant fee of one bag per week, payable in cheese.

On Friday, the department confirmed that the locked dumpster at the rear of the Clark Street lot had been closed to the public. A spokesperson said the unit was secured by key card on Thursday evening and that the card was returned to a city employee at 9:14 p.m. The employee, reached by phone, said the dumpster had been locked from the inside and that the key card had been found on the curb. The Community Board has requested an incident report. The cooperative has submitted a letter stating that it had no involvement with the lock, and that it was not in a position to hold a key card, having no hands. The matter is under review. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Where are the new Empire Bins being installed in New York City?Get the straight answer →

More from New York City

New York City front page
New York City
Empire Bins
Midtown Man Furious His Dumplings Arrived at Legal Speed

A Midtown man reported that his soup dumplings arrived at 15 miles an hour, the city's e-bike speed limit since October 2025. He described them as lukewarm and compliant.

More from Empire Bins
New York City
Moving to Jersey
Jersey City Removes Public Trash Cans to Cut Garbage Costs; New Yorkers Declare Victory

Jersey City will remove public trash cans to reduce waste-collection expenses. New York used sidewalk bags for 56 years and is still seven years from full containerization.

Related: The rat czar left; the bins arrived; the rats are reviewing both
New York City
The Garden & the Parking Lot
Mets Fans Told Casino Next Door Will Offer Better Odds

The Mets finished 74-88, last in the NL East, as Steve Cohen's Metropolitan Park casino heads for the Citi Field lot. Cohen said in August the roster carried 'too much risk,' a problem the slot machines will not have.

Nearby in New York City
New York City
City Hall Station
NYPD Has No Plans to Change Mayor

The NYPD announced that Zohran Mamdani is the mayor and that it has no plans to change that. He said the same of Commissioner Jessica Tisch in October, and a spokesperson said mayors serve at the commissioner's pleasure.

Nearby in New York City
New York City
Albany Permission Slip
Hochul: 'Only Albany May Destroy New York City'

Gov. Kathy Hochul told AI companies bracing for a catastrophe within a year that only Albany may destroy New York City. Her office said a rogue AI would also need the state's permission to lower the MTA bus fare.

Nearby in New York City
New York City
City Hall Station
Cuomo Enters Democratic Primary for Transportation Secretary

Andrew Cuomo entered the Democratic primary for transportation secretary after Gov. Kathy Hochul demanded Sean Duffy resign following the FAA ground stop. He trails.

Nearby in New York City
New York CityNew York

Eight million people, a $3 fare set in Albany, a subway line due in 2032.

New York City front page
Satire

The New York City paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Everyone quoted is made up, no real official is quoted, and the fare really is $3.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.