Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Out East

City Island Confirms It Wants Smaller Things

A City Island resident in a fishing cap in the Bronx pointing disapprovingly at a model of a tall cable-stayed bridge on a folding table at a civic meeting, the plain causeway visible through the window.AI illustration

— The civic association that sued over a 150-foot cable-stayed bridge and won the plain causeway it asked for confirmed its stance: small. A clam digger said anyone born elsewhere is a mussel sucker, permanently.

Asked whether the association would reconsider its position in light of the completed causeway, president Frank Dorsa said the group's policy has always been a preference for the smaller option in all cases, and that the causeway, which opened October 29, 2017, is what the community wanted. The 1901 span it replaced had been the island's only road link since the early twentieth century, and residents describe the replacement as a plain, low structure that does not ask anyone to look up. "We were not against progress," Dorsa said from the porch of the Lobster Pot. "We were against progress that needed a tower."

The city budgeted $149.5 million in 2012, including $100 million in federal money, for a cable-stayed span whose towers would have reached about 150 feet. The civic association called the design "totally out-of-touch," a phrase it repeated at three community board meetings and once on the sidewalk outside a deli. Tutor Perini signed a $102 million contract in 2013, and an injunction followed that delayed construction two years and forced a redesign. By the time the causeway opened, the island had spent four years insisting it had never wanted to be looked down on by anything taller than a flagpole.

Quote

Anyone born somewhere else is a mussel sucker. That's not a insult, that's the zoning.”

Walt Pruitt
Clam digger, City Island, speaking outside a bait shop on City Island Avenue
Why this lands
The island's terminology ranks residents by birthplace and writes that ranking into the zoning, which is why the population has stayed at about 4,400.

Under island usage, a clam digger is anyone born on City Island and therefore outranks everyone. A mussel sucker is anyone who lives there and was born elsewhere, a status that, residents say, does not expire. Asked whether a mussel sucker could ever become a clam digger, Pruitt said the question had come up once, in 1981, and was resolved by the island's oldest family, who declined to comment on the matter and have not commented since. The Bx29 bus remains the only public transit route to the island, and it runs at the pace the island has asked for.

Asked whether the island had considered the tall version at any point in its history, Dorsa said the question was not relevant to the association's policy, which is a preference for the smaller option in all cases, and that the island's position on height has not changed since the 1901 bridge was built and then, by the island's account, adequate. The 2012 design would have carried traffic about 150 feet above the harbor, a height the association's counsel described in court filings as "not in keeping with the character of the place." Dorsa said he could not recall what the character of the place had been before the causeway, but was confident the causeway had been it. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why did City Island sue to block a bridge and then get the flat one it asked for?Get the straight answer →

More from The Bronx

The Bronx front page
The Bronx
161st Street
Bronx Homeowner Asks to Pay His Property Taxes to His Own Mortgage, Like the Yankees

The Yankees' $84 million in 2023 payments in lieu of taxes went to Yankee Stadium bonds, not the city. A Finance Department clerk told the Throggs Neck man the program requires a team, and offered him the Mets.

Nearby in Bronx
The Bronx
Sedgwick & Charlotte
Hip Hop Museum Releases Deluxe Edition of Its Opening Date With Three Bonus Years

The Hip Hop Museum has announced openings for 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025, summer 2026 and now spring 2027. The deluxe edition adds 2028, 2029 and an unreleased 2031 that fans say is the better date.

Nearby in Bronx
The Bronx
Borough Hall
Bronx Democrats' Netflix Now Recommends 'Because You Lobbied'

The Bronx Democratic Party took $250,000 from Airbnb, and its housekeeping account spent $440,000, including on Netflix and dining tabs. The account has no ads, one profile per district leader and the donors' picks pinned to the home screen.

Nearby in Bronx
The Bronx
Opinion
I Know the Bronx From 6,000 Drives Through It

The Cross Bronx Expressway carries more than 200,000 vehicles a day, and since 2004 one of them has been my Lexus. The borough has really improved, judging by the retaining walls, and I have never once needed to get out.

Nearby in Bronx
The Bronx
The Armory
Kingsbridge Armory Remains Only Building to Outlast Four Mayors by Staying Empty

The Kingsbridge Armory has outlasted a mall, an ice rink and several mayors by staying empty. It remains on schedule for 2030.

Nearby in Bronx
The Bronx
Borough Hall
Bally's Borrows $400M, Pays Trump $115M to Leave

Bally's secured $400 million in loans for its $4 billion Ferry Point casino project. The Trump Organization will receive $115 million to exit the development deal.

Nearby in Bronx
The BronxNew York City

Birthplace of hip hop, 62nd of 62 in health, and the trench Robert Moses dug is still the main road.

The Bronx front page
Satire

The The Bronx paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real reporting and filed from the only borough on the mainland. Everyone quoted is made up, no real official is quoted, and every opening year printed here was really announced, which is the joke.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.