Poisonal
World
Poisonal
161st Street

Bronx Homeowner Asks to Pay His Property Taxes to His Own Mortgage, Like the Yankees

At a Bronx city tax office window, a middle-aged man in a Yankees cap slides a check under the glass to a clerk who is his exact double in the same Yankees cap, both of them filling out forms with total seriousness.AI illustration

— The Yankees' $84 million in 2023 payments in lieu of taxes went to Yankee Stadium bonds, not the city. A Finance Department clerk told the Throggs Neck man the program requires a team, and offered him the Mets.

Ken Duffy, 58, of Throggs Neck, arrived at the Department of Finance's Bronx business center on Tuesday with his property tax bill in one hand and a printout of a March 2023 report from the Independent Budget Office in the other. The report, which the city has not disputed, found that the Yankees' payments in lieu of taxes totaled $84 million that year and went to pay off bonds issued by the city's Industrial Development Agency to build Yankee Stadium, which opened in 2009 on former Macombs Dam parkland at the foot of 161st Street. The city, the report found, owns the land and forgoes roughly $115 million a year to own a building it does not run, rent or collect from.

"I own a semi-detached on Pelham Parkway and I'm paying my own bank," Duffy said at the counter. "So I want the same deal. I'm not asking for a stadium. I'm asking for a mortgage."

A clerk named Joanne Pacheco, a senior tax analyst, took the printout and examined it for eleven minutes. She then told him that the arrangement requires a team.

The ideaPayments in lieu of taxes, as they apply to a house in Throggs Neck

the mechanism
The Yankees do not pay the city property taxes on the stadium. Instead the Industrial Development Agency, a public authority, owns the building and leases it to a team affiliate, and the team pays a negotiated sum called a payment in lieu of taxes. That sum goes to service the tax-exempt bonds that financed the stadium. The city gets its land rent waived and the bond holders get paid. Duffy's own bill goes to the city.

Pay your tax to your own mortgage, like the Yankees

tax_bill*mortgage_share/100
9,800Amount routed to your own mortgage
At 9,800 dollars a year, the city receives nothing and the Department of Finance will require a stadium, a $2.6 billion building on former parkland, triple-tax-exempt bonds and a team.
Which slider matters more right now
One more step of Your annual property tax bill (9,800 dollars → 9,801 dollars) would raise Amount routed to your own mortgage by 1 dollars. One more step of Share you would send to your own bank (100 percent → 101 percent) would raise Amount routed to your own mortgage by 98 dollars. Share you would send to your own bank is the bigger lever at these settings.
If Your annual property tax bill were…
At 0 dollars, Amount routed to your own mortgage would be 0 dollars; at 100,000 dollars, 100,000; at 200,000 dollars, 200,000; at 300,000 dollars, 300,000; at 400,000 dollars, 400,000; and at 500,000 dollars, 500,000. You are at 9,800 dollars: 9,800 dollars.
Comparison

Yankee Stadium vs. Duffy's house

Yankee StadiumDuffy's house
Owner of the landThe cityDuffy
Owner of the buildingThe city's Industrial Development AgencyA bank
Who maintains itThe team, under the new leaseDuffy
Where the tax goesThe team's bondsThe city
Rent paid to the cityNoneNot applicable
ParkingAbout 9,000 spaces, 38% full on game days in a past reviewOne driveway, full
Frequently Asked

Department of Finance, Bronx business center: questions from the public

Only if you are a stadium.
Then you are a deck, and a deck is taxed as a deck.
The Mets have been mentioned. We have not been able to confirm whether the Mets come with the parking lot, which is legally a park.

Duffy was last seen at the counter asking whether the Mets came with the parking lot. The clerk said she would have to check with the Office of Anticipated Openings, which has not yet issued a date for a stadium-financed house in Throggs Neck, and which, according to its executive director, Hector Villanueva-Brandt, is working on the target year for the borough's next project.The stadium's garages, meanwhile, sit next door on 161st Street, a block from the Hall of Justice, and have been waiting since 2009 for October. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

How does the Yankee Stadium payment in lieu of taxes actually work, and who gets the money?Get the straight answer →

More from The Bronx

The Bronx front page
The Bronx
Opinion
Yankee Stadium Garages Still Waiting for Next October

The garages at Yankee Stadium, about 9,000 spaces built with more than $200 million in tax-exempt bonds, were 38% full on game days and had about 70 regular customers otherwise. The city's property tax on the stadium is forgone, and the stadium's own taxes pay its bonds.

Related: The House That the IDA Built: Yankee Stadium's parkland, its PILOTs and its empty garages
The Bronx
Sedgwick & Charlotte
Hip Hop Museum Releases Deluxe Edition of Its Opening Date With Three Bonus Years

The Hip Hop Museum has announced openings for 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025, summer 2026 and now spring 2027. The deluxe edition adds 2028, 2029 and an unreleased 2031 that fans say is the better date.

Nearby in Bronx
The Bronx
Borough Hall
Bronx Democrats' Netflix Now Recommends 'Because You Lobbied'

The Bronx Democratic Party took $250,000 from Airbnb, and its housekeeping account spent $440,000, including on Netflix and dining tabs. The account has no ads, one profile per district leader and the donors' picks pinned to the home screen.

Nearby in Bronx
The Bronx
Opinion
I Know the Bronx From 6,000 Drives Through It

The Cross Bronx Expressway carries more than 200,000 vehicles a day, and since 2004 one of them has been my Lexus. The borough has really improved, judging by the retaining walls, and I have never once needed to get out.

Nearby in Bronx
The Bronx
The Trench
Hunts Point Metro-North Station Postponed Until Neighborhood Finishes Digesting Trucks

The Hunts Point stop on the $3.1 billion Penn Station Access line will open last, after temporary platforms elsewhere in the borough. The MTA says Amtrak gave it 7 of 48 promised track outages, and Hunts Point will wait.

Nearby in Bronx
The Bronx
The Armory
Kingsbridge Armory Remains Only Building to Outlast Four Mayors by Staying Empty

The Kingsbridge Armory has outlasted a mall, an ice rink and several mayors by staying empty. It remains on schedule for 2030.

Nearby in Bronx
The BronxNew York City

Birthplace of hip hop, 62nd of 62 in health, and the trench Robert Moses dug is still the main road.

The Bronx front page
Satire

The The Bronx paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real reporting and filed from the only borough on the mainland. Everyone quoted is made up, no real official is quoted, and every opening year printed here was really announced, which is the joke.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.