Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Oxford Street Border

Surry Hills Takes Paddington to Court Over an Oxford Street Bench, With a 95 Per Cent Approval Rate in Its Favour

Three residents in fleece vests hold a fold-out tape measure against a park bench on Oxford Street, with a white painted line at its foot labelled BORDER, under on-camera flash.AI illustration

— The Oxford Street Border Residents' Committee lodged its first development appeal in the NSW Land and Environment Court against a bench on the Paddington side of Oxford Street. The court finalised 1,108 development-related appeals in 2025, approving 706 and refusing 37, a 95 per cent approval rate. Councils missed their statutory decision deadline in 54 per cent of those appeals.

The Oxford Street Border Residents' Committee lodged its appeal with the Land and Environment Court on a Tuesday, seeking review of Woollahra Council's failure to decide on a timber bench installed on the Paddington footpath of Oxford Street. The committee's convenor, who asked not to be named because the convenor walks past the bench every day, said the bench is facing the wrong way. The convenor said the bench faces Paddington. "It should face us," the convenor said. "It has been looking at them since it went in." The committee's grounds for appeal list no planning breach, no safety concern and no noise. The committee's stated grounds are that the bench faces the wrong suburb.

Chronology of the Appeal

🪑Day 0
Application lodged
The application for the bench is lodged with Woollahra Council, which governs the Paddington side of the street. The application was lodged with no objection on record from either suburb.
⏱️Day 40
Standard decision deadline passes
No decision is issued within the 40-day window set for a statutory decision deadline on an application of this kind. The bench remains unassessed and unoccupied.
⚖️Day 62
Appeal lodged with the court
The committee files its development appeal and names the bench as the sole exhibit. It is the first appeal the committee has ever lodged.
📅Unset
Matter not yet listed
The court has not yet set a hearing date for the appeal, and the bench has not moved. Nothing in the file indicates which side the bench will be asked to face.

Development-Related Appeals Finalised by the Land and Environment Court, 2025

Outcome of decided appeals
Approved
95 per cent of decided appeals
706 appeals
Refused
5 per cent of decided appeals
37 appeals
0200400600
appeals—Appeals
Reading the court's record
Of 743 decided appeals, 706 were approved and 37 refused. The committee's convenor says the bench is not a development and should not be counted.

Woollahra Council did not decide the bench application within the standard period and has not said when it will. The City of Sydney, which governs the Surry Hills side, did not respond to questions about the bench and has not taken a position on which side of it is the lesser. A Surry Hills resident who declined to be named said the bench was never really the point. "It's about who has to walk past it," the resident said, and then, after a pause, "Obviously it's them." The convenor said the matter would be heard in the court's ordinary list. The rivalry between the two suburbs has been running on this corridor for longer than anyone on it can remember. Larger proposals are given 60 days. The bench has been given 40, and it is still facing Paddington. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

How does a development appeal work in the NSW Land and Environment Court, and who can file one?Get the straight answer →

More from Surry Hills

Surry Hills front page
Surry Hills
Raper Street
Brett Whiteley Studio Update Reports Works Progressing, Visitor Parking Still Under Review

The Brett Whiteley Studio has issued its latest Raper Street update, reporting incremental progress on the building. Visitor parking is still under review, as it was in the last update.

Nearby in Surry Hills
Surry Hills
Good Food
City of Sydney Drafts First Menu Rule for Surry Hills Omakase Counter Reviewed as Having None

City of Sydney planners have drafted a development control requiring Wai's Omakase to publish a menu, after a Good Food review described the counter as having no published menu and no rules. The draft exempts private bookings on Fridays and Saturdays, the only nights the counter operates. The only rules that apply to the counter will be the ones that exempt it.

Nearby in Surry Hills
Surry Hills
Auction Room
Surry Hills Agency Counts Withdrawn Auctions as 'Still in Conversation' in Weekly Clearance Report

Ashgrove Property Group's weekly clearance report now counts withdrawn homes as still in conversation, lifting its Surry Hills figure above the 48 per cent Sydney-wide preliminary rate. Its Surry Hills table lists a Meta by Starck warehouse unit that sold for $2,250,000, $150,000 under reserve, beside homes still in conversation. Under Ashgrove's method, a home is never fully sold while anyone is still talking about it.

Nearby in Surry Hills
Surry Hills
The Tolled City
Jetstar Adds Badgerys-to-Mascot Flights for Passengers Trying to Reach Sydney

Western Sydney International opened Oct 25 with its metro due 'by the 2030s', the M12 unfinished and a $25 bus. The new hop to Kingsford Smith keeps the first flight's 20-minute delay as a heritage feature.

Nearby in Sydney
Surry Hills
Macquarie Street
First-Home Buyer Grant Now Includes Turf Club Membership to Vote on Housing

In May 2025, 56.1% of voting Australian Turf Club members rejected selling Rosehill for 25,000 homes and a metro station. Recipients now get a members' badge, a fascinator and a vote on whether they get a home.

Nearby in Sydney
Surry Hills
Sydney Is Dead
David Jones, 188, Dies in City Where People Only Buy Houses

The department store, founded in Sydney in 1838, entered voluntary administration on Nov 5 after talks with landlords failed. It is survived by its landlords and a median house price of $1,178,959.

Nearby in Sydney
Surry HillsSydney

Still a village, at village-of-the-future prices, with parking to match.

Surry Hills front page
Satire

The Surry Hills paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Everyone quoted is made up, and no real official is quoted.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.