Surry Hills Agency Counts Withdrawn Auctions as 'Still in Conversation' in Weekly Clearance Report
AI illustration
Surry Hills — Ashgrove Property Group's weekly clearance report now counts withdrawn homes as still in conversation, lifting its Surry Hills figure above the 48 per cent Sydney-wide preliminary rate. Its Surry Hills table lists a Meta by Starck warehouse unit that sold for $2,250,000, $150,000 under reserve, beside homes still in conversation. Under Ashgrove's method, a home is never fully sold while anyone is still talking about it.
The category appears in the weekly report's Surry Hills table beside sold, passed in and withdrawn. Ashgrove staff apply it to any withdrawn auction where a vendor, buyer or agent has not said goodbye. Sydney's weekend auctions produced 564 results and 208 withdrawn homes, and the agency's Surry Hills figure is built on the same clearance rate formula used across the city. The only difference is the new column. Under the new column, a withdrawn home is never reported as finished. Ashgrove said the change took effect in the report published this week.
A home qualifies if it was withdrawn, passed in or otherwise removed from auction and at least one party has not ended contact. The agency describes this as ongoing interest, which it counts as market activity. Silence from the parties is treated as a pause in the conversation, not an outcome.
No. A withdrawn home is not recorded as sold, but it is recorded as engaged, which the agency places in the same column as a sale for the purposes of the weekly clearance report. The distinction is maintained in a footnote that the report's readers are not asked to read. A home can be engaged without anyone having agreed to anything.
The home is reclassified. Ashgrove has not yet published a report in which a conversation of this type ended, and the agency declined to estimate how long the process takes. The 48 per cent Sydney-wide preliminary figure is calculated on a different basis, which the agency does not comment on. The reclassification has no scheduled date.
Comparison
Surry Hills Weekend Auction Results, Counted Two Ways
Sydney-wide preliminary method
Ashgrove method
Sold at auction
Counted as sold
Counted as sold
Withdrawn
Not counted
Still in conversation (counted toward rate)
Passed in
Counted as unsold
Still in conversation (counted toward rate)
Sydney preliminary rate
48 per cent, from 564 results
Surry Hills figure reported above 48 per cent
The Meta by Starck two-bedroom at 313/148 Goulburn Street, a 151 square metre corner unit, had a guide of $2,000,000. Bidding moved in $50,000 steps, then $25,000 steps, and the unit sold for $2,250,000, which is $150,000 under a $2.4 million reserve. The buyer and vendor are private and have not been named. Ashgrove's table lists the sale on the same page as homes still in conversation, and the agency has not said which row is finished. Sydney's preliminary clearance rate for the weekend was 48 per cent, from 564 results. ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.