Santa Clara Council Resolves To Bill 49ers Only For Grass Trampled By Winning Teams
AI illustration
Silicon Valley — The Santa Clara city council voted 5-2 Tuesday to amend the Levi's Stadium lease, ruling that municipal police overtime charges apply solely to visiting squads that secure a victory while maintaining an upright posture on municipal turf.
The amendment, drafted by the city attorney's office and presented to the council on Tuesday, sets a two-tier schedule for the police overtime that Levi's Stadium pays the city for each home game. Under the new language, a visiting squad that wins owes the city for its own police detail in full. A visiting squad that loses owes the city nothing, provided it leaves the field "in a condition consistent with municipal turf standards," a phrase that appears eleven times in the document and is not defined anywhere. The 49ers, who play their home games on the city-adjacent land under a lease that runs through the next decade, were not a party to the vote and did not respond to a request for comment.
The ordinance's sponsor, Councilmember Dale Okafor-Lindqvist, described the change as "a clarification of how the reimbursement schedule was always meant to read." Asked where in the original lease that meaning appears, he referred questions to the city attorney, who referred them back to the sponsor.
The council's staff report includes a turf-wear index, developed over six weeks by the Parks and Recreation Department, that scores each team's post-game footprint on a scale from one to ten. Staff say the index was calibrated against the grass at Levi's, which has been resodded twice since the stadium opened, and against a control plot at the Central Park athletic fields, which has not been resodded in recorded memory. A team that finishes the game "upright and in control of its gait" scores a zero and owes nothing. A team that finishes "on the ground, through the ground, or in a manner the officer on duty considered injurious to the field" scores a seven or above, triggering a police detail for the following home game at the visitor's expense.
The index has no published formula. Parks staff said it is "being thoughtful about the methodology," and that the full scoring rubric will be released after the next council meeting, which has been scheduled for a date that has not yet been set.
Memo
SC
City of Santa Clara, Police Department
Serving the Field
To:
Command Staff, Stadium Detail
From:
Lt. Ray Dumbrowski, Stadium Liaison Division
Date:
October 14
Re:
Reassignment of Sideline Personnel Under Revised Reimbursement Schedule
Effective immediately, the Stadium Detail will reassign personnel under the revised turf-wear reimbursement schedule adopted by council. The following changes take effect for the next home game.
Reassignments:
•Four (4) officers previously assigned to crowd management at Gate C are reassigned to sideline mascot escort duties.
•Officers will escort the Gold Rush mascot along the 40-yard line to ensure it remains upright at all times, as the mascot's footprint is scored under the turf-wear index.
•A patrol car will be parked on the east end zone to monitor grass conditions in real time.
Terminology:
•"Upright" means standing without assistance on turf, excluding officers.
•"Injurious" means any contact with the field that the officer on duty recognizes as injurious, as determined by the officer on duty.
•"Mascot" is considered a visiting squad member for the purposes of this schedule unless the mascot is wearing the team jersey, in which case it is a home squad member.
Questions regarding the new assignment should be directed to the Stadium Liaison Division. Please do not direct questions about the mascot's jersey status to the mascot.
Stay upright,
Lt. Ray Dumbrowski, Stadium Liaison Division
Officer Eduardo Platt escorts the stadium mascot along the 40-yard line during Tuesday's rehearsal of the upright posture standard.
Mayor Lisa Gillmor, who chairs the Stadium Authority and whose term ends in December, said the revised schedule reflects the council's commitment to fiscal responsibility at the stadium. "We have always asked what it costs the city when a visiting team falls down," Gillmor said. "Now we have a number for it. It's zero, if they're standing."
The city's current police reimbursement arrangement with the stadium totals roughly $6 million for the Super Bowl LX detail alone, a figure the city has previously described as "the cost of being a host." Under the new schedule, Gillmor said, the Super Bowl detail would be assessed on the outcome of the game, a determination she said the city attorney is still working out.
A resident of the Old Town neighborhood, who has lived across the street from the stadium since 2003, said she had hoped the council would address the afternoon sun on the east seats, which she said has been a source of complaints from fans for years. The city has not addressed the east stands in the amendment. Staff said the sun is not a municipal turf matter.
"I don't know what a turf-wear index is," said Carla Denholm, who has attended forty-one home games. "I just wanted somebody to say the sun is a problem."
The amendment passed 5-2. The two dissenting votes came from councilmembers who said the turf-wear index should be subject to independent review before it is applied to any team. Both said they would prefer the index be scored by a neutral third party, a suggestion the council did not take up.
The city has not said whether the reimbursement schedule will apply to the Super Bowl LX game, the sun on the east stands, or the Great America Amusement Park, which is scheduled to reopen next season on a countdown the city says it is still being thoughtful about. The council's next meeting is expected to set a date for the release of the turf-wear rubric, and the Stadium Liaison Division has asked that all officers continue to keep the mascot upright. ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.