San Jose — SJPD claims overtime fell after recruiting two lateral transfers, one named Overtime. The city auditor reported overtime still cost $72 million last year with only 998 of 1,172 budgeted officers staffed.
The department said overtime fell 12 percent in the quarter after Officer Luis Overtime reported for duty, a drop it attributes to Overtime himself. Under the San Jose Police Department's new accounting, each officer hired is recorded as savings equal to the overtime that officer would otherwise have caused by not being there.
The department hired two officers. It counted each of them twice: once at the swearing-in in March and once at a second swearing-in in June, held because the first one had gone well.
"Officer Overtime is our most cost-effective hire," said Lt. Brian Castaneda, the department's Fiscal Recovery Coordinator. "Every hour he isn't working overtime is an hour of overtime we aren't paying. He has been very consistent about that."
Comparison
SJPD Staffing Savings Ledger, Fiscal Year 2026 (Department Copy)
| Hire date | Recorded savings | New officers on patrol |
|---|
| Ofc. Luis Overtime | March | Credited | 1 |
| Ofc. Karen Holt | March | Credited | 1 |
| Ofc. Luis Overtime | June | Credited | 0 |
| Ofc. Karen Holt | June | Credited | 0 |
| Recruiting video featuring both officers | August | Credited | 0 |
City Auditor Joe Rois did not use the ledger. His 2026 audit put police overtime at $72 million for the year, with 998 of 1,172 budgeted officers on staff, a gap two lateral transfers close by two, or four if they attend both ceremonies.
The department said the audit predated Officer Overtime's second hiring. It said the savings from the recruiting video would appear in next year's figures, once the video has been watched.
share of Priority 1 emergency calls reached within the 6-minute target
Context
Average response ran past 8 minutes. The department said both officers were on the ledger at the time.
San Jose City Auditor, 2026 police overtime audit
Maria Tran, who called police from her apartment off Story Road in July, said the officers who arrived were not Overtime or Holt. "They told me they were on hour fourteen," Tran said. "I offered them coffee. They said it would count against the savings."
The announcement is the department's third overtime reduction of the year, following the reduction in which overtime was renamed extended shift continuity.Both officers become eligible for overtime in January. ■