Poisonal
World
Poisonal
High-Density

North Scottsdale Neighbors Oppose Church's 'Many Mansions' Plan as Too Dense

— A north Scottsdale church proposing senior housing cited the promise of many mansions, in a city that grew 0.7% in five years. Neighbors told the council the Father's house should remain single-family.

The application, filed by the church's pastor, quotes John 14:2 on its cover page and proposes three single-story senior apartments per acre on land the congregation already owns north of Shea. It reached the neighborhood HOA's design review committee, which returned the site plan with a single correction stuck to the corner.

Design Review

mansions: fine. many: no. gates — reduce gold.

The note was entered into the record at Tuesday's hearing at Scottsdale City Hall, where 41 residents signed up to speak. The first asked the applicant how many units many is, and whether the number had been reviewed by a traffic engineer or only by Scripture.

"With respect to the pastor, heaven has never had to deal with Pima Road at 5 p.m.," said Carol Henning, a retired orthodontist who lives across the wash from the site. "I moved here in 1998 so nothing would be next to me. Now there is going to be something next to me."

Another speaker said she heard about density everywhere: at the club, at the pharmacy, on the trail at Gateway. Asked by a council member where in the city she had actually seen density, she named the Loop 101.

"The applicant has shown one house with many mansions, which is a shared-wall configuration by any reading," said Doug Raines, the city's Senior Planner for Residential Character. "Staff recommends the Father consider a larger lot."

The Overrun
0.7%
Scottsdale population growth, 2020 to 2025
+1,645 peopleover 5 years
Context
The city went from 241,361 residents to an estimated 243,006, a gain that would fit in the lower bowl at the 16th hole with room for the beer line.
U.S. Census, 2020 count and 2025 estimate, via Wikipedia

The council voted 4-3 to continue the item pending a second study of how many mansions is too many. The pastor thanked the council and said the congregation would pray on the setbacks.

The study will not examine the McDowell Sonoran Preserve, which covers about 30,500 acres of the city and has never once been called overdeveloped.Residents asked that the mansions be built there instead, provided no one lives in them. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why does Scottsdale keep voting against overdevelopment when its population barely grew?Get the straight answer →

More from Scottsdale

Scottsdale front page
Scottsdale
The Coliseum
Scottsdale Residents Ask Whether 20,000-Seat Grandstand Qualifies as High-Density

A council filing asks if a 20,000-seat grandstand around a 162-yard hole is multifamily housing. The city attorney said it ends in February.

Related: 'High-density': the only issue, in a city that is 184 square miles and one-third preserve
Scottsdale
Finality
Axon-Funded Campaign Succeeds in Making Scottsdale Election About Axon

Axon and three executives gave $1.12 million to a PAC, and Councilman Barry Graham heard about Axon 'everywhere I went.' He won re-election by 2,427 votes, which Axon may now book as name recognition.

Nearby in Scottsdale
Scottsdale
Mailing Address
Scottsdale Woman Ends Date Upon Learning His Scottsdale Address Is in Phoenix

Her date's 85254 ZIP code reads 'Scottsdale, AZ' on every envelope, but his house near Kierland Commons is inside Phoenix. She told friends she could not see a future in the wrong tax base.

Nearby in Scottsdale
Scottsdale
Toilets to Taps
Scottsdale Water Offers Council-Elect Free Tasting of the Scam

Michelle Ugenti-Rita won a council seat opposing an 'unproven toilet-to-tap scam,' one aquifer detour from what the Scottsdale Water Campus already does. The campus invited her to a tasting of the 2019 scam lager.

Nearby in Scottsdale
Scottsdale
The Airpark
Scottsdale Counts Private Jet Route to Cabo as Its First Mass Transit

The largest American city never to have a rail line now has JSX service from Scottsdale Airport to Cabo San Lucas. Planners note it already goes farther than the Tempe streetcar, which stops at the city line.

Nearby in Scottsdale
Scottsdale
Phoenix Unified
Mesa Schools List Portables on Zillow as Starter Homes

After voters rejected a $449 million bond, Mesa Public Schools posted its portables as move-in-ready studios near great schools. The listings sat 76 days, matching the Valley average.

Nearby in Phoenix Metro
ScottsdaleArizona

The West's Most Western Town, with a Hermès, no train, and finality on Axon, pending appeal.

Scottsdale front page
Satire

The Scottsdale paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Nobody real is quoted, the 70 acres declined comment, and the numbers are the only thing we didn't make up. Not in Phoenix, whatever the envelope says.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.