Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Below the Portal

Neighbors Reject Developer's Faith in the Lancaster Avenue Trolley

On Lancaster Avenue in West Philadelphia, rows of neighbors in folding chairs on the sidewalk silently watch an empty trolley stop, while a developer in a suit stands beside a tabletop architectural model of an apartment tower, checking his watch.AI illustration

— Haverford Square Properties proposed 420 apartments with 65 parking spaces on Lancaster Avenue, arguing the trolley cuts the need for cars. Neighbors voted 21-4 against, and one asked when its executives last rode the trolley.

The zoning board's examiner, who was appointed to the case in August, spent the first hour of the Oct. 14 hearing asking the developer's traffic consultant to confirm, in writing, that the trolley runs. The consultant confirmed it. The examiner then asked for the schedule, the ridership, and the date of the most recent service interruption on the line. Haverford Square Properties did not have the last one. "We were assuming the service was reliable," the consultant said. "That is the assumption we are asking the board to make." The examiner wrote the word assumption down and underlined it twice. Neighbors who attended said the board had not asked a developer to justify a transit assumption in anyone's memory. It usually takes its word for the bus.

Interview Transcript
Cathedral Park Community Development Meeting, Excerpt
Community meeting, Lancaster Avenue, 50th to 52nd Streets
DEVELOPER REPRESENTATIVE:
[clicks to next slide] The T1 provides frequent, reliable service, which is why we are confident that 420 units can be supported with 65 parking spaces.
RESIDENT:
Can you tell us when the tunnel was last open for a full week?
DEVELOPER REPRESENTATIVE:
I don't have that figure in front of me.
RESIDENT:
[reads from phone] I do. It was closed January 2026 for the wire. Then four weekends in late August and September for a water-damaged substation. Would you like the dates?
DEVELOPER REPRESENTATIVE:
[long pause] We would be happy to follow up.
RESIDENT:
Hold on. My sister's car is at the 40th Street portal and she says it's a beer garden now.
MODERATOR:
Let's move to questions about the setback.

The Line, as Maintained

Dec. 15, 1906
Tunnel opens
The trolley tunnel under Penn's campus opens to service. Five lines enter at the 40th Street portal.
Early 2025
Lines renamed T1 through T5
SEPTA renames the five tunnel routes. Lancaster Avenue's Route 10 becomes the T1. Locals keep calling it the 10.
2025
Narrower pole sliders installed
SEPTA replaces 3-inch trolley-pole sliders with 4-inch ones to save money. The carbon wears through and damages the overhead wire.
January 2026
Tunnel reopens
Service resumes after the wire repair. Riders are advised to keep their expectations at the same carbon thickness as before.
Aug. 29 to Sept. 28, 2026
Four weekends closed
The tunnel shuts for a water-damaged substation. Four weekends in a row, the trolley is replaced by a bus that drives over the trolley's tracks.
Spring 2027
New trolleys due
The first of 130 new cars, about $5 million each, arrives. The rest follow through 2030. Delivery is described as on track.

The developer's filing argues that the trolley cuts the need for cars, which is a reasonable argument for a line that runs, and a bold one for a line that has been running in 1906 as a sort of event. The Cathedral Park Community Development Corporation voted 21-4 against the plan. Nov. 7, the Inquirer's headline on the next round read that the plan "hits roadblock at the zoning board." Neighbors said they had not expected the zoning board to be the most reliable part of the process. "We have a schedule for the 10," one resident said. "It is the schedule for the zoning board that nobody can predict."

Asked for comment on the developer's revised plan, which as of Nov. 7 reportedly lists 420 apartments and 420 bicycle spaces, Haverford Square Properties said it looked forward to working with the community. A spokesperson said the project would continue to rely on the T1 for transit, and that the company was committed to ensuring riders can reach the line. The examiner has asked for the next scheduled interruption in writing, and the board has set the next hearing for January. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Is the trolley actually reliable enough to justify building housing with fewer parking spaces on Lancaster Avenue?Get the straight answer →

More from West Philadelphia

West Philadelphia front page
West Philadelphia
Black Bottom Desk
Philadelphia Pays Black Bottom Back in Street Signs

Philadelphia cleared Black Bottom for Penn, Drexel and the Science Center, displacing about 5,000 residents by 1970. This fall it put the name on one block, and a state marker due in early 2027 will complete payment.

Nearby in West Philadelphia
West Philadelphia
In Lieu Of
Penn Offers City a Payment in Lieu of Payments in Lieu of Taxes

Penn pays no PILOT, and its $10 million a year to the School District is about 0.03% of a $31.1 billion endowment. Its new program adds a framed thank-you letter for each school the district has not closed.

Nearby in West Philadelphia
West Philadelphia
The Catchment
University City Couple Pays $200,000 Extra to Live Across the Street

Penn Alexander's catchment runs more than $200,000 above the rest of University City, so a couple moved across the street. Kindergarten there is free, they told friends, after closing costs.

Nearby in West Philadelphia
West Philadelphia
Clark Park to Cobbs Creek
Cobbs Creek Opens 19th Hole First

The city leased the 350-acre public course for $1 a year, and its first new building has a tavern. Holes 1 through 18 remain in fundraising, at $180 million.

Nearby in West Philadelphia
West Philadelphia
Nobody Likes Us
Philadelphia Boos Every Athlete, Re-Elects Every Incumbent

Voters who booed Jordan Walker during All-Star Game introductions gave Larry Krasner 75 percent and Josh Shapiro a second term. Poll workers said several residents booed the ballot, then filled it in exactly as before.

Nearby in Philadelphia
West Philadelphia
Eds & Meds
Private Equity Frees Hahnemann Land From the Hospital That Was Blocking It

The private-equity owner that closed Hahnemann University Hospital in 2019 kept its Center City real estate out of the bankruptcy filing. A spokesman said the land had endured 171 years of patients and was finally free to appreciate.

Nearby in Philadelphia
West PhiladelphiaPhiladelphia

Bought for $1, renamed by realtors, policed to 43rd Street, and still called University City out to 52nd.

West Philadelphia front page
Satire

The West Philadelphia paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real West Philly reporting. Every quote is invented, every number is sourced, and the catchment line is, unfortunately, real.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.