City Council Unveils Automated Testimony Machine That Automatically Thanks Residents Before They Reach the Microphone
AI illustrationPhiladelphia — City Council leaders demonstrated a new efficiency kiosk in Room 400 on Thursday designed to bypass public comment entirely by generating standardized gratitude statements for all local speakers. Perpetual commenter Donna Marie Scarduzio reportedly spent four hours arguing with the digital podium over her allotted three minutes.
- To:
- All Councilmembers and Legislative Aides
- From:
- Gerald Mahoney, Director of Floor Operations
- Date:
- November 20, 2026
- Re:
- Rollout of the Automated Testimony Acknowledgment Unit
Effective Thursday, all public comment will be acknowledged in advance, freeing members from the need to look up during it.
- •Testimony: the period between a resident standing and a resident sitting.
- •Heard: the state of having been thanked.
- •Input: see Heard.
- •The unit's gratitude statement runs nine seconds, saving an estimated two minutes and fifty-one seconds per speaker.
- •Members may continue reviewing their phones as before.
- •Residents who keep talking after being thanked will be logged as having testified twice.
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.
How does public comment at Philadelphia City Council meetings work, and how much time do residents get?Get the straight answer →



