Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Rent Freeze

Dolores Pinkwater Endorses Rent Freeze Despite Neighbor's Music

AI illustration

— At a Rent Guidelines Board hearing, Dolores Pinkwater testified about both a rent freeze and her neighbor's loud music in 4B. Board staff said she has gone off-topic every year since 1994.

Ms. Pinkwater, 81, of Kew Gardens Hills, arrived at El Museo del Barrio before the sign-in sheet had been placed on the table, according to a Rent Guidelines Board staff member who asked not to be named because the staff member has also testified. She took the first speaking slot, as she has at every hearing since 1994, and was called after five hours of public comment that the board had already decided to hear in full out of what staff described as courtesy.

She opened by endorsing the freeze. "I support a rent freeze for all one million stabilized apartments," she told the panel, "and I say that as a person who has heard every rent increase since the Carter administration." The board, which voted 7-1 to hold rents flat on roughly 1,000,000 units, did not respond. Its chair thanked her. Her remaining time was then spent on the unit above hers.

Ms. Pinkwater then turned to 4B. "The music in 4B has been on since the Clinton administration," she said. "I filed a complaint in 1998. It is still open. I would like the board to be aware that it is still open." Board counsel, who has taken the minutes at every hearing for the past nine years, asked whether the complaint concerned rent. Ms. Pinkwater said it concerned the bass.

The freeze, which takes effect for the next lease year, covers the apartment at issue. The apartment in 4B is also stabilized. Its tenant has not been reached for comment, and neither has the bass.

Board staff said the chair has thanked Ms. Pinkwater at every hearing she has attended, a practice that predates the current membership and that no current member could explain. "She is a fixture," one staff member said. "We don't have a procedure for her. We have a thank-you." The board's next meeting is scheduled for the fall. Ms. Pinkwater has already signed up for the first slot, and has submitted written remarks on the bass that staff say run to fourteen pages and cite a complaint that was never closed. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

How do residents file a noise complaint about a neighbor with the city's Department of Environmental Protection, and does a rent freeze change what happens next?Get the straight answer →

More from New York City

New York City front page
New York City
Rent Freeze
Columbia Admitting Fewer New Yorkers, More of New York

Columbia University, which enrolled 1,416 city undergraduates in 2022, down from 2,236, mailed acceptance letters this week to eleven Morningside Heights buildings. Admissions said the buildings interviewed well and would not need housing.

More from Rent Freeze
New York City
Rent Freeze
Tenants Win Right to Buy Buildings Already at Auction

The Community Opportunity to Purchase Act takes effect November 2027. A year prior, 38 East Harlem buildings went to foreclosure sale.

Related: The Rent Guidelines Board: nine people, one million leases, a mayor's thumb
New York City
Empire Bins
the recorder of deeds Testifies That Empire Bins Violate Her Grandmother's Kitchen Etiquette

the recorder of deeds addressed the Rent Guidelines Board for forty-seven uninterrupted minutes concerning containerized garbage lids. Board members stared blankly into their briefing packets.

Related: The Rent Guidelines Board: nine people, one million leases, a mayor's thumb
New York City
The Garden & the Parking Lot
Mets Fans Told Casino Next Door Will Offer Better Odds

The Mets finished 74-88, last in the NL East, as Steve Cohen's Metropolitan Park casino heads for the Citi Field lot. Cohen said in August the roster carried 'too much risk,' a problem the slot machines will not have.

Nearby in New York City
New York City
City Hall Station
Cuomo Enters Democratic Primary for Transportation Secretary

Andrew Cuomo entered the Democratic primary for transportation secretary after Gov. Kathy Hochul demanded Sean Duffy resign following the FAA ground stop. He trails.

Nearby in New York City
New York City
Opinion
Area Man Opts In to Salad, Out of Bin

A Midtown worker asked the bodega cat to sign for his $20 salad. The bodega said the cat is not legal.

Nearby in New York City
New York CityNew York

Eight million people, a $3 fare set in Albany, a subway line due in 2032.

New York City front page
Satire

The New York City paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Everyone quoted is made up, no real official is quoted, and the fare really is $3.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.