Federal Judge Rules Tax of Zero Dollars Invalidates Gun Registration Law
AI illustration
United States — A federal judge found that with the tax set at $0, the 1934 National Firearms Act lost its legal basis, and the ATF now calls registration 'voluntary.' The original stamp was $200 and was never indexed to inflation, so the law was already nearly free before anyone repealed it.
The ruling turns on a single cell. The National Firearms Act was written in 1934 as a tax, because Congress could tax machine guns more easily than it could ban them. The registry existed to make sure the tax got paid. With the tax at $0, the court held, there is nothing left to collect, so the government has no reason to keep a list of who owes it.
No member of Congress cast a vote on guns. The change rode in on a tax line of the OBBB, passed through reconciliation with a cross-reference to the excise code.
Federal tax stamp to own a short-barreled shotgun, 1934
THEN · 1934$200
ACTUAL, TODAY$0
CHANGE×0.0
The price fell about 100% over 92 years. Congress never indexed the stamp to inflation, then finished the job with a zero.
Prices in USD, as given; the change is computed from the two prices, not adjusted for inflation.
On Oct. 9 the ATF released an open letter calling registration voluntary. The bureau says it will keep the forms available for anyone who wants to fill them out.
"We have a fully staffed registry and a price of nothing," said Carol Henning, the bureau's Deputy Chief of Optional Compliance. "Demand is about what you would expect for a free product that comes with a federal background check. Our processing times have never been better."
Frequently Asked
ATF Guidance: Registration Under a $0 Tax
Registration remains available. The bureau encourages owners to register in the same spirit as signing a guestbook.
Your payment is on file and was appreciated. The ruling does not address money the government already has.
Those records are under review. They may be grandfathered, ungrandfathered, or kept as historical documents of a time when the tax cost something.
Then the bureau would have a law again.
Gun owners who registered under the old system have asked whether their paperwork still counts.
"I waited nine months and paid two hundred dollars to be on a list," said Dale Rourke, a retired machinist from Tulsa. "Now the list is a hobby. I'd like the nine months back."The bureau said it would not delete existing records, since deleting them would cost money. ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.