Poisonal
World
Poisonal
City Hall

Wilmington Says Solving Bancroft Fire Would Make the File Public

In a wood-paneled Wilmington, Delaware, city law office, two lawyers in suits gently tuck a thick fire-department file folder into a baby's crib and rock it to sleep, while a fire investigator in turnout gear tiptoes out of the room holding his helmet.AI illustration

— Wilmington's lawyers warned that naming a cause for the 2016 Bancroft Mills fire would close the case and open the file. Investigators agreed to stay undetermined for as long as it takes.

The guidance arrived in a two-page memo from the City of Wilmington Law Department to the Wilmington Fire Marshal's Office, obtained by Poisonal News from a folder labeled Ongoing. It walks investigators through Attorney General Opinion 21-IB06, which in March 2021 let the city keep most of the Bancroft file private because the cause had never been determined and the conclusion could still be revised.

The memo's author, Assistant City Solicitor Karen Dwyer, drew the lesson in plain English. A fire with no cause is an open investigation. An open investigation is an investigatory file. An investigatory file stays in the basement of the Louis L. Redding City/County Building.

Memo
CWL
City of Wilmington Law Department
800 N. French St. Ask Again Later.
To:
Fire Marshal's Office, All Investigators
From:
Karen Dwyer, Assistant City Solicitor
Date:
November 18, 2026
Re:
Records Exposure Arising From Conclusions

Following AG Opinion 21-IB06, the department's records position rests on three points.

The Opinion, Simplified:
  • •Undetermined means open.
  • •Open means withheld.
  • •Determined means a reporter from the News Journal gets a box.
Terminology:
  • •Cause: a records event.
  • •Hunch: a draft cause. Do not write it down.
  • •Because: avoid any sentence ending in this word.

Investigators who feel a conclusion forming should step outside, look at the Brandywine and wait for it to pass.

Going Forward:
  • •Prior designations such as 'UNDETERMINED/CLOSED' were a drafting error. The second word should never have been there.
Thank you for not knowing.
Karen Dwyer, Assistant City Solicitor

The memo's last bullet refers to September 2020, when the Bancroft file was in fact marked UNDETERMINED/CLOSED, a month after News Journal reporter Xerxes Wilson asked for it. By December the city was describing the file as one it still might prosecute.

A training deck followed. One slide shows investigators how to describe a four-alarm fire at an abandoned mill using only nouns. Another advises against bringing up the 2015 fire during demolition, which outlets at the time called suspicious, on the grounds that a pattern is a kind of conclusion.

A second memo extends the guidance to the Mother African Union Church fire. On Oct. 27 the department classified that fire undetermined and said the investigation will remain open. Deputy Chief Andre Cooper declined to release the engineer's report, and Spotlight Delaware's records request is still pending. Dwyer's memo calls the wording correct on the first try.

"The nice thing about not knowing is that you can keep doing it indefinitely," Dwyer said. "It's very low maintenance."

"I just wanted the reports," said Denise Holloway, who lives near the old mill site off the Brandywine. "It's been ten years. At some point not knowing is a decision."The fire marshal's office signed a reply agreeing to stay undetermined for as long as it takes. Dwyer's memo was not released. The city said it is part of an open investigation. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why can Delaware cities keep fire investigation records secret when the cause is never determined?Get the straight answer →

More from Wilmington

Wilmington front page
Wilmington
Chancery & Co.
ChristianaCare Declares State Regulator Out of Network

ChristianaCare declared the Diamond State Hospital Cost Review Board out of network, months after its lawsuit cost the board its budget veto. Board members may still examine ChristianaCare's spending at the self-pay rate.

Related: The Delaware Way
Wilmington
Schools
Redding Consortium Postpones School Merger Until Timeline Overtakes Student Lifespans

Citing complex boundary harmonizations, the Redding Consortium pushed implementation into the 2030s, ensuring current kindergarteners reach retirement age before consolidation.

Related: The Delaware Way
Wilmington
City Hall
Biden Presidential Library Site Selection Committee to Meet When Funding Becomes Available, Which Is Now

The Presidential Library Site Selection Committee announced a meeting date for the Joe Biden library project once the city or county contributed the pledged funds—at which point Mayor Carney, seated across from an empty chair, declared the committee ready to convene ''immediately.''

More from City Hall
Wilmington
City Hall
Highlands Man Backs Affordable Homes After Checking Map Twice

A homeowner reversed his opposition after verifying the $8.4 million project wouldn't affect his neighborhood. The affordable homes will go to Browntown, Riverside, and the Eastside.

More from City Hall
Wilmington
DuPont Country
Delaware Learns It Got DuPont's Hometown Discount

In 2021 DuPont and its spinoffs paid Delaware $50 million, with up to $25 million more if another state did better. In 2025 New Jersey got $875 million, and Delaware's clause topped out at a $25 million consolation prize.

Nearby in Wilmington
Wilmington
Philly's Little Brother
Blue Rocks Win Delaware's Major League Title by Forfeit

Delaware has no major league team, so its flagship is the Wilmington Blue Rocks, the Washington Nationals' High-A affiliate. The state's two Division I football teams, Delaware and Delaware State, are both exactly 5-5.

Nearby in Wilmington
WilmingtonDelaware

Three rivers, one court, 300,000 neighbors who never visit.

Wilmington front page
Satire

The Wilmington paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Every quote is made up, especially the ones from real officials.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.