Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Napa vs. Sonoma

Napa Petitions for Its Own Appellation After Colusa Picks Its Congressman

A Napa vineyard where ballot boxes sit planted in neat trellised rows like vines, a vineyard worker in a sun hat carefully tying each box to the wire with grafting tape.AI illustration

— Napa voted for Mike Thompson 58.2 percent, but voters in Colusa, Yuba and Sutter sent Eric Jones instead. Vintners filed paperwork to make congressional representation an estate-grown product.

The petition went to the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau, the federal office that approves wine appellations, and not to any elections official. Its author, Karen Whitlock, policy director of the Napa Valley Estate Growers Council, called the bureau the only agency that understands provenance.

The filing argues that Napa voters possess terroir. It cites volcanic soil, morning fog off San Pablo Bay and "a formative upbringing up valley" as conditions that cannot be reproduced in Yuba City. Three exhibits are soil samples. A fourth is a St. Helena High School yearbook.

Section 4 proposes label terms for members of Congress.

GlossaryA–Z

Estate Representative

A member elected, counted and certified entirely on Napa County soil.

Category: Petition, Section 4

Napa Valley Representative

A member with at least 85 percent of votes sourced inside the appellation, the threshold federal labeling rules set for grapes in an AVA.

Category: Petition, Section 4

California Representative

Any member whose margin was sourced from Colusa, Yuba, Sutter, Sacramento, Lake or Placer counties. May not print the word Napa on a yard sign.

Category: Petition, Section 4

Reserve

A vote cast north of Yountville. As with the wine term, it carries no legal meaning and costs more.

Category: Petition, Section 4

Bulk

Any ballot cast east of the Vaca Range. May be blended into another district without notice.

Category: Petition, Section 4

browse terms →

Under those terms Eric Jones, who beat the 14-term incumbent 52.5 percent to 47.5 percent in the new 4th District, would serve as a California congressman and could not enter the county without a sourcing disclosure. The petition notes that Jones spent about $15 million of his own money, a price it describes as "Napa on the label, Sutter in the bottle."

"Nobody is saying a Colusa County voter is worth less," Whitlock said. "We're saying it's a different product. An AVA adds thirty dollars to a bottle, and right now it adds nothing to a ballot."

Whitlock said the county's 2026 ballots have been moved to St. Helena for cellaring.

A steel ballot drop box lying on a barrel rack between oak wine barrels in a cellar, its slot sealed with red wax.

Napa County ballots, eighteen months from release, rest in French oak.

Sonoma County vintners responded within the day, asking if votes cast in Carneros, which straddles both counties, would count toward both appellations, as its Pinot does. The bureau now has two Carneros disputes on file, one of them about grapes.

Ray Mendes, a Colusa County rice grower, submitted the only public comment so far. It observes that wineries in the Central Valley, home to Bogle and Bronco, have bought the coast's unsold fruit on the bulk market for years without anyone filing a petition.

"I pay Napa rent and I got a Yuba City congressman," said Dan Pruitt, a cellar worker in Napa. "I'd settle for somebody fixing the rent part."

The petition lists 2026 as a vintage Napa does not intend to release. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

How did Eric Jones beat Mike Thompson in California's new 4th District when Napa County voted for Thompson?Get the straight answer →

More from Wine Country

Wine Country front page
Wine Country
The Glut
Growers Line Up to Donate Unsold Vineyards to Marsh

Napa's new estuary park on South Jefferson Street returned 46 acres of former vineyard to tidal marsh with $5.06 million in state grants. Growers with uncontracted cabernet have formed a line at the trailhead holding deeds.

Related: The Great Pull-Out: vines torn out, fruit left hanging
Wine Country
Tasting Room
Yountville Moves Uncounted Mayoral Ballots to French Laundry Waitlist

With the mayor's race separated by 17 votes, remaining ballots will be counted when a table opens up. Voters may call the reservation line daily at 10 a.m. two months out.

Nearby in Wine Country
Wine Country
Use Permit
Napa Wineries Apply to Be Reclassified as Retro Video Game Lounges

After downtown's Super Lounge arcade won approval in a single cycle, four wineries filed to reopen as arcades with cabernet. Their 1984 use permits capped visitors at two a week, and arcades have no cap.

Nearby in Wine Country
Wine Country
Opinion
Ask the Sommelier: My Wine Club Ended, Am I Still Loved

A Windsor reader asks why her Sonoma-Cutrer membership became a SKU. The sommelier advises seeing other labels.

Nearby in Wine Country
Wine Country
Fire Season
Santa Rosa Man Holds FAIR Plan Envelope Up to Light

The man has examined his renewal against the kitchen window for three days. He has determined it contains a number.

Nearby in Wine Country
Wine Country
Up the 101
Healdsburg Offers to Move Street Two Minutes Closer

With SMART deciding the station site in December, the city proposed relocating the street itself to end a fight over a five-versus-seven-minute walk. Cloverdale, promised a train in 2008, asked to be moved closer to Healdsburg.

Nearby in Wine Country
Wine CountryNapa & Sonoma, California

$79 to taste it, $9.99 to buy it, a bulldozer to make it stop.

Wine Country front page
Satire

The Wine Country paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, poured from real local reporting. Every quote is made up, especially the real officials'. Tasting fee waived.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.