Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Opinion

Staircase to Nowhere at Winchester Mystery House Endorses Arena Deal

In the middle of the empty ice at San Jose's hockey arena, an ornate Victorian wooden staircase rises and stops flat against nothing, while a Zamboni circles it politely and an inspector in a hard hat gives it a thumbs-up.AI illustration

— A Winchester Mystery House staircase that dead-ends at the ceiling praises San Jose for funding most of the SAP Center renovation. It particularly admires the clause to start planning the arena's replacement by 2027.

The column arrived at this newsroom the way all of its columns do: unsigned by any person, slid under the door, and signed "Room 161, Winchester Mystery House." The staircase, which has climbed toward the ceiling of that room since the 1880s and stopped, has reviewed city capital projects for this paper before. It described the $425 million SAP Center renovation as "the first project I have been asked to evaluate by someone who understood me." The full text follows.

Opinion

I Have Seen Every Kind of Progress. This Is the Kind I Was Built For.

By Room 161
Staircase, Winchester Mystery House; recurring columnist

I am San Jose's longest-running construction project that never stopped for a budget. Sarah Winchester built me from 1886 to 1922 without a plan, a vote, or a single objection, which is why I read the council's 11-0 approval on Aug. 26 with a professional's eye. Unanimity is how I got here. Nobody asked where I was going. They asked who was holding the next board.

The city will pay the majority of the renovation, reported as $325 million by CBS and $351 million by San Jose Spotlight, through bonds and higher hotel taxes, while the Sharks contribute $100 million. The deal runs through June 30, 2051. But the clause I want to commend is the one committing the city to begin planning the arena's replacement by September 2027. San Jose has agreed to renovate a building and, in the same document, to start replacing it. I have waited my whole life for a government to understand this. It is like adding a door that opens onto a wall, and I say that as someone who has carried people toward a ceiling for a hundred and forty years.

I would be a poor columnist if I ignored the arithmetic. The city faced a $35.6 million shortfall when it voted, and it is the party paying most of the bill. The owner, Hasso Plattner, is worth roughly $15 billion per Forbes. I have seen these proportions before. I was built on someone else's fortune, too, and I can tell you the staircase never asks the fortune where the money went. The fortune is very good-natured about it.

So I endorse the deal. I endorse the renovation, the bonds, the hotel tax, and the planning clause, which gives the whole arrangement its shape. And I endorse the next arena, the one San Jose will start planning in 2027, which I sincerely hope will also be renovated.

Receipt
APPROVED
City of San Jose
SAP Center renovation, Aug. 26, 2025
City share, majority of $425M$325M-$351M
Funded by bondsyes
Funded by higher hotel taxesyes
Sharks share$100M
Dissenting council votes0
New arena, planning, by Sept 2027committed
Same document.
Lease expiresJun 30 2051
Due through June 30, 2051$325M+
- Room 161

The deal's own numbers, which Room 161 reproduced from reporting by CBS Bay Area and San Jose Spotlight, were left unaltered. The council's 11-0 vote is the latest entry in this paper's running table of big things approved unanimously, and dissenting votes, combined, remain zero. A glass City Hall rotunda on Santa Clara Street was built so the public could watch exactly this kind of vote, and a Shark Tank name that predates the TV show is now attached to a building the city has agreed to start replacing.

Three Numbers in One Deal

3 ITEMS · TOGGLE THE SCALE
On a log scale each step is ten times the last, so everything fits on one stage. The city's budget gap closed at $50 million in 2026-27, per KALW. The owner's estimated fortune is about $15 billion, drawn here on a log scale because on a linear one the city would not be visible.

Gus Pettibone-Arreola, founder and sole member of the Friends of the Plaza de Cesar Chavez Parking Garage, addressed the council on the matter during public comment, as he has at every meeting since the rotunda opened. "I support the staircase's position," he said. "I have no position on the arena. I would like it noted that the garage is also a structure that goes up and then stops." A city spokesperson, Delia Marchetti, Deputy Director of Capital Continuity, said the staircase's column was "received." The Sharks were eliminated from playoff contention for the seventh straight season on April 13 and finished 39-35-8.

The lease runs through June 30, 2051. The staircase is expected to still be climbing toward the ceiling then, at no cost to the city. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

How much is San Jose actually paying for the SAP Center renovation, and what does the lease commit the city to?Get the straight answer →

More from San Jose

San Jose front page
San Jose
The Shark Tank
Shark Tank Renovation Bonds Mature in 2051, Arena Replacement Scheduled for 2027

The city agreed to pay $325 million to renovate the SAP Center for a team that has missed the playoffs seven straight seasons, then agreed the same afternoon to begin planning its replacement. Council members said the two decisions were 'complementary.'

Related: The Shark Tank: $325 million to keep a team that hasn't made the playoffs since 2019
San Jose
The Shark Tank
Fans Beg Sharks to Win One Game Before Renovation

Season ticket holders begged the team to win before renovation. The Sharks have lost 15 consecutive games.

Related: The Shark Tank: $325 million to keep a team that hasn't made the playoffs since 2019
San Jose
Diridon & the Fence
Google Announces Downtown West Chain-Link Fence Will Become a Permanent Civic Feature

The company said Tuesday that the 80-acre site around Diridon Station will be retained as a fenced open space, citing 'the community's clear appetite for the view.' Mayor Matt Mahan asked residents not to worry about the fence's future.

Related: City Hall: a glass rotunda, eleven votes, and a lot of unanimous
San Jose
Creeks & Counts
San Jose Renters Flee to San Francisco for Cheaper Rent

A Zillow analysis found a $100,000 income can afford 13% of San Jose-area rentals and 31% in San Francisco. A Willow Glen couple moved north and now tell friends they live somewhere affordable, near San Jose.

Nearby in San Jose
San Jose
Overtime
Police Department Credits Overtime Drop to Hiring Officer Named Overtime

SJPD claims overtime fell after recruiting two lateral transfers, one named Overtime. The city auditor reported overtime still cost $72 million last year with only 998 of 1,172 budgeted officers staffed.

Nearby in San Jose
San Jose
Creeks & Counts
Council Asks Residents Not to Mention Floods During Flood Wall Completion

City officials requested residents avoid referencing the 2017 flood during public comment on Coyote Creek's new flood walls. Valley Water completed 8,000 feet of barriers and awarded a $100 million contract for the next phase.

Nearby in San Jose
San JoseCalifornia

Capital of Silicon Valley. Population 1 million. Visitors: in San Francisco.

San Jose front page
Satire

The San Jose paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting and public records. Every quote is made up, especially the real officials'. Approved unanimously.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.