Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Opinion

Audiences Have Franchise Fatigue, Which Is Why We're Remaking Moana Again

A cinema poster shows a cartoon ocean wave crashing into a photographic ocean wave crashing into another cartoon wave, the pattern shrinking toward a tiny vanishing point.AI illustration

— Disney's live-action remake of Moana opened to $43 million against a reported $250 million budget. A studio executive explains why the cure for franchise fatigue is an animated version of the live-action version of the cartoon.

The executive oversees remakes at a Burbank studio and requested anonymity because he is also overseeing the remake's remake. He submitted the column below days after ScreenCrush listed Moana among 2026's bombs, and he attached a chart.

His reading of the summer is that audiences are exhausted, and that exhausted people want something familiar. Toy Story 5 opened to $159 million. Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey, adapted from a poem roughly 2,800 years old, opened to $123 million domestically. The executive considers Homer the season's best-performing existing property and has asked legal who owns it.

Opinion

Audiences Have Franchise Fatigue, Which Is Why We're Remaking Moana Again

By A Studio Executive
President of Reimagined Properties at a major studio. He has seen Moana three times, all of them at work.

Audiences are tired. I hear it everywhere, mostly from people standing in line for Toy Story 5. We take that seriously. Fatigue is a medical condition, and the treatment has always been rest, in a seat, in front of something you have already seen.

Our live-action Moana opened to $43 million on a reported $250 million budget. The lesson is that we waited too long. The 2016 original had ten years to go stale. The animated version of the live-action version begins production Monday, and a live-action version of that is dated for 2030. The gap will keep closing until the films overlap.

The word franchise comes from the Old French franc, meaning free. I had someone look it up, and I am assured that is no longer in the contract. If audiences are tired, that is what the sequel is for.

A studio spokesperson confirmed the schedule. "Nobody asked for the first remake either, and it still made back $186 million of a reported $250 million," said Dana Whitlock, vice president of audience recovery. "That is people telling us they will come most of the way."

Marco Reyes, 34, of Glendale, saw the remake opening weekend. "It was $23 and I knew how every scene ended," he said. "I'd go see something new if somebody made one." He said this from the line for Toy Story 5.

The executive's chart is reproduced as submitted, with his notes.

Summer 2026: What the Tired Audience Paid For

Worldwide gross as of late July, with the executive's annotations
Toy Story 5
Expected total. Fifth one. Fatigue confirmed: tired people sit down.
1,000 M
The Mandalorian & Grogu
A new floor to build on. Old floor: Solo, $392M.
340 M
The Odyssey
Under a week. Author unavailable for sequel; proceeding.
320 M
Moana (live-action)
Remade too slowly. Correcting.
186 M
Supergirl
Projected ceiling. Not yet remade, which is the problem.
150 M
02004006008001,000
M—millions of dollars, worldwide
Executive's finding
Every film on this chart that lost money had been remade only once.

The poster for the animated remake reached theaters this week, ahead of a script.

A movie poster in a theater light box showing a cartoon wave crashing into a photographic wave crashing into another cartoon wave, repeating smaller and smaller toward the center.

The same ocean, back sooner than anyone asked.

The studio optioned this column Thursday. The executive has asked readers who disliked it to wait for the live-action version. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Is franchise fatigue real, or do audiences only reject bad remakes?Get the straight answer →

More from Los Angeles

Los Angeles front page
Los Angeles
City Hall
Raman Wins Every Part of Los Angeles That Doesn't Know Her

Nithya Raman beat Mayor Karen Bass 54.8 to 45.2 percent citywide and lost her own Council District 4, 52.4 to 47.6. Neighbors who voted for Bass say they are happy for her and happier she will be downtown.

Nearby in Los Angeles Metro
Los Angeles
City Hall
LAPD Holds Bake Sale to Cover $150 Million in Settlements

Mayor-elect Nithya Raman wants the LAPD to pay its own settlements, which ran about $150 million last fiscal year. At $3 a brownie, the department needs to sell 50 million brownies a year, roughly 13 per Angeleno.

Nearby in Los Angeles Metro
Los Angeles
Palisades & Altadena
Insurer Lets Palisades Fire Policyholders Choose Which Half of Their House It Rebuilds

With Palisades claims reportedly paying about half of rebuild costs, one carrier now lets Pacific Palisades policyholders pick which half. Most choose the front half, which looks complete from the street.

Nearby in Los Angeles Metro
Los Angeles
The Street Beat
Los Angeles Loses Role of Los Angeles to Atlanta

With on-location filming down 12 percent this spring, FilmLA said, Los Angeles lost its own part in a period drama to Atlanta. Casting directors said Atlanta read as more authentically Los Angeles, especially the traffic.

Nearby in Los Angeles Metro
Los Angeles
Metro Watch
Dodgers Leave Early to Beat Traffic

Swept 4-0 by the Brewers, the Dodgers left the NLCS early, a Dodger Stadium tradition normally kept to the seventh inning. Team officials said leaving after Game 4 saved each player roughly two weeks on the 110.

Nearby in Los Angeles Metro
Los Angeles
The Street Beat
Scientology Removes Door Handles After Speedrunners Reach Enlightenment for Free

A TikTok trend of speedrunning through Scientology buildings began at a Hollywood location, which responded by removing its door handles. The church, whose path to spiritual freedom is sold in levels, objects mainly to the free trial.

Nearby in Los Angeles Metro
Los AngelesMetro

Rebuilt on paper, half-paid in person, ribbon-cut before the permit clears.

Los Angeles front page
Satire

The Los Angeles paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Every quote is made up, especially the ones from real officials.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.