Poisonal
World
Poisonal
The Great Highway, Vote Four

Great Highway Fight Ends, Sunset Issues Request for Proposals for a New Grievance

On a foggy beachfront promenade, a committee of residents in fleece sits at a folding table under a banner, solemnly reviewing a stack of protest signs, while skateboarders and families stream past behind them.AI illustration

— With Prop G defeated 65-35 and its beachfront precincts backing Sunset Dunes, the Outer Sunset has nothing left to oppose. Submissions are due Friday, and 'no' is not an eligible proposal.

The selection committee met on La Playa Street, where chair Lorraine Petrakis ran the session from a folding chair she has brought to every Great Highway hearing since 2020. The request runs four pages. A qualifying grievance must be visible from a living room window, must outlast two election cycles, and must not be fixable by the city.

"For six years, people knew where to find me on a Tuesday," Petrakis said. "We are looking for something that brings the neighborhood together and cannot, under any circumstances, be resolved."

She then entered the committee's prior record into evidence.

Comparison

The Great Highway, by the votes

DateResultDid the Sunset get what it wanted
Prop K (close the road)Nov 2024Passed, 55% citywide; about 36% in D4No
Engardio recallSep 2025Recalled, 64.6%Yes. Road stayed closed.
Lawsuit against Prop KJan 2026Prop K upheldNo
Prop G (reopen weekdays)Nov 2026Failed, 65.7% noYes, apparently
Eight precincts on the road2024 to 202640% to 58% for the parkCommittee declined to score

The committee accepted the table without discussion and moved to bids. Eight proposals cleared the first screening, among them the skate park on the old asphalt, which was penalized because several committee members' grandchildren use it.

Dale Fenstermacher, 58, who has used his lawn sign as a windbreak since 2024, asked to submit a ninth. "I took the 29 Sunset for an hour to testify about a road I drive twice a year," he said. "Nobody has ever asked me about the 29."

The committee ruled the 29 ineligible because Muni could, in theory, add a bus.

What should the Sunset oppose next?

TAP A WINNER IN EACH MATCHUP
Which grievance can be opposed longest without anyone fixing it.
QUARTERS
CHAMPION
—

Whatever the Mission wants won the final round. The committee then learned it would have to find out what that was, and voted 4-1 to oppose the committee instead. Petrakis dissented from her folding chair and requested a recall.

Supervisor Alan Wong said in January, per ABC7, that reopening the road would take another ballot measure. Residents found the phrase very reassuring.Dale Fenstermacher has repainted his Keep the Great Highway Open sign to read Keep. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why did the precincts right next to the Great Highway go from 40% to 58% in favor of the Sunset Dunes park?Get the straight answer →

More from The Sunset

The Sunset front page
The Sunset
Fog Desk
Twenty Snowy Plovers Take Ocean Beach Without a Single Ballot Measure

Beach rules now keep kites, bonfires and off-leash dogs north of Lincoln Way for twenty threatened birds on Ocean Beach. Residents who spent four years voting over the Great Highway called it the cleanest land grab in Sunset history.

Related: The Great Highway: closed by vote, a supervisor recalled, a lawsuit lost, closed by vote again
The Sunset
Room 200
Garry Tan Admits San Francisco to Y Combinator for 7 Percent

Y Combinator chief Garry Tan, a GrowSF supporter and former board member, admitted San Francisco to the winter batch for 7 percent. Partners advised the city to talk to its users and pivot away from housing by Demo Day.

Nearby in San Francisco
The Sunset
Four Stories Max
City Approves Final Rebuilding Permit From 1906 Fire

The Department of Building Inspection approved the last rebuilding permit from the 1906 earthquake and fire, which destroyed most of San Francisco. Staff called the 120-year review expedited and told the applicant's great-grandchildren that neighbors may still appeal.

Nearby in San Francisco
The Sunset
Stucco & Zoning
Henry Doelger's Ghost Opposes New Housing in the Sunset, Citing Character He Built

The builder who covered the dunes in mirrored stucco houses on 25-foot lots spoke against 10-story buildings on Taraval Street. He warned that mass-produced housing would ruin the neighborhood.

Nearby in Sunset
The Sunset
Fog Desk
Outer Sunset Resident Reports Sun to 311 as Unidentified Object

A 47th Avenue resident called 311 on Tuesday to report a bright disk over Ocean Beach that was producing heat. Dispatchers told him the object appears every October and leaves without filing.

Nearby in Sunset
The Sunset
Irving vs. Taraval
Irving Street Booms Past 2019, Taraval Told Its Boom Is on the Next L

City sales-tax data shows the Inner Sunset above its pre-pandemic peak, while Taraval Street and Noriega have not recovered. SFMTA said the recovery is due in nine minutes, at peak.

Nearby in Sunset
The SunsetSan Francisco

Summer arrives in October. The recall arrives sooner.

The Sunset front page
Satire

The The Sunset paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting and written in a parka on La Playa. Everyone quoted is made up, the real officials' included; the fog is not.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.