Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Karl & Co.

SHADE Act Passes 10-1 After Planners Notice Shadows Are Not Actually Injuries

An urban planner holds a flashlight against a scale model of an apartment building while three neighborhood activists frantically measure the resulting darkness with a protractor.AI illustration

— The Board of Supervisors voted 10-1 on Monday to pass the SHADE Act, officially declaring that the fog's afternoon overhang does not constitute a punitive assault on residential living rooms. Supervisor Bilal Mahmood noted that 2,000 housing units had been delayed since 2017 because developers failed to negotiate light-rights agreements with passing clouds.

The vote followed a Planning Department review that found no documented case of a shadow striking a resident. Staff examined eight years of appeals and identified furniture as the most common victim.

"For years we processed a shadow as something that happens to a person," said Dennis Ochoa, the department's senior shadow analyst. "We measured thousands of them. We went out with a tape. Every one of them turned out to be the absence of something, which we had no form for."

Ochoa's office released the file on one 41-unit building on Divisadero Street to show how the old process worked.

Case file: 41 units, Divisadero Street

📄2017
Application filed
Five stories, 41 apartments, no parking.
🪟2018
Shadow appeal filed
A neighbor states the building would darken a kitchen windowsill for 11 minutes each December afternoon.
☀️2019
Developer submits sun study
340 pages. Planning staff ask for a site visit on a sunny day.
🌫️2020-2023
Site visit pending
No qualifying day occurs.
✍️2024
Light-rights agreement requested
Developer is told to obtain a signature from Karl. Three notarized attempts evaporate.
🏛️2026
SHADE Act passes
Shadow reclassified from assault to weather.

Karen Liu, 34, a dental hygienist in the Richmond, has been on the waitlist for that building since 2019. "They told me my apartment was stuck behind a cloud," Liu said. "I asked which one. They said it was confidential."

In the Marina, residents near the Dateway spent Tuesday morning checking their windows for darkness. Several called the city to report it, and were told it had been night.

By noon, a neighborhood group called Friends of the Afternoon Overhang had filed suit in Superior Court on the fog's behalf, naming the Board as defendant and Karl as the injured party.

light-rights agreement
Definition
A contract in which a developer asks the fog for permission to stand under it, and the fog does not respond.

The complaint asks the court to restore the shadows to their former legal standing and seeks damages for eight years of lost overhang. A judge agreed to hear arguments once both parties can be present in the same room. The sun is scheduled to appear in September. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

What does San Francisco's SHADE Act actually change about shadow appeals against new housing?Get the straight answer →

More from San Francisco

San Francisco front page
San Francisco
Four Stories Max
City Approves Final Rebuilding Permit From 1906 Fire

The Department of Building Inspection approved the last rebuilding permit from the 1906 earthquake and fire, which destroyed most of San Francisco. Staff called the 120-year review expedited and told the applicant's great-grandchildren that neighbors may still appeal.

Related: Family Zoning: 36,000 homes by 2031, a few hundred so far, and a Safeway carve-out
San Francisco
Karl & Co.
Police Commission Approves Drone Rules That Ban Mass Surveillance Unless Helpful

The Police Commission approved a comprehensive set of drone-use rules Wednesday restricting mass surveillance to situations where nobody is watching. Chief Derrick Lew assured the public the thirty-day retention limit guarantees footage is deleted right after everyone forgets it was filmed.

Related: 1906, 1989, Karl, and 800,000 complaints a year
San Francisco
Room 200
Mayor Declares Rent Emergency After Discovering Asking Prices Cost Money

Mayor Daniel Lurie announced a rent emergency on Monday following economic reports showing that asking prices for two-bedroom units have officially crossed the $6,000 threshold. Administration officials confirmed the emergency grants the city special powers to draft strongly worded press releases while leaving landlords free to raise rates another 26 percent.

Related: Family Zoning: 36,000 homes by 2031, a few hundred so far, and a Safeway carve-out
San Francisco
Karl & Co.
McCovey Cove Kayakers Begin Bringing Books

Kayakers in McCovey Cove began bringing novels after the Giants finished 65-97 and missed the playoffs for a fifth straight year. One paddler is 300 pages into Middlemarch and has asked the lineup not to rush him.

More from Karl & Co.
San Francisco
Opinion
City Loves Recalls, Still Shocked Each Time It Recalls Someone

San Francisco residents claim to oppose recalls in principle. Yet a Chronicle analysis found the city voted 19 points higher than the state for recall measures.

Nearby in San Francisco
San Francisco
Doom Loop / Boom Loop
Waymo Autonomous Fleet Reopens Market Street by Refusing to Humanly Drive

Transportation officials confirmed Wednesday that Market Street has been successfully returned to driverless vehicles after a five-year hiatus on human transit. Waymo robotaxis now occupy every lane between 10th Street and the Ferry Building, maintaining traffic flow through polite obstruction.

Nearby in San Francisco
San FranciscoCalifornia

The doom loop is over. The invoice is a $6,000 two-bedroom.

San Francisco front page
Satire

The San Francisco paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Every quote is made up, no real official is quoted, and yes, the vacancy rate is the real one.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.