Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Fiscal Cliff Notes

Muni Reminds Riders Both Ballot Measures Must Pass to Avoid Total Collapse

A transit planner draws a second cliff on a whiteboard directly behind the first one while pointing earnestly at a pie chart labeled 'Voluntary Fare Evasion.'AI illustration

— Transit officials confirmed Friday that the SFMTA fiscal cliff can only be averted if San Francisco voters approve two separate parcel taxes on the same ballot while standing on one foot. The Connect Bay Area sales tax will automatically dissolve if any rider remembers what pre-pandemic service felt like.

The SFMTA fiscal cliff, which transit officials say has been arriving since 2023 and has been rescheduled once per budget cycle ever since, now carries a $344 million deficit for fiscal 2027 and a general fund contribution of 39 percent. Julie Kirschbaum, the agency's Director of Transportation, told reporters Friday at SFMTA headquarters that the two parcel taxes are not alternatives to one another. "Both of them have to pass," she said, "and then we have to see the ridership."

The ridership is currently about 70 percent of what it was in 2019, a figure the agency's own forecast treats as a floor and its own ballot language treats as a ceiling. The Office of Downtown Vibrancy and Foot-Traffic Recounts has confirmed that every future recovery will be measured against 2019, a year in which Muni was also described as being in crisis.

Frequently Asked

What Riders Are Asking About the Two Measures

One tax raises money. The second tax raises the possibility that the first tax was necessary. Voters who approve only one are asked to treat it as a deposit.
Owners of single-family homes, who are legally entitled to pass it through to the tenants of rent-controlled units, who are legally entitled to ride the 22 Fillmore to work at the office that no longer requires them.
Service will be reduced to the level the passing measure was said to prevent. The agency declined to say which level that is, only that it has a map.
The agency has modeled this and describes the outcome as a different crisis.

Dale Rutkowski, 54, who rides the 22 Fillmore from the Marina to a hybrid job he attends on Tuesdays, said the agency has been clear. "They told me both measures have to pass. They told me last year that one measure had to pass. I don't know what the third one is going to be."

Kirschbaum said Friday that if the measures fail, the agency will have no choice but to evaluate stopping the 22 Fillmore, a sentence she delivered without a pause and without any visible awareness that the 22 Fillmore is the agency's most heavily used line.

The Connect Bay Area regional sales tax, separately on the same ballot, includes a clause under which it dissolves automatically if a majority of riders recall what service felt like before 2020. Agency counsel said the clause has never been tested, as no majority of anyone has been located.

Asked what the agency would do after election night, Kirschbaum said the SFMTA board would meet to determine the next cliff.The fiscal cliff has been arriving since 2023. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

What happens to Muni service if San Francisco voters reject the parcel taxes and the regional sales tax?Get the straight answer →

More from San Francisco

San Francisco front page
San Francisco
Room 200
City Investigates Municipal Parking Garage For Hosting ICE Vehicles While Violating San Sanctuary Law

Municipal administrators in Room 200 confirmed Thursday that federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement vehicles occupying the Golden Gateway garage at 250 Clay St. may technically constitute a zoning violation under local sanctuary city ordinances. Officials noted the agency has maintained stalls inside the city-owned SFMTA facility for over a year, forcing bureaucrats to weigh the cost of municipal parking against federal jurisdictional immunity.

Related: The Muni fiscal cliff and the two taxes that both have to pass
San Francisco
Doom Loop / Boom Loop
PG&E Prices Municipal Grid Takeover at Cost of Rebuilding Roman Empire

PG&E informed state regulators that taking over the local electric grid would cost $22.5 billion, a figure that includes itemized severance charges for the emotional damage of no longer billing San Francisco. City officials noted the estimate exceeds the replacement value of every asset on the Peninsula.

Related: The Muni fiscal cliff and the two taxes that both have to pass
San Francisco
Room 200
Garry Tan Admits San Francisco to Y Combinator for 7 Percent

Y Combinator chief Garry Tan, a GrowSF supporter and former board member, admitted San Francisco to the winter batch for 7 percent. Partners advised the city to talk to its users and pivot away from housing by Demo Day.

Nearby in San Francisco
San Francisco
The Containment Zone
SFPD Publishes Drug Market's 2027 Tour Dates

SFPD, which testified in October that enforcement pushed dealing into the Mission, published the market's 2027 stops. Each includes a hearing and a press release.

Nearby in San Francisco
San Francisco
Opinion
City Loves Recalls, Still Shocked Each Time It Recalls Someone

San Francisco residents claim to oppose recalls in principle. Yet a Chronicle analysis found the city voted 19 points higher than the state for recall measures.

Nearby in San Francisco
San Francisco
The Great Highway, Forever
Traffic Study Confirms Great Highway Closure Added Exactly Seventeen Seconds To Outer Richmond Commutes

An eight-month traffic analysis conducted by the SF Chronicle and Here Technologies revealed that closing the Upper Great Highway increased Outer Richmond commutes to the SF Zoo from 16 minutes to 16 minutes and seventeen seconds. Municipal modelers attributed the congestion spike to a combination of speed cameras, traffic calming measures, and el nino tides hitting the seawall.

Nearby in San Francisco
San FranciscoCalifornia

The doom loop is over. The invoice is a $6,000 two-bedroom.

San Francisco front page
Satire

The San Francisco paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Every quote is made up, no real official is quoted, and yes, the vacancy rate is the real one.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.