Bayview Caltrain Station Reaches Major Milestone: a Corner
AI illustration
Bayview-Hunters Point — After almost 40 years of planning, officials chose Oakdale Avenue and Third Street as the preferred site for a Bayview Caltrain station. Trains have passed the corner the whole time, declining to stop out of respect for the process.
The selection was announced as the culmination of the Bayview station program, which has been continuously staffed since 1988. "We took a lot of care to land on a corner," said Corinne Abernathy-Shaw, the senior planner who has worked the program for 38 years and was promoted this month for choosing it. "Some agencies would have rushed to pick a block. We have been careful to pick an intersection." Abernathy-Shaw said her office is not yet discussing a platform, a ticket machine or a train stopping, and described those as "downstream considerations." Her promotion came with a larger desk and her own copy of the study.
TELEGRAM
FROMSouthern Pacific Railroad BoardPLACESan FranciscoTOPlanning Division, City and County of San FranciscoDATEMARCH 14 1988
RECONSTRUCTED · not the surviving text of a real telegram
The report is still being prepared. Planners say the original request has been fulfilled in every respect except the reporting back. The Paul Avenue station, which served the neighborhood by Caltrain, closed in 2005, and the program has since proceeded on the understanding that a station is easier to study once it no longer exists. "Closing the old one was the first thing we got done on schedule," said an SFCTA staffer who asked not to be named because she is still on the program.
Cycle
How a Corner Gets Chosen
01
📋
Needs Assessment
Planners determine that the Bayview would benefit from a station, a finding reached independently in each decade.
02
🗺️
Alternatives Study
Several corners are compared on a matrix. The matrix is later revised.
03
🪑
Community Meeting
Residents attend and say they have already attended.
04
📝
Revised Alternatives
The matrix is revised again, now with a column for the previous matrix.
05
🪑
Community Meeting
Residents attend and say it again, in nearly the same words.
06
📍
Preferred Location
One corner is named preferred, which is a status and not a station.
07
🔍
Environmental Review
The preferred location is reviewed for its effect on the environment that has been passing it by.
08
➰
Back to Community Meeting
The only exit is unlabeled, and nobody has tried it.
Oakdale Avenue and Third Street was selected over several other corners that remain, per the program's records, also corners. The T Third, which opened in 2007, now holds the distinction of being the neighborhood's newest transit promise and the only one that has ever carried a passenger to a destination. "We're really proud of how far this has come," Abernathy-Shaw said. "Forty years ago there wasn't even a corner." There was, in fact, a corner.
Done, many times, by many consultants, at the rate of one generation.
▼
💡
TipStudies are available for review at the next study.
2
Close the old station
Done in 2005, ahead of any plan for a replacement.
3
Choose a corner
Done in 2026, to applause the planners described as measured.
4
Design the station
Pending. Awaiting the design of the process for designing it.
5
Fund the station
Pending.
6
Build the station
Pending.
7
Open the station
Pending. Overall progress toward a working station: 14%.
At 8:40 Thursday morning, a commuter at the chosen corner waved at a passing northbound train. Reached by a reporter, Darnell Reeves, 47, said he has done it "every workday since the old station closed, and the train has never once done anything about it." This week it did. Officials believe the gesture, which the engineer made through the cab window without braking, was likely a first for the program.Officials said the next milestone, choosing a side of the street, is expected by the 2040s. ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.