Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Local Control (Pending Appeal)

Pleasanton Man Fights to Preserve Historic Former Kohl's

— A Pleasanton man petitioned to landmark the former Kohl's on Rosewood Drive, a Housing Element site. He listed the parking lot as a contributing structure.

The application was filed at the Planning Division counter on a Tuesday morning, on a form the city has not updated since the Kohl's opened. Robert Tallmadge, a Pleasanton homeowner, asked that the building at 4525 Rosewood Drive be designated a historic resource. The narrative section ran to nine pages. It describes the store's period fluorescent lighting, its original return desk near the escalator that did not exist, and a bathroom mirror that Tallmadge says he had never noticed before the store closed. Under "Contributing Features," he listed the parking lot. "The lot is where people stood," he said at the counter. "Stood and waited for their spouses to finish in Women's."

Tallmadge circulated a petition through the Ruby Hill neighborhood, which is a mile from the store and, according to residents, has never been inside it. Forty-one of the 52 signers said they had shopped at the Kohl's; seven said they had heard of it. "I didn't want to be the only one saying the building matters," Tallmadge said. The Planning Commission has scheduled a hearing for the same evening as the city's rezoning of 4515 Rosewood Drive, a neighboring parcel, for up to 1,438 homes at 30 to 60 units an acre, due by December 31, 2026. Staff said the two items would be heard in separate rooms.

Quote

Nothing about 1996 was ever about housing. It was about the feel of the place, and the feel was a Kohl's.”

Corliss Venhuizen-Abad
Supporting statement, Tri-Valley Committee to Preserve the 1996 Feel

Closures of Party City and Kohl's accounted for more than 55 percent of Hacienda's negative absorption in the second quarter of 2025, according to the business park's brokers. Tallmadge says the store was the anchor of the neighborhood. Asked what the anchor had anchored, he paused. "The idea," he said. Planning staff noted the application was incomplete in one respect: the Kohl's was not, at the time of filing, a building anyone had asked to be a home.

Pleasanton voters adopted a 29,000-unit housing cap in 1996. A judge ruled in 2010 that it violated state law, and the city paid $1.9 million in legal fees. The city's housing element now calls for the rezoning of three sites totaling about 30 acres, including the Rosewood strip. Tallmadge, asked whether he understood the rezoning was the state's order, not the city's wish, said he understood both were on the calendar that night. "A historic building," he said, "is the only kind the court can't touch." 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Can a Pleasanton building be landmarked to block housing, and does it work?Get the straight answer →

More from Tri-Valley

Tri-Valley front page
Tri-Valley
Office Park Weather
Oracle, Workday File Layoffs Against Each Other

Oracle's 63 layoffs Friday and Workday's 142 effective Nov. 30 now share a WARN-notice table at the Employment Development Department. Pleasanton workers who lose both jobs are routed to the Hacienda career fair held at neither campus.

Related: Hacienda: 875 acres of office park slowly turning into the housing element
Tri-Valley
Office Park Weather
99 Ranch Closes With Enough Stores Left to Feel Robbed Less

The Pleasanton 99 Ranch Market at Rose Pavilion closes permanently December 5 after 16 years. Two other nearby stores will continue serving Pan-Asian groceries in the area.

Related: Hacienda: 875 acres of office park slowly turning into the housing element
Tri-Valley
Local Control (Pending Appeal)
Dublin Schools Get 65.38 Percent, Which Is a Failing Grade

Measure I, the Dublin Unified parcel tax, won 65.38 percent of the vote and needed two-thirds. The city ranked best in California has now been told it fell short.

More from Local Control (Pending Appeal)
Tri-Valley
Local Control (Pending Appeal)
Livermore Settles Referendum by Deleting Its Subject

The council voted 4-1 to re-approve the Eden Housing project after rescinding the park-funding provisions the referendum targeted. Livermore's direct democracy now comes with an edit button.

More from Local Control (Pending Appeal)
Tri-Valley
End of the Line
Riders Told Median Station Is Not Yet Final Stop

BART opened public comment on an extension it voted down in 2018. The unbuilt line remains a placeholder for future expansion.

Nearby in Tri-Valley
Tri-Valley
The Lab
Lab Employee Says 'It's Mostly Computers' for 31st Year

Livermore resident Dale Ostrowski told a neighbor at a barbecue Saturday that his work at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory is mostly computers. The neighbor, who has asked every year since 1995, said he has stopped hoping for a second sentence.

Nearby in Tri-Valley
Tri-ValleyLivermore, Pleasanton, Dublin, California

Best place to live in California, end of the BART line, 100,000 cars on the Altamont, and a lightbulb that has outlasted every transit plan.

Tri-Valley front page
Satire

The Tri-Valley paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Every quote is made up, the Lab declined to confirm it exists, and the numbers are the only thing we didn't make up.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.