Poisonal
World
Poisonal
End of the Line

BART Station Sits in Middle of Freeway It Was Supposed to Replace

— Commuters at Dublin/Pleasanton step onto a platform between eastbound and westbound I-580 lanes. The station was built in the median rather than replacing the highway, according to transit officials.

Riders disembarking at the Dublin/Pleasanton station are advised by posted signage that the platform is not a freeway. Several said they were not aware of this until the train doors opened onto a concrete strip with the eastbound and westbound lanes of I-580 running past on either side, at a speed the station's own announcements describe as "brisk." The station, which opened in 2011 at a cost of $80 million, was designed to serve as the eastern terminus of the BART system, a function it performs with no apparent difficulty. Its location was selected after planners determined that the median was the only parcel in the corridor that was not already occupied by a freeway, an office park, or a parking structure belonging to someone who was consulted.

A regular rider from Dublin said she has taken BART every weekday for six years to avoid driving. "I take BART so I don't have to sit in traffic on 580," she said, standing on the platform as a westbound semi passed close enough to lift her hair. "Then I get off and I'm sitting in traffic on 580."

Transit officials said the platform's exposure to wind is a known consideration, one addressed in the station's design through a glass windscreen that covers part of the platform's length. Riders at the unscreened ends reported that the wind coming off the Altamont Pass, where turbines turn on both sides of the freeway, arrives at the platform with the same force as the trucks, and considerably less warning. A Livermore bookkeeper who has commuted through the station since it opened said the turbines move while the cars do not.

A spokesperson for the regional transit agency declined to comment on whether the screen could be extended, citing an ongoing review of "platform-adjacent conditions," a phrase the agency has used in several separate reports without defining it.

Riders who drive to the station and park in its garage are advised that the walk from the garage to the platform crosses a pedestrian overpass, a stairwell and a sidewalk that runs alongside the freeway's shoulder. One commuter from Pleasanton said the walk takes longer than the train ride from her stop to downtown Oakland. She drove to BART so she wouldn't have to drive, she said, and now she drives, parks, walks, rides and walks again.

The garage reached capacity by mid-morning on a recent Tuesday, according to a sign at the entrance that was not updated until later. Commuters who arrived after that time parked in the Safeway lot across the street and walked the remaining distance through a gap in the sound wall that a transit spokesperson described as "informal."

A rider identified only as a regular at the station has been on the platform since the end of last week, according to two other commuters and a transit employee who said the rider has declined several invitations to board a train. "He's got a bench," said a station agent, who asked not to be named. "He's got a thermos. I checked his fare card and it's still good for the Embarcadero, but he says he's waiting to see how the median plays out."

The transit agency said it does not track riders who remain on platforms, a policy it said was consistent with the agency's stated commitment to "open and unrestricted access to the system." Asked whether the system could be described as having reached its eastern terminus, a spokesperson said the agency "does not characterize its service in those terms."

The median on which the station sits has been owned by the state since before the freeway was widened to its current eight lanes, and planners said there is no realistic alternative site in the corridor. A transit official who worked on the station's design, and who asked to be identified only as a senior planner, said the decision reflected the long-term view. "We looked at every parcel between here and Livermore," the planner said. "The only thing we didn't look at was the parcel the train was going to be on, which was a different question."The station's terminus designation means the line will not extend further east for the foreseeable future. Trains will continue to stop at the station, and passengers will continue to step off at the median, where, according to posted signage, "the platform is not a freeway." 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why was the BART station built in the middle of I-580 instead of replacing the highway?Get the straight answer →

More from Tri-Valley

Tri-Valley front page
Tri-Valley
End of the Line
BART Reassures Livermore Its Five Miles Remain Available Upon Request

BART announced Monday that the five-mile Livermore extension it declined to build 3,094 days ago is being held in reserve for any resident who submits a written inquiry. Applicants will be told the Isabel Avenue lot, purchased in the mid-1980s, is still empty and still theirs to look at.

Related: Dublin/Pleasanton: the end of the line, and the five miles BART said no to
Tri-Valley
End of the Line
Altamont Commuter's Children Know Him Mostly as Headlights

One of about 100,000 daily Altamont Pass commuters, a Tracy father is known to his children as headlights on the ceiling. The youngest has begun waving at any gray Honda.

Related: The Altamont: 100,000 cars over a windmill pass every morning
Tri-Valley
Opinion
Area Man Hears Lab Is Hiring, Asks If Bombs Still Work

A Livermore resident asked a neighbor if warheads still function. The neighbor said it's mostly computers now.

Related: The Altamont: 100,000 cars over a windmill pass every morning
Tri-Valley
Not Napa
Centennial Light Attends Own 125th Birthday Party, Declines Cake, Burns at 4 Watts

The Livermore Fire Station 6 bulb, lit since 1901, was feted by the city this year and watched online by a webcam. It has outlasted every BART plan and has never required a referendum.

Related: Dublin/Pleasanton: the end of the line, and the five miles BART said no to
Tri-Valley
Seventh Term
Lifelong Tri-Valley Resident Can Name Two Valleys

A Tri-Valley native, 54, named the Livermore and San Ramon valleys at a Pleasanton barbecue and then asked for a hint. He is a graduate of Amador Valley High School.

Nearby in Tri-Valley
Tri-Valley
Office Park Weather
Workday Thanks Laid-Off Staff for Beta Testing Layoff Module

Workday, Pleasanton's largest employer with 5,387 workers, thanked laid-off staff for beta testing its layoff module. Their feedback ships in the next release.

Nearby in Tri-Valley
Tri-ValleyLivermore, Pleasanton, Dublin, California

Best place to live in California, end of the BART line, 100,000 cars on the Altamont, and a lightbulb that has outlasted every transit plan.

Tri-Valley front page
Satire

The Tri-Valley paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Every quote is made up, the Lab declined to confirm it exists, and the numbers are the only thing we didn't make up.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.