Traffic Study Confirms Great Highway Closure Added Exactly Seventeen Seconds To Outer Richmond Commutes
AI illustration
San Francisco — An eight-month traffic analysis conducted by the SF Chronicle and Here Technologies revealed that closing the Upper Great Highway increased Outer Richmond commutes to the SF Zoo from 16 minutes to 16 minutes and seventeen seconds. Municipal modelers attributed the congestion spike to a combination of speed cameras, traffic calming measures, and el nino tides hitting the seawall.
The Office of Downtown Vibrancy and Foot-Traffic Recounts has priced the 17 seconds at $1.9 million a year in lost productivity, a figure its director described as conservative. The GPS analysis behind the finding covered 4,100 trips and 2.3 million location pings collected by Here Technologies between March and October. The study ran each trip through its model twice, once with the highway open to cars and once with it closed, and the difference came out to 17 seconds. The Office then re-baselined the result against 2019, when the road was still a highway and the trip was, by its count, 16 minutes flat. The 17 seconds is the only figure in the study that was measured rather than estimated.
Comparison
Office of Downtown Vibrancy Re-Baseline, Outer Sunset Corridor
2019 Baseline
Current
Office Recovery Claim
Outer Richmond to SF Zoo, drive time
16:00
16:17
Recovered 17 seconds (re-baselined)
Ocean Beach foot traffic, weekdays
Not counted
Counted
Up 41% from zero
Sunset Dunes visits, weekdays
0 (highway)
Rising
Recovered from 2019 highway
Drivers who used the highway in 2019
All
Unavailable
Excluded from baseline
Lorraine Petrakis-Ng, a 31-year resident of the Outer Sunset, addressed the two-minute limit that applies to every speaker at the hearing. She has spoken at every Great Highway hearing since 2020 and has never once been in favor of anything the committee has put in front of her. 'I timed the trip myself,' she said. 'Seventeen seconds is an eternity in the Outer Sunset. My mother used to say the eternity was the fog, and the fog has better manners than this committee.' The timer went off at the end of her second minute. She thanked the committee for the seventeen seconds and sat down, as she has done since 2020.
Frequently Asked
Office Answers, Frequently
The Office does not use the term statistically significant. The Office uses the term material, which it defines as any figure that can be read aloud at a press briefing without a pause. The Office has never published a figure it could not read aloud.
El Niño is a weather pattern. The Office holds that it is also a traffic calming measure, in the sense that it is slow, unavoidable and produces no parking revenue for the Municipal Transportation Agency.
The question is scheduled for the November ballot as a fourth measure. The Office is preparing the analysis now, in advance, so the answer can be re-baselined against the first.
The Office has asked the Department of Elections to add the seventeen seconds to the ballot as a fourthballot measure analysis, for context. At 731 days since voters last settled the road, the great-highway clock has one more reset ahead of it. The road is scheduled for another election in November. ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.