Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Toll Booth Pending

State Rules Right to Idle Down Lombard Street Is a Matter of Equity

A long line of rental convertibles idles nose to tail down a steep, flower-lined zigzag street, their drivers holding up phones, while a resident in a bathrobe sits on his front steps holding a cup of coffee and a tiny unused toll ticket.AI illustration

— The city proposed a $5 weekday, $10 weekend fee for the crooked block, and the governor vetoed it over 'social equity issues.' Tourists idling in rented convertibles called it a civil rights victory.

A spokesperson for the governor's office, Priya Holloway, Deputy Director of Access Equity in the Sacramento press office, said the veto was necessary because "no family should be priced out of a twenty-minute wait." She said the state had reviewed the proposal for "any unintended consequences for visitors of modest means" and found that the toll would have created "a two-tier system of who gets to idle past the house." Asked how many visitors had raised the concern, Holloway said the office had heard from "a number of people who came from Ohio and had really been looking forward to it."

The Crooked Block Queue Abatement Working Group, a residents' committee that has met monthly since 2014, submitted written testimony in October 2019 asking the state to "consider literally anything." The group's chair, Hollis Varga-Bright, 64, who has lived on the block for 31 years and has never driven it, said the committee was not consulted before the veto and that the veto did not address the cars.

The ideaWhat the veto actually means for Lombard Street

the mechanism
The Lombard Street toll would have charged drivers $5 on weekdays and $10 on weekends and holidays to enter the crooked block between Hyde and Leavenworth. The city's transportation authority recommended it. The governor vetoed it in October 2019 on the grounds of social equity issues, so the block remains free to drive, which means it remains free to idle, which means it remains the most expensive free thing on the hill.

A weekday trip down the crooked block of Lombard Street, 2019

THEN · 2019$5
ACTUAL, TODAY$0
CHANGE×0.0
The price fell about 100% over 7 years. Crooked block, weekday: $5. Weekend: $10. Today: $0, by order of the State of California.
Prices in USD, as given; the change is computed from the two prices, not adjusted for inflation.

How Lombard Street became a civil rights matter

🛞1922
The eight curves are built
Lombard's crooked block is laid out between Hyde and Leavenworth, one way, downhill, and designed for a horse-drawn carriage.
🚧2014
Four summer weekends are closed to traffic
At the request of Supervisor Mark Farrell, the city closes the block on four summer weekends and promises to assess the pilot.
📋2017–2019
The reservation study
The city studies reservations, a toll, and a dozen other ways to make the block less of a parking lot.
✍️October 2019
The veto
Governor Gavin Newsom vetoes the toll, citing social equity issues. The block stays free.
⏳2026
Still assessing the 2014 pilot
The city confirms it is still assessing the four weekends from 2014.
You are the city of San Francisco, and the crooked block of Lombard Street is clogged with rented convertibles again. The state has ruled out money, reservations and the obvious fixes. What do you do?
Which path do you take down the hill?
every path ends at a rental car at Van Ness

Thibault Moreau, 34, of Lyon, France, was reached by phone at the bottom of the block near Leavenworth on his eleventh pass. He said he had driven the crooked block eleven times "to get the angle right" and was grateful the state had protected his right to do so. "In France we would have a fee for this," Moreau said, adjusting his sunglasses. "Here, the governor has decided the road belongs to everyone who can rent a car."Residents of the block were asked whether they too could be considered an equity issue. They were told to get in line. The Working Group has scheduled its next meeting for the first Tuesday of next month. The queue is expected to reach Van Ness Avenue by then. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why did the state of California veto a Lombard Street toll on equity grounds?Get the straight answer →

More from Russian Hill

Russian Hill front page
Russian Hill
The Crooked Block
Vermont Street Files Defamation Suit Over Lombard's 'Crookedest Street' Claim

Lawyers for Vermont Street in Potrero Hill say it is steeper than Lombard and gets none of the two million annual visitors. They are seeking damages and one summer weekend of gridlock.

Related: The crooked block: eight turns, 600 feet, two million visitors and a line to Van Ness
Russian Hill
The View Desk
AI Founder Buys on Crooked Block of Lombard, Files Ticket Requesting a Straighter Street

A founder who bought on Lombard's crooked block filed a 311 request asking that its eight turns be refactored into one. He said the 1922 design had obvious latency issues.

Related: The crooked block: eight turns, 600 feet, two million visitors and a line to Van Ness
Russian Hill
Polk, Coming Soon
Polk Street Opens One of Five Announced Restaurants, Gets 42,000-Square-Foot Gym

Of five restaurants announced for Russian Hill's stretch of Polk Street, one has opened, and a 42,000-square-foot gym has arrived. Residents can now burn off the four restaurants they were promised.

Nearby in Russian Hill
Russian Hill
Up the Hyde Line
Balclutha Leaves Hyde Street for Mare Island, Latest Resident Priced Out to Vallejo

The 1886 square-rigger is at Mare Island while Hyde Street Pier is rebuilt, with no date to return. Friends say it is happier, and can finally afford a second bedroom.

Nearby in Russian Hill
Russian Hill
Four Stories Max
City Approves Final Rebuilding Permit From 1906 Fire

The Department of Building Inspection approved the last rebuilding permit from the 1906 earthquake and fire, which destroyed most of San Francisco. Staff called the 120-year review expedited and told the applicant's great-grandchildren that neighbors may still appeal.

Nearby in San Francisco
Russian Hill
Room 200
Lurie Thanks Human Extinction for Choosing San Francisco

Mayor Daniel Lurie, who has called San Francisco the home of AI, thanked human extinction for locating in Mission Bay. He asked only that it remain headquartered in the city through completion.

Nearby in San Francisco
Russian HillSan Francisco

Eight turns. Two million visitors. Zero tolls.

Russian Hill front page
Satire

The Russian Hill paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting and filed from the queue on Lombard, which has not moved. Everyone quoted is made up, the real officials' included; the eight turns are not.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.