Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Opinion

City Loves Recalls, Still Shocked Each Time It Recalls Someone

— San Francisco residents claim to oppose recalls in principle. Yet a Chronicle analysis found the city voted 19 points higher than the state for recall measures.

The San Francisco Department of Elections has stopped describing the city's voting record as a record. Since 2022 it has kept it as a ledger: one column for the people voters elected, one for the people voters later removed, and a running balance that has not been in the black since February of that year.

Each entry is filed the morning after a recall, beside a fresh survey showing that most residents find recalls distasteful.

Entries in the City's Recall Ledger, 2022–2025

🏫February 2022
Three school board members recalled
Removed after a fight over renaming Lincoln High and admissions at Lowell High School. Ledger note: Isolated.
⚖️June 2022
District Attorney Chesa Boudin recalled
Second entry in four months. Ledger note: Isolated.
📭2023–2024
No recalls
Department staff described the period as a rest.
🏖️September 2025
Supervisor Joel Engardio recalled
Sunset voters removed the supervisor over Prop K, the measure that closed the Great Highway, which the district had also voted on.

The ledger's back pages track appointed supervisors, who in San Francisco have historically lost their first race. Staff added a column in 2026 after two appointees, Alan Wong and Stephen Sherrill, won anyway, leaving the department unsure where to file them.

"We've moved them to pending," said Marisol Tran, the department's Recall Intake Coordinator. "Pending isn't a judgment. It's just where we keep everyone we've elected."

The department has since pre-printed a recall petition for every newly sworn official, to save time.

A charter amendment now circulating would cap every official at a lifetime limit of two terms, a term being defined as the stretch between an election and its recall.

A political consultant who has run both sides of all four recalls said the proposal would stabilize the city. "Voters hate recalls," the consultant said. "They just keep needing one."

Dennis Kwan, a retiree in the Parkside, said he signed the 2025 petition on the sidewalk outside Safeway and has regretted it at every red light since. "I wanted a highway," Kwan said. "Nobody on the clipboard said I'd get a special election."

Alan Wong won his full term with about 76 percent of the vote. The petition was already in the drawer. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

How many recall elections has San Francisco held since 2022, and why do they keep passing?Get the straight answer →

More from San Francisco

San Francisco front page
San Francisco
Room 200
Prop D Campaign Raises $14 Million To Make It Harder For Citizens To Place Ballot Measures Asking For Less Power

Supporters of Prop D poured $14 million into municipal campaign coffers to raise the signature threshold for citizen initiatives from two percent to eight percent, protecting Room 200 from future voter participation.

Related: Recall culture: the school board, Boudin, Engardio, and the appointee curse
San Francisco
The Great Highway, Forever
Sunset Residents Vote to Make Great Highway a Park on Leap Years Only

Outer Sunset voters confirmed plans Wednesday for a third election to determine whether the Upper Great Highway should function as a coastal park or a parking lot for Teslas. Proponents of the compromise suggested closing the asphalt to human life on weekdays while allowing Waymo robotaxis to practice parallel parking during King Tides.

Related: Recall culture: the school board, Boudin, Engardio, and the appointee curse
San Francisco
Opinion
Potrero Hill Is Arrakis, and the Spice Is a Parking Space

Frank Herbert wrote Dune at 412 Mississippi Street, on a sunny hill where parking tickets rose at least 30% in six months. A North Slope resident argues that he who controls the curb controls the hill.

More from Opinion
San Francisco
Opinion
I've Stood Over This Shipyard Since 1947, and the Cleanup Is the Longest Thing I've Seen

The Hunters Point crane, once the world's largest, has stood over the shipyard since 1947 and watched its cleanup since 1989. In an op-ed it asks the Navy whether 2036 is a deadline or a mood.

More from Opinion
San Francisco
Four Stories Max
City Approves Final Rebuilding Permit From 1906 Fire

The Department of Building Inspection approved the last rebuilding permit from the 1906 earthquake and fire, which destroyed most of San Francisco. Staff called the 120-year review expedited and told the applicant's great-grandchildren that neighbors may still appeal.

Nearby in San Francisco
San Francisco
Doom Loop / Boom Loop
Amodei: 'Stop Me Before I Raise $64 Billion'

Anthropic chief Dario Amodei, who said in September the industry needs to slow down, is raising up to $64.4 billion. He asked his underwriters to stop him, and they added the plea to the risk factors.

Nearby in San Francisco
San FranciscoCalifornia

The doom loop is over. The invoice is a $6,000 two-bedroom.

San Francisco front page
Satire

The San Francisco paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. Every quote is made up, no real official is quoted, and yes, the vacancy rate is the real one.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.